321 vs Bulldogs

[hobbo1]

3 Stefano 2 Blore 1 Brooks

3 Brooks 2 Mbye 1 Nofa

80 mins
16 runs for 83m
A 40/20
1 try assist
8 tackle busts and an offload
23 tackles
2 missed
2 errors
13 kicks for 364m

Get over the Brooks bashing mate. Pick on the blokes not having a go.

The argument will be the attack is clunky and sideways. That’s on individuals to grow a set and run with some heart.

But as long as you ask, he threw up the usual crap - except for the 40/20. Which, btw, was such an anomaly, even for him, that he proceeded to give them the ball straight back with a dumb error. One he compounded only moments later.
If you think those stats make him look good then mate you are simply out of touch with reality.

Serious Brooks votes- it **is** a joke.

Our 6 , 7 and especially the 9 are awful.
Doueihi has the makings of a good footballer just not sure what position tbh .. The other 2 have had more than enough chances ..

 

[Droppy]

3 Stefano 2 Blore 1 Brooks

3 Brooks 2 Mbye 1 Nofa

80 mins
16 runs for 83m
A 40/20
1 try assist
8 tackle busts and an offload
23 tackles
2 missed
2 errors
13 kicks for 364m

Get over the Brooks bashing mate. Pick on the blokes not having a go.

The argument will be the attack is clunky and sideways. That’s on individuals to grow a set and run with some heart.

But as long as you ask, he threw up the usual crap - except for the 40/20. Which, btw, was such an anomaly, even for him, that he proceeded to give them the ball straight back with a dumb error. One he compounded only moments later.
If you think those stats make him look good then mate you are simply out of touch with reality.

Serious Brooks votes- it **is** a joke.

Our 6 , 7 and especially the 9 are awful.
Doueihi has the makings of a good footballer just not sure what position tbh .. The other 2 have had more than enough chances ..

Agree. Time to part ways with those two & a few others.

 

[bigsiro]

3 Stefano 2 Blore 1 Brooks

3 Brooks 2 Mbye 1 Nofa

80 mins
16 runs for 83m
A 40/20
1 try assist
8 tackle busts and an offload
23 tackles
2 missed
2 errors
13 kicks for 364m

Get over the Brooks bashing mate. Pick on the blokes not having a go.

The argument will be the attack is clunky and sideways. That’s on individuals to grow a set and run with some heart.

But as long as you ask, he threw up the usual crap - except for the 40/20. Which, btw, was such an anomaly, even for him, that he proceeded to give them the ball straight back with a dumb error. One he compounded only moments later.
If you think those stats make him look good then mate you are simply out of touch with reality.

Serious Brooks votes- it **is** a joke.

Our 6 , 7 and especially the 9 are awful.
Doueihi has the makings of a good footballer just not sure what position tbh .. The other 2 have had more than enough chances ..

Agree re Douehi. If we had a 6 he’d be a good centre - Wighton style.
Where have his awesome torpedos gone? No idea why he only had license to do that for two weeks.

 

[colinbh]

I struggle to understand how anyone gives Adam D points today. He was terrible. Just a complete handbrake of a player

Definitely a few ahead of him in today’s game. He wasn’t completely terrible but he wasn’t good either


Not one of our best, two weeks in a row now

I do not know what game you were watching but ad ran straight and hard, a try assist and 6 out of 6 goals. Not to sure what else he could do to please you.

1 Steph

2 Chee Kam

3 AD

Mamo, Lucy and Twal also went ok.

Brooks had his moments, both good and bad. Tackled great though.

 

[Speed2burn]

I struggle to understand how anyone gives Adam D points today. He was terrible. Just a complete handbrake of a player

Definitely a few ahead of him in today’s game. He wasn’t completely terrible but he wasn’t good either


Not one of our best, two weeks in a row now

I do not know what game you were watching but ad ran straight and hard, a try assist and 6 out of 6 goals. Not to sure what else he could do to please you.

1 Steph

2 Chee Kam

3 AD

Mamo, Lucy and Twal also went ok.

Brooks had his moments, both good and bad. Tackled great though.

He needs to pick his moments better

I thought he bombed a couple opportunities hitting chee kam short when our winger was wide open

Runs a lot when he should be passing

Individually his stats might look ok but to the detriment of the team

 

[bathursttiger1]

3 Utoikamanu
2 Maumalo
1 Blore

 

[Needaname]

Blore's not just a consistent tackler, he's really strong in the tackle and slows the speed of the ruck. He's a beast. Not seen someone like him for us defensively since Ellis. Great game, really promising player.

Doueihi is confused at the moment, the backline is all over the place running into each other and passing to no one. He's not too slow, he's just out of sorts.

Laterally he is slow. No zip to worry defences.

 

[Needaname]

1 Stefano.

No idea who to give the points too apart from that.

Blore deserves a special mention for playing his best game in first grade.

Glad Blore is finally getting solid game time

Looking the goods

Madge took too long to give him his start. He is Better than Garner

I don't have the same type of jitters when players run at Blore - he puts them on the deck.

Blore and Stefano are solid as. Blore hurts in defence. You can see the change in Stefano after the SOO camp. He was good before, even better now. A couple more like these two and this will be a top 8 squad.

If they have so much cap space this year Stefano should be extended now for another
2 years and pay him a big bonus out of this year's cap

That’s one way to do it.

 

[rihannafan1]

Good to see Blore get through a full game even if he was invisible for the final 60 minutes.

 

[Mountain_Man]

3 Utoikamnau
2 Maumalo
1 Blore

Watched game on replay. Most Tigers players had some good moments but consistency of effort and concentration across 80 minutes is a problem. Defensive line struggles if opposition gets a quick play the ball. Having some tall outside backs is useful. Win was scratchy but still feels better than a loss.

 

[jrtiger]

3 Stefano 2 Blore 1 Brooks

3 Brooks 2 Mbye 1 Nofa

80 mins
16 runs for 83m
A 40/20
1 try assist
8 tackle busts and an offload
23 tackles
2 missed
2 errors
13 kicks for 364m

Get over the Brooks bashing mate. Pick on the blokes not having a go.

The argument will be the attack is clunky and sideways. That’s on individuals to grow a set and run with some heart.

But as long as you ask, he threw up the usual crap - except for the 40/20. Which, btw, was such an anomaly, even for him, that he proceeded to give them the ball straight back with a dumb error. One he compounded only moments later.
If you think those stats make him look good then mate you are simply out of touch with reality.

Serious Brooks votes- it **is** a joke.

Our 6 , 7 and especially the 9 are awful.
Doueihi has the makings of a good footballer just not sure what position tbh .. The other 2 have had more than enough chances ..

Brooks has been very very poor these past two weeks. before that he was one of our better performers. Liddle looks gassed, probably due to the fact that it's his first full season of NRL and Madge is doing him absolutely no favours with no Simpkin on the bench to alleviate the workload.

Doueihi has been brilliant this year, but has been poor these past two weeks. hopefully he turns it around and finishes the year strong.

 

[cktiger]

3 Stefano 2 Blore 1 Brooks

3 Brooks 2 Mbye 1 Nofa

80 mins
16 runs for 83m
A 40/20
1 try assist
8 tackle busts and an offload
23 tackles
2 missed
2 errors
13 kicks for 364m

Get over the Brooks bashing mate. Pick on the blokes not having a go.

The argument will be the attack is clunky and sideways. That’s on individuals to grow a set and run with some heart.

But as long as you ask, he threw up the usual crap - except for the 40/20. Which, btw, was such an anomaly, even for him, that he proceeded to give them the ball straight back with a dumb error. One he compounded only moments later.
If you think those stats make him look good then mate you are simply out of touch with reality.

Serious Brooks votes- it **is** a joke.

Our 6 , 7 and especially the 9 are awful.
Doueihi has the makings of a good footballer just not sure what position tbh .. The other 2 have had more than enough chances ..

Brooks has been very very poor these past two weeks. before that he was one of our better performers. Liddle looks gassed, probably due to the fact that it's his first full season of NRL and Madge is doing him absolutely no favours with no Simpkin on the bench to alleviate the workload.

Doueihi has been brilliant this year, but has been poor these past two weeks. hopefully he turns it around and finishes the year strong.

Look how poor the opposition were... a good half and hooker would have torn them to pieces.
I tipped Brooks to have a rare good game (because of the opposition) but he let everyone down again.
Putting up his half baked stats against such a rubbish team as the Bulldogs doesn't show how he has zero clue how to set the attack or how many dumb things he does.
Liddle seems to be getting weaker instead of stronger with the extra game time.
Now having a hard time getting to the play the balls, mixed with bad pass selection and plain terrible passing.

 

[TrueTiger]

3 Stefano 2 Blore 1 Brooks

3 Brooks 2 Mbye 1 Nofa

80 mins
16 runs for 83m
A 40/20
1 try assist
8 tackle busts and an offload
23 tackles
2 missed
2 errors
13 kicks for 364m

Get over the Brooks bashing mate. Pick on the blokes not having a go.

The argument will be the attack is clunky and sideways. That’s on individuals to grow a set and run with some heart.

But as long as you ask, he threw up the usual crap - except for the 40/20. Which, btw, was such an anomaly, even for him, that he proceeded to give them the ball straight back with a dumb error. One he compounded only moments later.
If you think those stats make him look good then mate you are simply out of touch with reality.

Serious Brooks votes- it **is** a joke.

Our 6 , 7 and especially the 9 are awful.
Doueihi has the makings of a good footballer just not sure what position tbh .. The other 2 have had more than enough chances ..

Brooks has been very very poor these past two weeks. before that he was one of our better performers. Liddle looks gassed, probably due to the fact that it's his first full season of NRL and Madge is doing him absolutely no favours with no Simpkin on the bench to alleviate the workload.

Doueihi has been brilliant this year, but has been poor these past two weeks. hopefully he turns it around and finishes the year strong.

I dont want you to tear me to shreds jrtiger,but when Mbye was at 6 a few weeks ago,AD played very well in the centres,the backline had more ball and Brooks played his best footy.....
I dont know the answer but Moses has a heap of haters on here,yet I dont hate him because he has been shuffled all over the place because he is a versatile player just getting a job done,however he is a halves player and it shows when he plays alongside Luke....

3..LL
2..KM
1..AD

 

[Tim Sheens]

3 Stefano 2 Blore 1 Brooks

3 Brooks 2 Mbye 1 Nofa

80 mins
16 runs for 83m
A 40/20
1 try assist
8 tackle busts and an offload
23 tackles
2 missed
2 errors
13 kicks for 364m

Get over the Brooks bashing mate. Pick on the blokes not having a go.

The argument will be the attack is clunky and sideways. That’s on individuals to grow a set and run with some heart.

But as long as you ask, he threw up the usual crap - except for the 40/20. Which, btw, was such an anomaly, even for him, that he proceeded to give them the ball straight back with a dumb error. One he compounded only moments later.
If you think those stats make him look good then mate you are simply out of touch with reality.

Serious Brooks votes- it **is** a joke.

Our 6 , 7 and especially the 9 are awful.
Doueihi has the makings of a good footballer just not sure what position tbh .. The other 2 have had more than enough chances ..

Agree re Douehi. If we had a 6 he’d be a good centre - Wighton style.
Where have his awesome torpedos gone? No idea why he only had license to do that for two weeks.

Because on average those kicks don't get the same return, simple. We probably lost the Easter Monday match against the slimes because of too many of those.

They are a good addition on occasion and Adam can nail them, but that's all they are.

 

[jrtiger]

3 Stefano 2 Blore 1 Brooks

3 Brooks 2 Mbye 1 Nofa

80 mins
16 runs for 83m
A 40/20
1 try assist
8 tackle busts and an offload
23 tackles
2 missed
2 errors
13 kicks for 364m

Get over the Brooks bashing mate. Pick on the blokes not having a go.

The argument will be the attack is clunky and sideways. That’s on individuals to grow a set and run with some heart.

But as long as you ask, he threw up the usual crap - except for the 40/20. Which, btw, was such an anomaly, even for him, that he proceeded to give them the ball straight back with a dumb error. One he compounded only moments later.
If you think those stats make him look good then mate you are simply out of touch with reality.

Serious Brooks votes- it **is** a joke.

Our 6 , 7 and especially the 9 are awful.
Doueihi has the makings of a good footballer just not sure what position tbh .. The other 2 have had more than enough chances ..

Brooks has been very very poor these past two weeks. before that he was one of our better performers. Liddle looks gassed, probably due to the fact that it's his first full season of NRL and Madge is doing him absolutely no favours with no Simpkin on the bench to alleviate the workload.

Doueihi has been brilliant this year, but has been poor these past two weeks. hopefully he turns it around and finishes the year strong.

I dont want you to tear me to shreds jrtiger,but when Mbye was at 6 a few weeks ago,AD played very well in the centres,the backline had more ball and Brooks played his best footy.....
I dont know the answer but Moses has a heap of haters on here,yet I dont hate him because he has been shuffled all over the place because he is a versatile player just getting a job done,however he is a halves player and it shows when he plays alongside Luke....

3..LL
2..KM
1..AD

haha i won't tear you to shreds mate. I think M'Bye was great for us in that 6 week period but he reached a point where he clocked out for the rest of the season. he just looks as if he's happy to collect his paycheck every week at this point and hopefully make his way out at season's end.

 

[TrueTiger]

3 Stefano 2 Blore 1 Brooks

3 Brooks 2 Mbye 1 Nofa

80 mins
16 runs for 83m
A 40/20
1 try assist
8 tackle busts and an offload
23 tackles
2 missed
2 errors
13 kicks for 364m

Get over the Brooks bashing mate. Pick on the blokes not having a go.

The argument will be the attack is clunky and sideways. That’s on individuals to grow a set and run with some heart.

But as long as you ask, he threw up the usual crap - except for the 40/20. Which, btw, was such an anomaly, even for him, that he proceeded to give them the ball straight back with a dumb error. One he compounded only moments later.
If you think those stats make him look good then mate you are simply out of touch with reality.

Serious Brooks votes- it **is** a joke.

Our 6 , 7 and especially the 9 are awful.
Doueihi has the makings of a good footballer just not sure what position tbh .. The other 2 have had more than enough chances ..

Brooks has been very very poor these past two weeks. before that he was one of our better performers. Liddle looks gassed, probably due to the fact that it's his first full season of NRL and Madge is doing him absolutely no favours with no Simpkin on the bench to alleviate the workload.

Doueihi has been brilliant this year, but has been poor these past two weeks. hopefully he turns it around and finishes the year strong.

I dont want you to tear me to shreds jrtiger,but when Mbye was at 6 a few weeks ago,AD played very well in the centres,the backline had more ball and Brooks played his best footy.....
I dont know the answer but Moses has a heap of haters on here,yet I dont hate him because he has been shuffled all over the place because he is a versatile player just getting a job done,however he is a halves player and it shows when he plays alongside Luke....

3..LL
2..KM
1..AD

haha i won't tear you to shreds mate. I think M'Bye was great for us in that 6 week period but he reached a point where he clocked out for the rest of the season. he just looks as if he's happy to collect his paycheck every week at this point and hopefully make his way out at season's end.

I tend to think that Mbye should have stayed in the halves and AD in the centres until the season ends,however injuries and Mbyes versatility value was used elsewhere...thats the way it goes at the WTs we are very good at improvising without specialising...

 

[Depressed]

I only got to see the second half.
No standouts.

Cini did OK.

Cini is horrendous. Should never play first grade again.

I want him to fo well purely on the way he sticks out.

 

[Demps]

I only got to see the second half.
No standouts.

Cini did OK.

Cini is horrendous. Should never play first grade again.

I want him to fo well purely on the way he sticks out.

Yeah I don't know, I don't think we've seen enough to put a line through him.

Tommy Talau was awarded how many chances?

Worth some perseverance.

 

[Depressed]

1 Stefano.

No idea who to give the points too apart from that.

Blore deserves a special mention for playing his best game in first grade.

Glad Blore is finally getting solid game time

Looking the goods

Madge took too long to give him his start. He is Better than Garner

I don't have the same type of jitters when players run at Blore - he puts them on the deck.

Need more players like that who genuinely bend the opposition line.

Stefano's kick returns were outstanding.

Was outstanding bullcrap how long the dogs could lay on him after.

 

[Depressed]

I only got to see the second half.
No standouts.

Cini did OK.

Cini is horrendous. Should never play first grade again.

I want him to fo well purely on the way he sticks out.

Yeah I don't know, I don't think we've seen enough to put a line through him.

Tommy Talau was awarded how many chances?

Worth some perseverance.

Tommy, my god he gives me anxiety.