Adam Blair and Moses Mbye

@851 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1213837) said:
I am in a very small minority, but I thought Blair copped a lot of unfair criticism, he never missed a game in 3 years.
Sheens just wrongly used him, he was good at Melbourne before us and Brisbane after us.
Yes we over payed, but he was far from our worst signing.

Was it Sheens who told him to take 4 hitups a game?
 
@Fraze23 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214228) said:
@851 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1213837) said:
I am in a very small minority, but I thought Blair copped a lot of unfair criticism, he never missed a game in 3 years.
Sheens just wrongly used him, he was good at Melbourne before us and Brisbane after us.
Yes we over payed, but he was far from our worst signing.

Was it Sheens who told him to take 4 hitups a game?

Sheens he won us a comp, but boy he made some braindead decisions after the 2005 title
 
@Fraze23 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214228) said:
@851 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1213837) said:
I am in a very small minority, but I thought Blair copped a lot of unfair criticism, he never missed a game in 3 years.
Sheens just wrongly used him, he was good at Melbourne before us and Brisbane after us.
Yes we over payed, but he was far from our worst signing.

Was it Sheens who told him to take 4 hitups a game?

Sheens made him slim right down over the off season to stick with his light mobile pack theory. That wasn’t the player he bought or the style he had ever displayed. Loved Sheens, but he was too pig headed and it brought about his downfall.
 
@Furious1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214234) said:
@Fraze23 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214228) said:
@851 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1213837) said:
I am in a very small minority, but I thought Blair copped a lot of unfair criticism, he never missed a game in 3 years.
Sheens just wrongly used him, he was good at Melbourne before us and Brisbane after us.
Yes we over payed, but he was far from our worst signing.

Was it Sheens who told him to take 4 hitups a game?

Sheens made him slim right down over the off season to stick with his light mobile pack theory. That wasn’t the player he bought or the style he had ever displayed. Loved Sheens, but he was too pig headed and it brought about his downfall.

Ahysford at 5/8 was his downfall ?
 
@hobbo1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214237) said:
@Furious1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214234) said:
@Fraze23 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214228) said:
@851 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1213837) said:
I am in a very small minority, but I thought Blair copped a lot of unfair criticism, he never missed a game in 3 years.
Sheens just wrongly used him, he was good at Melbourne before us and Brisbane after us.
Yes we over payed, but he was far from our worst signing.

Was it Sheens who told him to take 4 hitups a game?

Sheens made him slim right down over the off season to stick with his light mobile pack theory. That wasn’t the player he bought or the style he had ever displayed. Loved Sheens, but he was too pig headed and it brought about his downfall.

Ahysford at 5/8 was his downfall ?

Danny Galea ...right up there ...Johnny Cronk ......Moltzen as NSW 7......Sheenius the Genius
 
@happy_tiger said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214242) said:
@hobbo1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214237) said:
@Furious1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214234) said:
@Fraze23 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214228) said:
@851 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1213837) said:
I am in a very small minority, but I thought Blair copped a lot of unfair criticism, he never missed a game in 3 years.
Sheens just wrongly used him, he was good at Melbourne before us and Brisbane after us.
Yes we over payed, but he was far from our worst signing.

Was it Sheens who told him to take 4 hitups a game?

Sheens made him slim right down over the off season to stick with his light mobile pack theory. That wasn’t the player he bought or the style he had ever displayed. Loved Sheens, but he was too pig headed and it brought about his downfall.

Ahysford at 5/8 was his downfall ?

Danny Galea ...right up there ...Johnny Cronk ......Moltzen as NSW 7......Sheenius the Genius

Those were Royce not sheens ?
 
@hobbo1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214245) said:
@happy_tiger said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214242) said:
@hobbo1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214237) said:
@Furious1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214234) said:
@Fraze23 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214228) said:
@851 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1213837) said:
I am in a very small minority, but I thought Blair copped a lot of unfair criticism, he never missed a game in 3 years.
Sheens just wrongly used him, he was good at Melbourne before us and Brisbane after us.
Yes we over payed, but he was far from our worst signing.

Was it Sheens who told him to take 4 hitups a game?

Sheens made him slim right down over the off season to stick with his light mobile pack theory. That wasn’t the player he bought or the style he had ever displayed. Loved Sheens, but he was too pig headed and it brought about his downfall.

Ahysford at 5/8 was his downfall ?

Danny Galea ...right up there ...Johnny Cronk ......Moltzen as NSW 7......Sheenius the Genius

Those were Royce not sheens ?

Royce was the greatest 2nd assistant coach we ever had
 
@happy_tiger said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214242) said:
@hobbo1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214237) said:
@Furious1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214234) said:
@Fraze23 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214228) said:
@851 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1213837) said:
I am in a very small minority, but I thought Blair copped a lot of unfair criticism, he never missed a game in 3 years.
Sheens just wrongly used him, he was good at Melbourne before us and Brisbane after us.
Yes we over payed, but he was far from our worst signing.

Was it Sheens who told him to take 4 hitups a game?

Sheens made him slim right down over the off season to stick with his light mobile pack theory. That wasn’t the player he bought or the style he had ever displayed. Loved Sheens, but he was too pig headed and it brought about his downfall.

Ahysford at 5/8 was his downfall ?

Danny Galea ...right up there ...Johnny Cronk ......Moltzen as NSW 7......Sheenius the Genius

Still remember the team sheet day with Danny at prop. Had to look away then back at the screen to make sure. He tried hard that game but just got completely smashed, then injured for his troubles. Poor Guy, always like the bloke.
 
@GNR4LIFE said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214118) said:
@Jedi_Tiger said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1213927) said:
agree forgot about Ballin
lol
signed by an egomaniac
Ballin and McQueen both taylor signings
Anasta was a Sheens signing
it makes Cleary signings seem ok lol

Ballin was on minimum contract. Any player on minimum contract is not even in the picture when it comes to worst ever signings. As for McQueen, he was signed by Cleary.

Ballin was definately not on minimum contract.Manly paid about 270k for his first year we paid the rest.In his 2nd year we paid it all due to JT having a massive ego which was in complete contrast to his ability
 
@hobbo1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214237) said:
@Furious1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214234) said:
@Fraze23 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214228) said:
@851 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1213837) said:
I am in a very small minority, but I thought Blair copped a lot of unfair criticism, he never missed a game in 3 years.
Sheens just wrongly used him, he was good at Melbourne before us and Brisbane after us.
Yes we over payed, but he was far from our worst signing.

Was it Sheens who told him to take 4 hitups a game?

Sheens made him slim right down over the off season to stick with his light mobile pack theory. That wasn’t the player he bought or the style he had ever displayed. Loved Sheens, but he was too pig headed and it brought about his downfall.

Ahysford at 5/8 was his downfall ?

Fitzy at five eight, wow, a winger on the bench, Johnny Cronk to replace Prince, the list is very long,
 
@hobbo1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214245) said:
@happy_tiger said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214242) said:
@hobbo1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214237) said:
@Furious1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214234) said:
@Fraze23 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214228) said:
@851 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1213837) said:
I am in a very small minority, but I thought Blair copped a lot of unfair criticism, he never missed a game in 3 years.
Sheens just wrongly used him, he was good at Melbourne before us and Brisbane after us.
Yes we over payed, but he was far from our worst signing.

Was it Sheens who told him to take 4 hitups a game?

Sheens made him slim right down over the off season to stick with his light mobile pack theory. That wasn’t the player he bought or the style he had ever displayed. Loved Sheens, but he was too pig headed and it brought about his downfall.

Ahysford at 5/8 was his downfall ?

Danny Galea ...right up there ...Johnny Cronk ......Moltzen as NSW 7......Sheenius the Genius

Those were Royce not sheens ?

You know full well it wasn’t. Royce just put the witches hats out
 
@hobbo1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214237) said:
@Furious1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214234) said:
@Fraze23 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214228) said:
@851 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1213837) said:
I am in a very small minority, but I thought Blair copped a lot of unfair criticism, he never missed a game in 3 years.
Sheens just wrongly used him, he was good at Melbourne before us and Brisbane after us.
Yes we over payed, but he was far from our worst signing.

Was it Sheens who told him to take 4 hitups a game?

Sheens made him slim right down over the off season to stick with his light mobile pack theory. That wasn’t the player he bought or the style he had ever displayed. Loved Sheens, but he was too pig headed and it brought about his downfall.

Ahysford at 5/8 was his downfall ?

He did love to make a player play out if position and frame it, Remember the Chris Lawrence - Laurie Daley comment? Almost as good as his Robbie Farah is the best half in the club and the immortal “Johnny Cronk”
 
@Furious1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1213974) said:
@formerguest said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1213972) said:
Haven't read much past the initial post, but isn't this just more to move to the lament thread.

Just about the whole forum is lament.

Well it’s hard to piss in the clubs pocket
 
@BAGNF05 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214414) said:
@Furious1 said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1213974) said:
@formerguest said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1213972) said:
Haven't read much past the initial post, but isn't this just more to move to the lament thread.

Just about the whole forum is lament.

Well it’s hard to piss in the clubs pocket

You won’t get any argument from me.
 
Well starting to think that we have a delusional coach and now it feeds down to the team.
Madge goes down on the sidelines to view the game and states afterwards we can still make the 8. Think we all new after Knights game if not prior that season was gone and we watch out of interest to see what changes should be made fir the coming season.
Now I read the Mybe thinks he is a chance of playing origin again ????
This means he would be in Walters ear stating he knows he is not in the best form but deserves an opportunity even last season I ? his selection.
As one forum member observed attending last game Mybe woujd bid put his body on the line and what I reviewed is that he kept running out of the line creating gaps and catching thin air.
If he thinks he is an Origin player it shows how delusional he is as apart from our lack of depth I scratch my head in amazement that he is selected each week.
As supporters think we are over the BS and who writes these articles just be upfront.
 
All teams and their coaches on 12 points have to say.they think they can make the eight because mathematically they can and the whole point of the competition is to make the finals.
If you want to.talk about delusional how about the fans sitting home who think they know more about the capabilities of this squad than Maguire does - now that's delusional.
 
Reading through this thread has reminded me how many shockers we've had - wow. Some of these guys were not only bad, but crippled (crippling) our team at the time and in years to follow even after their departures. They've all stemmed form bad decisions in recruitment - some completely unforeseen to be fair. Hopefully Madge is more on top of this aspect than our predecessors - goes without saying we never want to see a Blair again..
 
@Lauren said in [Adam Blair and Moses Mbye](/post/1214548) said:
If Blair is our worst buy, what would you call our current recruitment blunders?

Blair was bad but to have Reynolds, Packer, Mbye and McQueen all at the same time is far more crippling.
 

Staff online

Back
Top