The Forum has been overating players by comparing them to others in the team, that is a poor comparison. Your comments are spot on .If everyone is fairdinkum about our culture change then you have to let go of the fav players in our side...AD hasnt got the experience of Api at NRL level or played rep football at SOO or represented Australia,he may have reped for Lebanon,but thats a far cry from the NRL grind week in week out,same as Brooks...
To be honest a spoon side picking a fan favourite over a quality NRL premiership player that has a longer contract than both mentioned really astounds me and no wonder we as a team and club are where we are...first the boys club now the fan boy favs...fair dinkum...
Offa is the next best but I dont think he has the smarts that Api has...