Andrew Fifita

[Guest]

Sounds like Moors might be in the mix afterall.

 

[Blake93]

It's just a question. If the club could only keep one for financial reasons

 

[Guest]

Not an ideal thread really given the situation as it currently stands. There's room for both and at this stage I'd prefer Galloway starting, ripping in for 15-20 minutes and then have Fifita come on and do as much damage as he can for another 15 which has been the case for the last few weeks.

 

[MacDougall]

Fifita will end up the better player. At the moment they are basically equals imo.

 

[Tiger_Watto]

It's just a question. If the club could only keep one for financial reasons

ok… if the club had to make a financial decision in moving one on, Galloway is a tried and tested Prop and would get the vote. Fifita, while setting the world on fire, is still a pup...

 

[Geo]

Nah….get rid of them both and get Snowden and Petro...

 

[benjibrotown]

Fifitas better then Galloway now.. In two years Galloway won't even come close.

 

[mike]

Galloway for sure.

Fifita off the bench for impact. Give him another year and then we'll see. Galloway is a seasond prop.

 

[Granto87]

Wont ever happen Galloway and Fifita are the future… Best thing is Galloway and Fifita havent hit their prime yet & will only get better. I feel for Galloway thow as he always seems to get injured just before he hits his straps imo we havent seen the best from him yet & he is still one of the topr props in the game.

 

[Student_of_the_game]

Galloway for sure.

Fifita off the bench for impact. Give him another year and then we'll see. Galloway is a seasond prop.

"seasoned" .. what's that supposed to mean? He's been around for a few years? That's about the only thing he's got over Fifita.

Fifita > Galloway

 

[Student_of_the_game]

I think Galloway's prime was last year honestly… Injuries have affected him, he's lost his confidence and he's not as good as Fifita. I'd probably have Payten over him atm, imo.

 

[innsaneink]

Fifitas better then Galloway now.. In two years Galloway won't even come close.

Providing Fifita doesnt accumulate the same amount of injuries Kilo has
No one knows whats down the track in two years time…

 

[tiger05]

I think Galloway is the better player atm however that could change.

They both get us going forward.

 

[Blake93]

I'm very much liking our depth in the forwards this year. If mckinnon is out, i'd like to see:

1\. Brown
4\. Daniella
8\. Fifita
10\. Galloway

with moors and shirnack on the bench

 

[Bismark]

Galloway right now because he has bigger stints than Fifita, and is more level headed.

I think Fifita can/might turn into a Gibbs-style of p[layer, giving away stupid penalties and making dumb mistakes when frustrated.

 

[mike]

Galloway for sure.

Fifita off the bench for impact. Give him another year and then we'll see. Galloway is a seasond prop.

"seasoned" .. what's that supposed to mean? He's been around for a few years? That's about the only thing he's got over Fifita.

Fifita Galloway

It's called experience.

Maybe in a year or two yes but not now.

 

[red_dogg]

a great rugby league side has atleast 3 dominating front rowers we currently have 2 in fifita and galloway… we r lucky this yr cause our backrow is really helpin us out up there.... i would hate to loose one and cant see why we would have to do so.....

 

[Blake93]

Galloway right now because he has bigger stints than Fifita, and is more level headed.

I think Fifita can/might turn into a Gibbs-style of p[layer, **giving away stupid penalties and making dumb mistakes when frustrated**.

I think fifita was like that earlier in the year but once he got dropped and came back, he has cut a lot of that stupidness out of his game. I think the way he has improved from last year to these past couple weeks is amazing.

 

[system]

Galloway.

Ideally of course the answer would be both. However impact is a small part of the game and can come from many sources. A guy who has been around the traps and learnt from their rich experiences and consistantly churns over 100 metres a game is the absolute essential for any starting prop.

Worst case scenario I would choose Keith and use Dave Fifita

 

[Citizen_Tiger]

Fifita got my 2 points yesterday, just for pure impact.

Sure that Fifita's Dad/Uncle is Johnny Fifita, who played for Saints in the 70's.

http://www.findthatcard.com.au/index.php?main_page=product_info&cPath=36_61_63_137&products_id=441" onclick="window.open(this.href);return false;

Fifita's numbers against Galloway's looked good yesterday. Big Keith is just a footballer I'm afraid, his rate of improvement has been negligible over a 5 season period