Ayshford v. Lawrence as back-up five-eight?

[Tommy Magpie]

Keep Lawrence away from 5/8\. Stifles the attack.

 

[Goose]

I agree Moltz i prob the best 6, but, he doesn't respond to being moved around IMO, so if it is short term he should stay at fullback, we seem to play better with Aysh at 5/8 than Lawrence, with Moltz filling in a with a bit of ball playing

 

[MacDougall]

Ayshford doesn't pass enough to be so close to the ruck.

 

[hellman]

I'd prefer (in injury crisis)

1\. Ryan

6\. Moltzen
7\. Benji

with Chris & Blake staying in the regular positions.
Honestly think that'd be our strongest option instead of playing Blake or Chris @ 5/8th.

I like this the best.

 

[bythebeardofzeus]

I agree Moltz i prob the best 6, but, he doesn't respond to being moved around IMO, so if it is short term he should stay at fullback, we seem to play better with Aysh at 5/8 than Lawrence, with Moltz filling in a with a bit of ball playing

Agreed. If it was long term def move beau to fb, moltz to 5/8, with Chris & Aysh staying in the centres.

Looking forward to the return of Siro, Ellis & the Cashman!!
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_

 

[Gray]

Too classy centres to waste in the halves. Especially with a player whose favoured position is Half there aswell?

Be definitely good too see Ellis back for his last few games for the Tigs!

 

[sunshine_coast_tiger]

For mine if Sironen is injured we have to play:

6\. Marshall
7\. Miller (give him another go, he is a better half than Ashyford or Lawrence).

 

[gazroc]

Neither they are both terrible no 6s humble or molts at 7 benji at 6 will do me or any combo of the three

I totally agree, we wasted several seasons trying to make one the games best ever five eights into a halfback and now we are doing it again. I have had enough! Humble or Masada at half and Marshall at no 6\. However, it would not have mattered tonight who played where, our attitude in defense was appalling, line speed was not there, sliding defense none existent, the only highlight was seeing Robbie Farah in the form that will see the Blue's take the trophy.

 

[JoshTheNewcastleFan]

Why on earth would you have either there? Honestly, coming from a non Tigers supporter it seems to be one of the most dumbest selections putting a freakin centre at five-eighth when you could just put Moltzen there who is a playmaker & have Ryan at fullback, Ryan is awesome there.

 

[gazroc]

Why on earth would you have either there? Honestly, coming from a non Tigers supporter it seems to be one of the most dumbest selections putting a freakin centre at five-eighth when you could just put Moltzen there who is a playmaker & have Ryan at fullback, Ryan is awesome there.

Mate, it wouldn't not have mattered tonight, the Tigers defensive effort was appalling and I won't argue with you there about Ryan, he is best on the wing or at fullback. As for a number 7 we had $500,000 a year to spend on someone but we bought a forward with about as much line penetration as a bloke with 2 inch love pole.

 

[stryker]

Why on earth would you have either there? Honestly, coming from a non Tigers supporter it seems to be one of the most dumbest selections putting a freakin centre at five-eighth when you could just put Moltzen there who is a playmaker & have Ryan at fullback, Ryan is awesome there.

Dont know Josh…you are not the first opposition fan to mention this. Most on here would agree with this as well.
Tim rarely settles on his final lineup this early in the season.

 

[Irvine]

Why on earth would you have either there? Honestly, coming from a non Tigers supporter it seems to be one of the most dumbest selections putting a freakin centre at five-eighth when you could just put Moltzen there who is a playmaker & have Ryan at fullback, Ryan is awesome there.

Welcome to our world.