Both of them played absolutely terrible tonight. Lui's defense is a huge liability, he let in at least 2 tries tonight (correct me if i'm wrong) and beau….well there's no words for how he played. Find someone else for halfback, move brown to the wing and once mckinnon is back, drop ryan. I know he tries and his enthusiasm is fantastic for the team but he practically cost us the game tonight. Thoughts?
CAN WE PLEASE GET RID OF LUI AND RYAN!
- Thread starter Blake93
- Start date
Tigerstripes
New member
Ryan has been pretty fantastic all season and he can be allowed a shocker of a game.
His attitude is right and he will be bounce back from this. No one will be more disappointed about tonight's performance than Beau,
His attitude is right and he will be bounce back from this. No one will be more disappointed about tonight's performance than Beau,
Hard to argue on the evidence shown tonight. Lote wasn't much better though. Two tries were the result of him not being urgent or focussed enough on getting to the ball.
shiretiger
Well-known member
@mattc78 said:
Remember the Roosters game at Cambo?????
Ryan reminds me of a Justin Hodges QLD performance, wwhere he gave us 2 tries!
That doesn't mean Hodges is a crap player now, does it? Same with Ryan, true he needs practise under the highball and he had a terrible game but that happens in sport, I'm sure he would have been pulled off the field if Lawrence wasn't injured.
Lui is growing in attack every game, but he needs some kind of remedial defensive training. That first try….are you kidding? I don't care if he's 19, your a first grade halfback for a well positioned team, learn to tackle.
That doesn't mean Hodges is a crap player now, does it? Same with Ryan, true he needs practise under the highball and he had a terrible game but that happens in sport, I'm sure he would have been pulled off the field if Lawrence wasn't injured.
Lui is growing in attack every game, but he needs some kind of remedial defensive training. That first try….are you kidding? I don't care if he's 19, your a first grade halfback for a well positioned team, learn to tackle.
Newy_Tiger
New member
@Bismark said:
Couldnt have said it better myself mate.
Lui was ok. Needs to involve himself a little more. Tell Farah to stay at hooker and push Benji out sometimes. His defence isn't a massive issue for a halfback of his age. That 1st try occurred because Lawrence was at marker. The rookie centre stood up Lui and Tuqiri watched from over the sidelines.
Beau was poor put we haven't said that too many times before. That try after half-time was freakish and it was only a matter of time before the hit back into the field cost a side. It was a mistake that was always going to happen to a fill in.
Beau was poor put we haven't said that too many times before. That try after half-time was freakish and it was only a matter of time before the hit back into the field cost a side. It was a mistake that was always going to happen to a fill in.
Some individual performances really cost us tonight.
Beau Ryan is not a First grader. He makes really bad individual, unforced errors right through his career. Tonight he was so bad it was just incredible. Tuqiri was not far behind him tonight, he was woeful. No urgency on kicks. Marshall did some good things but some utterly selfish things. Lui is just not up to it, a a turnstyle. I Don't want to bag Farah too much because you can tll he hurts after losses more then most. However going on twitter and spruking his new restaurant all week, its just dumb. I know people have other things in their lives and its just a game, however it makes thm look distracted and brings them in for some heat when they produce efforts like this.
Less footy show and twitter and half baked efforts and we might have a chance to turn it around. In our current mood 4 losses are a moral. Heighto and Ellis, i feel for those blokes.
Some of these guys have big profiles and big egos but they can't produce. Seriously
Beau Ryan is not a First grader. He makes really bad individual, unforced errors right through his career. Tonight he was so bad it was just incredible. Tuqiri was not far behind him tonight, he was woeful. No urgency on kicks. Marshall did some good things but some utterly selfish things. Lui is just not up to it, a a turnstyle. I Don't want to bag Farah too much because you can tll he hurts after losses more then most. However going on twitter and spruking his new restaurant all week, its just dumb. I know people have other things in their lives and its just a game, however it makes thm look distracted and brings them in for some heat when they produce efforts like this.
Less footy show and twitter and half baked efforts and we might have a chance to turn it around. In our current mood 4 losses are a moral. Heighto and Ellis, i feel for those blokes.
Some of these guys have big profiles and big egos but they can't produce. Seriously
Staff online
-
DempsModerator
Members online
- Bruiser
- KH1988
- Tiger_Yoshi
- BunganHead Tiger
- Tigerbenb
- hank37w
- Federals
- 426Tlgerland
- Tiger4life43
- simonsatiger
- tigahhh
- Harvey
- Wagga_Tiger
- Charred
- tigerballs
- George Piper's #1 fan
- Bus 2 Terrigal
- BalmainBoy67
- old_man_tiger
- Lukic
- diedpretty
- Hargreaves
- Jolls
- Mighty_Tiger
- ATown
- tigeress
- tigerbenji
- RonDingo
- bomberbrown
- Razorback
- Bula
- 88
- 1eyetiger
- The_Patriot
- Mando Tiger
- Demps
- goldeneye
- Red88_Tiger
- tiger_one
- Siberian Kitten