Coach Benji 👑

Winston Churchill said:
Moments like this make you wish Potter was still at the club. Not because he'd necessarily have the guts to drop Luai and Doueihi but because he'd have the guts to drop Benji too.

This side has no accountability. Right now, Benji looks like a coach who's completely out of his depth.

Weak selections. Weak standards. Weak leadership. The Tigers fans deserve better.
Click to expand...
Potter got such a raw deal when he was here. He had us on track for finals in 2014 until Farah decided to tank the season by mouthing off to Tallis. Payten was also actively trying to whiteant him as well.

Potter would be a great assistant but Benji’s bruised ego would never allow it after Potter was the one to bench him and break up the original boys club.
 
You Know Who said:
Potter got such a raw deal when he was here. He had us on track for finals in 2014 until Farah decided to tank the season by mouthing off to Tallis. Payten was also actively trying to whiteant him as well.

Potter would be a great assistant but Benji’s bruised ego would never allow it after Potter was the one to bench him and break up the original boys club.
Click to expand...
He did well as a quick fix after D Pay ? left the dogs .Tim the weather man shafted him also back in the day
 
Winston Churchill said:
Moments like this make you wish Potter was still at the club. Not because he'd necessarily have the guts to drop Luai and Doueihi but because he'd have the guts to drop Benji too.

This side has no accountability. Right now, Benji looks like a coach who's completely out of his depth.

Weak selections. Weak standards. Weak leadership. The Tigers fans deserve better.
Click to expand...
Has been out of his depth since appointment. Clueless coach. Now laughing stock of NRL world.
 
Droppy05 said:
Has been out of his depth since appointment. Clueless coach. Now laughing stock of NRL world.
Click to expand...
This is what happens when appointments are driven by sentiment instead of proven coaching credentials. Benji was fast tracked through the Sheens succession plan as one of the club's own, and the results have been exactly what many feared. The Tigers are paying the price for choosing nostalgia over merit. Every week the standards slip further, the same mistakes are repeated, and the club becomes an even bigger punchline across the NRL. Fans have been told for 15 years (2 generations of playing careers) to trust the process. Instead, they've watched the club drift backwards while top teams move further forward. Patience has long since turned into complacency.
 
Ive been thinking about the notion that Marshall plays favourites.
Personally, I think that its natural and not a problem as long as it falls within agreed performance standards. It comes with the territory when leading a group of people, all of whom are individuals with their own quirks.
You are always going to have some individuals that are reliable and motivated, and they will get the easiest level of supervision. Others will have to be supervised more closely and often not given the same level of freedom in decision making.
If favouring one player over another does not fall within agreed performance standards, you're introducing a recipe for failure. I dont know which applies here.
 
NT_Tiger said:
Ive been thinking about the notion that Marshall plays favourites.
Personally, I think that its natural and not a problem as long as it falls within agreed performance standards. It comes with the territory when leading a group of people, all of whom are individuals with their own quirks.
You are always going to have some individuals that are reliable and motivated, and they will get the easiest level of supervision. Others will have to be supervised more closely and often not given the same level of freedom in decision making.
If favouring one player over another does not fall within agreed performance standards, you're introducing a recipe for failure. I dont know which applies here.
Click to expand...
From the get go Benji appeared to have this idea that a group would perform better if members of the group competed with each other.
From day one he divided the group into old vs young players.

Don’t understand why the club re-signed Doueihi in March after he and his agent were so disruptive over the off season?
The bottom line is pretty much the whole team is not performing to the best of their ability and that’s a major concern.
The Raiders game was so disappointing.
I realise Moses wanted to highlight via his scribe Kenty that Terrell missed a tackle while he was arguing with the ref., but for me the lowlight of the game was Bula missing that tackle on Weekes. He had him for pace! Bula is always arriving late these days.
 
https://weststigersforum.com/threads/sack-marshall.35738/post-1988508

My take from August 2024:

My take at the time Benji was appointed that it was a classic "look over there" stunt to take the heat off management for spoon #2.

We were all looking forward to fairy tale ending with a Benji inspired and lead turn around of the team that we love but deep down we were expecting the mother of all train wrecks, bodies everywhere, the gnashing of teeth and endless tears.

Well here we are with spoon #3.

I cant say that I am exactly surprised.

The question though in my mind is Benji to blame for where our team sits on the ladder?

Had we had a magic wand and lets say Bellamy (or whichever super coach is your particular flavour) was appointed coach last year instead, with this roster, would things have ended up differently?

Will 2025 be any different? It is too early for me to answer that question.

I pine for the days that we finished 9th.
Click to expand...

Two years down the track from that post, I still pine for 9th.

I'm not convinced Benji is the answer.

That being said, I don't think it is all his fault.

I am still convinced that if you had the magic wand and could appoint whatever super coach you desired, that this organisation is so disfunctional, so broken - from Board level to coaching and playing level - that we are basically beyond redemption.

Such a super coach I don't believe could make a difference.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 3,773 (members: 44, guests: 3,729)
Back
Top