I'll leave the ill informed opinions to you, champ.
You can forgive me for not gushing over this guys performances, because it's the first time in a now 9 year international career that he hasn't been useless, but lets be realistic about it. He is a test opener who in 9 tests has one century. All these plaudits about being our best player because he finally isn't being awful are way over the top.
The thing about Watson is that he bats the same way in Test, ODI and T20 cricket. He has yet to prove he can tough it out and bat a day and a half if needed, he has yet to face an attack that has it's stuff together and he still has a very big technical flaw in regard to LBW.
Alot, and I do mean ALOT of players have had to make way for this guy to be shoehorned into the side over the years, so really in the scheme of things, he is doing the bare minimum in regards to the treatment and favouritism he has been shown. I'm yet to be convinced.
And yes I just checked it. He is the first batsman to win the AB medal for only a single test hundred. WOW!
I think you're in denial SunTan.
Sehwag bats the same in odis and Tests, so did Gilly.
He may of copped some favouritism, but thats because of the potential that everyone saw in him that is starting to show now, you look at his first class stats, he averages around 45 with the bat (More then North and Clarke) and 30 odd with the ball, so you cant really say he didnt earn his spot.
And what about the wickets in all forms of the game, the slips catches, the match winning 100s in the semis and final of the champions trophy and another 2 odi 100s earlier in the year?
Every batsman has technical floors, Katich playing away from his body, Hughes with the short ones, Ponting with his front foot getting in the way of his bat (And recently the short ball), Hussey with his off stump, Clarke half pushing at deliveries outside off stump, and North with the ball at the body and the full wide deliveries, etc. I know Watson has had probs with LBW in the past but id like to know how often Watson has been dismissed LBW this Summer, because I dont think it has been many
And he may of been the first 'batsmen' to win the AB medal, but he is also the first 'Allrounder' to win it too!
Sehwag and Gilchrist are/were hundred makers, Watson isn't.
Unlike those other batsmen and their flaws, they have proven themselves in pretty much all environments. Watson has yet to prove he can bat against anything other than short and wide pitched crap.
If you think the last 3 months of solid, consistent form makes up for the previous 7 years of inept failure, then good luck to you. I'll just wait and see if he can perform against sides that aren't completely stuffed before I hail his arrival.