David Klemmer #264

@ricksen said:
@Milky said:
@happy tiger said:
@jirskyr said:
Well if TigerTorch is right and we had a big contract to offer Klemmer, hopefully that money can still be spent elsewhere.

I am not a fan of overpaying for props, I think you get great mileage out of 1 elite prop plus a bunch of cheaper hard heads.

Now a rep-level centre - that has my interest.

How many of the rep centres will actually be centres ??

We don't need any backs

Simona/Carr
Naiqama/Nofa

Is a pretty striking backline

It really isn't - half of them wouldn't get a run at most other NRL clubs.
That said, I'd rather the money was spent on a backrower or two than a prop.

Yeah its really not an outstanding backline. On its day yes but otherwise we have, by a long long way, the smallest backline in the league. Many of whom are suspect in defence, under the high ball and are prone to making poor decisions (or no decision).

Same goes for the back row, injury prone, mistake riddled, poor decision making players.

You can only carry so many of those players in a team, as of course not everyone can be an elite player.
 
@Balmain Boy said:
Yeah its really not an outstanding backline. On its day yes but otherwise we have, by a long long way, the smallest backline in the league. Many of whom are suspect in defence, under the high ball and are prone to making poor decisions (or no decision).

Same goes for the back row, injury prone, mistake riddled, poor decision making players.

You can only carry so many of those players in a team, as of course not everyone can be an elite player.

Yep.
We have too many questions marks across the squad - guys that can turn it on now and then, but also capable of terrible ineptitude on their day. Others that have plenty of the lows without the highs.
The top teams these days have rep quality for around half of their 17, and consistent performers for the rest.
 
Josh Aloiai hasn't shown anything to suggest that he'll make it in the NRL? The games that I've watched at the ground have shown to me that he'll be a very good NRL forward and has earned his place already with his aggressive play. Maybe a bit too religious but I can overlook that while he develops further.
 
It's a shame. Klemmer is pretty much exactly what we need. A nutter who plays the game hard and tough and hits people. Anyone who would turn him down is nuts.
 
@happy tiger said:
@innsaneink said:
Signed with dogs for three more

As did Moses Mbye

So much for Woods being Klemmer's bestie /bffl

Means sweet nothing in the real world

But but but we thought we had hi…never mind...

Can we move onto Josh Jackson instead...
 
@Milky said:
@happy tiger said:
@jirskyr said:
Well if TigerTorch is right and we had a big contract to offer Klemmer, hopefully that money can still be spent elsewhere.

I am not a fan of overpaying for props, I think you get great mileage out of 1 elite prop plus a bunch of cheaper hard heads.

Now a rep-level centre - that has my interest.

How many of the rep centres will actually be centres ??

We don't need any backs

Simona/Carr
Naiqama/Nofa

Is a pretty striking backline, what we need to do is completely scratch our 8-17 with the exception of a few players and then we will see results.

Until our forward pack is competing forget the backs, even if we had Mansour on one wing and Izzy on the other, we would still lose.

We have just about the worst forward pack in the game, until tough calls are made and the likes of Halatau and Buchanan are gone wsaid will continue to be dominated.

8\. Woods
9.
10\. Grant
11\. Lawrence
12\. Sue
13.

14\. Ava
15.
16.
17.

The unfilled numbers need to come from outside of the club, at the moment i have seen nothing from Aloai to suggest he is up to it, same with the rest of the players i have left out. Peats and Segeyaro would easily slot into our hooking position but unfortunatley the club is commited to developing juniors and signing 30 year old nuffies.

Our backline is bog average. There are far better options out there then Kev, Nofa and even Simona.
 
@GNR4LIFE said:
@Milky said:
@happy tiger said:
@jirskyr said:
Well if TigerTorch is right and we had a big contract to offer Klemmer, hopefully that money can still be spent elsewhere.

I am not a fan of overpaying for props, I think you get great mileage out of 1 elite prop plus a bunch of cheaper hard heads.

Now a rep-level centre - that has my interest.

How many of the rep centres will actually be centres ??

We don't need any backs

Simona/Carr
Naiqama/Nofa

Is a pretty striking backline, what we need to do is completely scratch our 8-17 with the exception of a few players and then we will see results.

Until our forward pack is competing forget the backs, even if we had Mansour on one wing and Izzy on the other, we would still lose.

We have just about the worst forward pack in the game, until tough calls are made and the likes of Halatau and Buchanan are gone wsaid will continue to be dominated.

8\. Woods
9.
10\. Grant
11\. Lawrence
12\. Sue
13.

14\. Ava
15.
16.
17.

The unfilled numbers need to come from outside of the club, at the moment i have seen nothing from Aloai to suggest he is up to it, same with the rest of the players i have left out. Peats and Segeyaro would easily slot into our hooking position but unfortunatley the club is commited to developing juniors and signing 30 year old nuffies.

Our backline is bog average. There are far better options out there then Kev, Nofa and even Simona.

True
 
I said Klemmer was never coming. His sister had no reason to lie and say he was staying. Anyone who thought he was coming here just because he's mates with Woods had rocks in their heads.
 
http://www.smh.com.au/rugby-league/state-of-origin/state-of-origin-2016-david-klemmer-almost-left-bulldogs-to-join-aaron-woods-at-wests-tigers-20160530-gp7532.html
\
\
\
NSW prop David Klemmer has revealed how close he came to joining the Wests Tigers after an attempt from best mate Aaron Woods to lure him away from Canterbury earlier in the season.
Woods and Klemmer, strangers before the 2014 City-Country game, have since become the closest of friends and have been inseparable in the past two NSW Origin camps, having been paired together as roommates.
Klemmer, who negotiated his own contract with the Bulldogs before signing a four-year deal with the club ths month, held several discussions with Woods about joining the joint venture club.
Bond: NSW teammates Aaron Woods (left) and David Klemmer have been roommates during the past two Origin camps.
Bond: NSW teammates Aaron Woods (left) and David Klemmer have been roommates during the past two Origin camps. Photo: Janie Barrett
While the 22-year-old wouldn't have been able to land the type of money at the Tigers that he did at Canterbury with a deal in excess of $2 million for four years, Klemmer says he gave genuine thought to the possibility of leaving the Bulldogs to link with Woods.
"Me and him had a yarn about it. There was an option there to go to the Tigers," Klemmer told Fairfax Media ahead of Wednesday night's State of Origin series opener at ANZ Stadium.
"I really had a deep discussion with my family and my missus most importantly, and we had to make the right decision to help me progress forward. Me and Woodsy have always spoken and joked about it, saying 'imagine playing with each other'. He just said 'how good would it be, we'll see each other everyday, we'll get married and run off'.
Friendly rivals: David Klemmer is held up over the line by Aaron Woods.
Friendly rivals: David Klemmer is held up over the line by Aaron Woods. Photo: Mark Kolbe
"It was tempting, I'm not going to lie. He's one of my closest mates if not my best mate. It was very tempting to go over there and play with him, but I've been a Bulldogs supporter since I was a kid. It would have been very hard to leave the club I've supported since I was a little boy."
While the Tigers captain was hopeful of negotiating one of the biggest coups in the club's short history, he didn't heap pressure on Klemmer to turn his back on the Bulldogs.
So close have the pair become, they recently had coffee at a Belmore cafe with Bulldogs five-eighth Josh Reynolds and Tigers hooker Robbie Farah just a few days before they squared off at ANZ Stadium in round 10.
Brothers in arms: David Klemmer and Aaron Woods sing the national anthem with Will Hopoate before game one of the 2015 …
Brothers in arms: David Klemmer and Aaron Woods sing the national anthem with Will Hopoate before game one of the 2015 State of Origin series. Photo: Mark Kolbe
Despite Klemmer, who will start on the bench on Wednesday night, turning down Woods' bid to lure him to the Tigers, there's no hard feelings shared between the pair.
"With players like that, you'd love to have at your club," Woods said.
"I told him we'd love to have him, but we just might not have enough money for you. I just threw it out there and said 'if you're keen, I can talk to people at the club, but if not it's all good, it's not going to change our friendship'.
"He's got a little family to look after as well, so it's awesome to see him locked up at the Bulldogs for four years."
Klemmer, who this year shared a room in the Blues' Coffs Harbour camp with Woods and Farah, has no doubts over his decision to re-sign with Canterbury.
He insists Woods was happy for him when he informed the Tigers prop that he would be staying at Belmore, knowing exactly what it would mean for Klemmer, his partner and his two young boys.
"Honestly, he was happy for me," Klemmer said.
"I've got two kids I have to look after. He was happy for me because he knows it's a business. It's a business, too, so you have to look after yourself and make sure you go there everyday happy. I'm happy I made the right decision."
 
I don't see it as a big loss. We have a bunch of forwards who can play up the middle at this point. On the right dollars he would be great though.
 
Oh damn. Would have loved him here

One of the biggest motors in the game..I can't remember the last player who can run into a line and keep his legs pumping like he does
 

Latest posts

Back
Top