Did Bellamy know!!!

@TigerDave81 said:
Not questioning slater, I think he is a champion player. I'm more questioning Bellamy, the integrity of the voting for the dally m and the spin the storm have done for "resting" slater and smith on the weekend, Happy Tiger.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED

Bellamy has form :imp: :imp:
 
@TigerDave81 said:
Not questioning slater, I think he is a champion player. I'm more questioning Bellamy, the integrity of the voting for the dally m and the spin the storm have done for "resting" slater and smith on the weekend, Happy Tiger.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED

I would be extremely surprised if Melbourne had got the word
there would of been a massive betting plunge if they had knew
Much like what happened with the wooden spoon thing last year on the betting market
 
So let's say the storm game was on Friday, would they of played him then due to not knowing Benji polled 0 in sharks game, would he of played then?
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 
Slater. A red hot chance of winning the daily m with 1 round to go, the best individual award in the NRL, and the coach "rests you" for the good of the team!!!

If slater had of lost by 1 point tonight because he was "rested" how do you think slater would have felt!!! If it was me I would be pissed. It would cause more harm than good IMO!!

Bellamy would not rob his best player that opportunity without knowing it was already locked up!!

If that was the case why didn't he rest cronk for 1 last game!!! Because he was still a chance of getting 3 points and tying with slater!!! What's better than having 1 player in your team win the daily m!!! Have 2 win it!!!

Watch all the positive media Melbourne get tomorrow after cleaning up tonight. How the pain of last year has come full circle!!!!

The more I think about it/post about it, the clearer it's becoming. If Phil Rothfield gets a wiff of this thread, it might be the first time he writes a half decent article. Lol!!!
\
\
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 
@TigerBoy33 said:
So let's say the storm game was on Friday, would they of played him then due to not knowing Benji polled 0 in sharks game, would he of played then?
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED

Yeah for sure…but not for the Dally M. Manly were still a chance of gaining the Minor Premiership. If Melbourne played Fri night they would have sent their best side out.

As the MP was already locked up by Sun night they rested them...
 
Wow, is it such a stretch to think that the Storm had the MP wrapped up and had nothing to play for, therefore, thought it would be a good idea to rest their 2 most valueble players??? of course it is :crazy Some people obviously just can't accept Benji may have been beaten fair and square, so they are letting their bitterness control their emotions

I guarentee if it were the other way around and it had been the Tigers who had the MP wrapped up, rested Marshall and he won the way Slater did, and had Storm supporters calling for conspiracy theories we'd be scoffing
 
The Storm & Bellamy should be put in jail… They even forged voting slips to ensure Julia Gillard remained PM. It's simply a joke... Where will it end? :bawling :bawling :bawling
 
My concern with the Dally Ms is that they have allways been fixed i stopped watching it years ago when Dave Fairleigh won it his pts got leaked out and people made thousands out of it ,so it does not surprise me that the dirtiest coach of the year pain in the arse(bellamy). Now i sat down to watch the DM last night coco and slippers on and it was the 1st time i had watched them since robbie got dudded you would all remember that last game of the year thurston had to get 3 pts out of there last game in tville well for memory he played 30 minutes the coach took him off they got beaten and surprise surprise thurston got 3 pts and beat robbie, so when the cheats were going up and down getting the Ms i thought rewarding the cheats for there season was a joke, my other [This word has been automatically removed] we are on a winning streak 8 games now can someone tell me how many pts benji made out of them please if he didnt get 3 pts for each game how come he didnt at least get 2 or 1 even just like cronk and slater were sharing there pts i think benji may have gotten 9 pts all up over the last 8 games and to me thats just wrong but Rugby League was the winner last night it was just a shame they had to showcase the cheats for it,hopefully the DM curse will stick with them only 1 player has won both the medal and gf in the same year 08 manly and orford.
 
I never said Benji was robbed!!! Didn't say the voting was rigged at all. Only questioned if Bellamy knew more than he should have and that's why slater was rested!! It's a big advantage for them having their stars rested, and if he didn't know slater was a lock, I believe would have played him!!!
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 
Bellamy wanted to rest his players but no doubt had the prospect of slater winning the daily m in his mind. The decision was easy to make knowing that slater would win regardless!! To me, that's an unfair advantage. As mentioned before. What if Bellamy didn't know, slater plays and either gets injured or on report!

A long bow but is a chance of happening.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 
@TigerDave81 said:
Not questioning slater, I think he is a champion player. I'm more questioning Bellamy, the integrity of the voting for the dally m and the spin the storm have done for "resting" slater and smith on the weekend, Happy Tiger.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED

Couple of easy solutions Dave81 Don't reveal any of votes at all during the season
Have it handled by an independant body
 
If Bellamy knew the winner of the Dally M beforehand somewhere, someone cheated??…why is this man associated with the dark side of the game?
 
@Stryker, yeh uve got a point there, so are u saying they put Melbournes game in rnd26 the last game of the round on purpose, I think the whole bloody thing is some sort of conspiracy, cause I know for a fact they would not of rested him if it was before the manly or tigers game, and I also feel robbed with Benj, he definitely deserved 3 points against manly and not 2, and the 2 points against Penrith and not 1, and at most maybe a point against sharks, that would of given him a 2 point buffer on slater, not right
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 
It doesn't really matter does it?

At the end of the day, Benji should have been a little more consistent and the award would have been his.

Slater is deserved of the award and along with Benji is one of the best and most exciting players in the game.

I would also think that Bellamy's focus would be on giving the Storm the best chance of winning the grand final, not ensuring one player secures an accolade for individual achievements.
 
@alexaki said:
If Bellamy knew the winner of the Dally M beforehand somewhere, someone cheated??…why is this man associated with the dark side of the game?

whats the dark side of the game? News Ltd Conspirisies are only in the heads of most monkeys who live in Sydney and support poorly run football franchises…

Thank god the Tigers are moving ahead of all these lazy/dumb Sydney Clubs!
 
Bellemy and Melbourne would not even considered the Dally M when giving Smith and Slater a rest, all he would be worried about is freshing them up for semies.

I think that Smith, Bellemy and Slater were all worthy winners. Captain and Coach awards are always a little contentious cause there is no clear criteria on what makes the coach or captain of the year.
 
WOW

Slater won and deserved it, like everyone else i would have loved to see Benji win.

But this line of conversation from some of you is embarrassing.
 
@MAFIA said:
My concern with the Dally Ms is that they have allways been fixed i stopped watching it years ago when Dave Fairleigh won it his pts got leaked out and people made thousands out of it ,so it does not surprise me that the dirtiest coach of the year pain in the arse(bellamy). Now i sat down to watch the DM last night coco and slippers on and it was the 1st time i had watched them since robbie got dudded you would all remember that last game of the year thurston had to get 3 pts out of there last game in tville well for memory he played 30 minutes the coach took him off they got beaten and surprise surprise thurston got 3 pts and beat robbie, so when the cheats were going up and down getting the Ms i thought rewarding the cheats for there season was a joke, my other [automatically edited] we are on a winning streak 8 games now can someone tell me how many pts benji made out of them please if he didnt get 3 pts for each game how come he didnt at least get 2 or 1 even just like cronk and slater were sharing there pts i think benji may have gotten 9 pts all up over the last 8 games and to me thats just wrong but Rugby League was the winner last night it was just a shame they had to showcase the cheats for it,hopefully the DM curse will stick with them only 1 player has won both the medal and gf in the same year 08 manly and orford.

Fairleigh betting plunge was for the Rothmans medal and was a disgrace.

I dont think it is rigged, but the judges get star struck and give points to some blokes when they dont really deserve it, I dont think that was the case too many times with Slater last night.
I thought Benji should have got points in the Penrith game, and thought Benji was prob best on ground in the Manly game….
 
Slater only won the award, in the end, because Glen Stewart was a moron.

Take away the deducted points and he is equal with Benji and had the opportunity to poll in the last two rounds.

Well done Captain Grey Matter
 
Slater is a superstar and very consistent.
Benji is a superstar but tends to be inconsistent.

There's the reason for your 2011 winner right there.
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top