Draft Game 2000-2010

[Flippedy]

Is that it?
Are we all done?

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0_

Teams are done, now we have to vote, TB - whatever that entails :laughing:

I reckon we should have neutral people vote on the players - i.e. those who haven't picked a team, so there is no bias. Maybe Ink, True Tiger, Knuckles or someone else - just think it would be fairer, but I don't really know what I'm talking about lol. What do you all think?

Great idea Flip

Someone even mentioned last time there were people voting to win the comp , not on merits

**And the idea of putting all of Geo's players last might become overwhelming :roll**
I'm with Flip

Yes that would be tempting :smiling_imp:

If we do end up going with the neutral voters, we'll need to make sure they know to rate on the player's 2000-2010 form and not before or after. I'd hate to see Braith end up being rated on his 2 seasons with us! 😱pen_mouth: :laughing:

 

[Geo]

That's how Happy rolls…

 

[happy_tiger]

Is that it?
Are we all done?

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0_

Teams are done, now we have to vote, TB - whatever that entails :laughing:

I reckon we should have neutral people vote on the players - i.e. those who haven't picked a team, so there is no bias. Maybe Ink, True Tiger, Knuckles or someone else - just think it would be fairer, but I don't really know what I'm talking about lol. What do you all think?

Great idea Flip

Someone even mentioned last time there were people voting to win the comp , not on merits

**And the idea of putting all of Geo's players last might become overwhelming :roll**
I'm with Flip

Yes that would be tempting :smiling_imp:

If we do end up going with the neutral voters, we'll need to make sure they know to rate on the player's 2000-2010 form and not before or after. I'd hate to see Braith end up being rated on his 2 seasons with us! 😱pen_mouth: :laughing:

Braith wasn't voted the most over rated player twice on the RLW players player votes for a reason

 

[Flippedy]

Is that it?
Are we all done?

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0_

Teams are done, now we have to vote, TB - whatever that entails :laughing:

I reckon we should have neutral people vote on the players - i.e. those who haven't picked a team, so there is no bias. Maybe Ink, True Tiger, Knuckles or someone else - just think it would be fairer, but I don't really know what I'm talking about lol. What do you all think?

Great idea Flip

Someone even mentioned last time there were people voting to win the comp , not on merits

**And the idea of putting all of Geo's players last might become overwhelming :roll**
I'm with Flip

Yes that would be tempting :smiling_imp:

If we do end up going with the neutral voters, we'll need to make sure they know to rate on the player's 2000-2010 form and not before or after. I'd hate to see Braith end up being rated on his 2 seasons with us! 😱pen_mouth: :laughing:

Braith wasn't voted the most over rated player twice on the RLW players player votes for a reason

He was good player, especially when he was at Canterbury - played for Aus. He was just over rated and over hyped by the media - I think that's what the other players objected to, but I could be wrrrong :mrgreen:

 

[Geo]

Apart from Goose who I respect very much…

who else could be bothered getting involved with this lunacy...

Vote for each others teams.....the only problem I foresee is players picked who only scraped into the front or back-end of the Era getting judged against those that played the majority of the Era....if you are fair dinkum...

 

[happy_tiger]

Ink ,Watto , Knuckles , GNR ,Steve Tiger ,TITG , Willow ,Batboy , KS , Supercoach ,851 ,Jirskyr ,Jerry Seinfeld, Stryker , Hobbo to name a few (If I left people out forgive me , nothing personal )

Enough people who's opinion's I have faith in

I mightn't agree with everything they say , but they have integrity

 

[Flippedy]

Ink ,Watto , Knuckles , GNR ,Steve Tiger ,TITG , Willow ,Batboy , KS , Supercoach ,851 ,Jirskyr ,Jerry Seinfeld, Stryker , Hobbo to name a few (If I left people out forgive me , nothing personal )

Enough people who's opinion's I have faith in

I mightn't agree with everything they say , but they have integrity

I'd be happy with any of that lot Happy, but I'd also add Cunno and TT to the list. Depends on who is on here enough, as well. Some of those guys don't come on here as often as us losers, who have nothing better to do :laughing: I would suggest a panel of 4 or 5 only, also.

 

[happy_tiger]

Ink ,Watto , Knuckles , GNR ,Steve Tiger ,TITG , Willow ,Batboy , KS , Supercoach ,851 ,Jirskyr ,Jerry Seinfeld, Stryker , Hobbo to name a few (If I left people out forgive me , nothing personal )

Enough people who's opinion's I have faith in

I mightn't agree with everything they say , but they have integrity

I'd be happy with any of that lot Happy, but I'd also add Cunno and TT to the list. Depends on who is on here enough, as well. Some of those guys don't come on here as often as us losers, who have nothing better to do :laughing: I would suggest a panel of 4 or 5 only, also.

Sorry TT and Cunno

My worry with Cunno is that age thing Flip , he'd probably forget some of who those players were :laughing:

 

[Geo]

TRADE WINDOW went well….we can now start the voting process ...whatever that turns out to be...

 

[happy_tiger]

TRADE WINDOW went well….we can now start the voting process ...whatever that turns out to be...

Yep

One of your finest Geo :laughing:

Any other great ideas Dopey ??

 

[foreveratiger]

O.K lets start with the Fullbacks

# Brett Mullins
# Matt Bowen
# Greg Inglis
# Billy Slater
# Brett Stewart
# Preston Campbell
# Anthony Minichello
# Jarryd Hayne
# Brett Hodgson
# Karmichael Hunt

You can not vote for your own Fullback, 1\. being your most favourite to 9\. being your least favourite.

Remember you do not vote for your own player

 

[foreveratiger]

My order :

1\. Anthony Minichello
2\. Brett Hodgson
3\. Matt Bowen
4\. Billy Slater
5\. Jarryd Hayne
6\. Greg Inglis
7\. Karmichael Hunt
8\. Brett Mullins
9\. Preston Campbell

 

[happy_tiger]

Inglis
Hayne
Slater
Hunt
Mullins
Stewart
Bowen
Mini hello hello
Campbell

 

[Geo]

1\. Brett Hodgson
2\. Jarryd Hayne
3\. Billy Slater
4\. Anthony Minichello
5\. Brett Mullins
6\. Matty Bowan
7\. Brett Stewart
8\. Greg Inglis
9\. Preston Campbell

 

[Geo]

Inglis
Hayne
Slater
Hunt
Mullins
Bowen
Mini hello hello
Campbell

:laughing: You can't even vote right…left out B Stewart...sweet jesus... :crazy

 

[foreveratiger]

Inglis
Hayne
Slater
Hunt
Mullins
Bowen
Mini hello hello
Campbell

:laughing: You can't even vote right…left out B Stewart...sweet jesus... :crazy

Oh dear and it's only the fullbacks :laughing:

 

[Flippedy]

Mini
Hunt
Hodgo
Inglis
Hayne
Stewart
Bowen
Mullins
Campbell

 

[tiger_betto]

1\. Anthony Minichello
2\. Billy Slater
3\. Jarryd Hayne
4\. Brett Hodgson
5\. Brett Stewart
6\. Matt Bowen
7\. Greg Inglis (only because he didn't play fullback much at all in the era)
8\. Karmichael Hunt
9\. Preston Campbell

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0_

 

[Sabre]

Aren't we doing this wrong?
As per the original post:

# How it will be scored : We are not doing this 10,9,8,7,6….....System we had . Every player will be scored out of 10 for every position , cause there is 2 Centres ? each Centre will be scored out of 10 .
Your 4 interchange players will be scored out of 10 as a team of 4.
You don't rate your own

 

[Flippedy]

Aren't we doing this wrong?
As per the original post:

# How it will be scored : We are not doing this 10,9,8,7,6….....System we had . Every player will be scored out of 10 for every position , cause there is 2 Centres ? each Centre will be scored out of 10 .
Your 4 interchange players will be scored out of 10 as a team of 4.
You don't rate your own

NFI, I'm just following the leader :laughing: