End of season player ratings

[UP THA TIGERS]

1 the worst score and 10 the highest.
*This list is not categorized in a particular order.
1. Benji - 9
2.Brooks - 8
3. Marsters - 6
4. garner -7
5. nofoaluma - 9
6.Jennings - 5
7.Twal -7
8.farah - 8
9. Mbye - 7
10.Momirovski - 8
11.Matterson - 9
12. Eisenhuth - 7
13. Taylor - 6
14.Reynolds - 6
15. Mikaele - 7
16. aloiai - 7
17. Chee-kam - 7
18.clark -6
19.Thompson - 8
20. fonua - 6
21.Talau - 6
22. Matulino -6
23.Lawrence - 7
24. McQueen - 6
25. Liddle - 7
26. packer - 5

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

Not sure how matto could be anything other than a 10. That bloke should be the next captain.

 

[rustycage]

1 the worst score and 10 the highest.
*This list is not categorized in a particular order.
1. Benji - 9
2.Brooks - 8
3. Marsters - 6
4. garner -7
5. nofoaluma - 9
6.Jennings - 5
7.Twal -7
8.farah - 8
9. Mbye - 7
10.Momirovski - 8
11.Matterson - 9
12. Eisenhuth - 7
13. Taylor - 6
14.Reynolds - 6
15. Mikaele - 7
16. aloiai - 7
17. Chee-kam - 7
18.clark -6
19.Thompson - 8
20. fonua - 6
21.Talau - 6
22. Matulino -6
23.Lawrence - 7
24. McQueen - 6
25. Liddle - 7
26. packer - 5

There's some very generous summations there

 

[Madge]

Marsters - 6... should’ve been (-6)

 

[Russell]

So everybody gets a pass mark - more than generous I'd say.

Masters 3.5
Jennings 2 (thats for putting on the jersey)
McQueen 4
Thompson 9
Farah 7
Twal 8
Matterson 10
Brooks 10
Garner 8
Eisenhuth 6
Taylor 7

The rest about the same.

 

[tig_prmz]

alright let's set a scale:
10= steve smith like
0= didn't take the field

 

[Roar_Power]

@UP-THA-TIGERS very generous marking there. Are you basing this on the skill level of Tigers players or against players in the rest of the comp? Nofo gets a 9? Wow!

 

[BZN]

G'day @UP-THA-TIGERS: I'd like to take this opportunity to wish you, and all our Forumers "A Very Happy CHRISTMAS" :christmas_tree: :mother_christmas: :christmas_tree: :mother_christmas::christmas_tree: :mother_christmas::christmas_tree: :mother_christmas: :christmas_tree: :mother_christmas: :christmas_tree: .
.....................................................................................................................................
my points.
8.9---Benji Marshall---the world's most exciting player ever and still an attacking weapon.
8.5---Luke Brooks---I wouldn't trade him for any other no. 7. Guts and determination personified.
8.4---Matterson---deserves to be Wests Tigers next captain.
7.9---Thompson---100% effort every game.
7.8---Garner--- a star in the making.
7.3---Twal, Taylor, Aloiai, Mikaele and Mbye.
7.2---Farah.
7.1---Lawrence.
7.0---Momorovski---my most improved.
6.9---Eisenhuth.
6.7---Clark---will probably be an 8.0 be next year.
6.5---Reynolds--- I hope he stays with us and injury-free.
6.4---Liddle---A good replacement for Farah if he stays injury-free.
6.0---Nofoaluma and Chee-kam.
5.0--- Marsters.
4.0---Jennings.

 

[earl]

8 Benji, Brooks & Matterson.
7 Thompson, Garner, Aloiai, Mikaele & Nofo
6 Twal, Taylor, Momorovski, Eisenhuth, Farah, Lawrence, Chee-kam, Mbye & Clark.
5 Liddle, Marsters, McQueen, Matulino & Fonua
4 Reynolds & Jennings
3 Packer & Talau

 

[Madge]

@Earl jeez bit harsh on Talau, he’s had more linebreaks than Jennings and he’s only played one game. I wouldn’t include him in these ratings on the one game he played.

 

[earl]

@Earl jeez bit harsh on Talau, he’s had more linebreaks than Jennings and he’s only played one game. I wouldn’t include him in these ratings on the one game he played.

He played one game. I don't see how you rate him any higher.

 

[WT2K]

10 Matterson
8 Benji, Brooks
7 Thompson, Garner, Aloiai, Mikaele
6 Twal, Taylor, nofo, Farah, Lawrence, Momirovski
5 MCK, Eisenhuth, Clark
4 Mbye, Fonua, Matulino, Liddle, Reynolds
3 McQueen
2 Marsters
1 Packer, Jennings

 

[gallagher]

10 Matterson
8 Benji, Brooks
7 Thompson, Garner, Aloiai, Mikaele
6 Twal, Taylor, nofo, Farah, Lawrence, Momirovski
5 MCK, Eisenhuth, Clark
4 Mbye, Fonua, Matulino, Liddle, Reynolds
3 McQueen
2 Marsters
1 Packer, Jennings

Bit harsh on Marsters there, the rest seems about right.

 

[Madge]

@Earl I wouldnt include him.

 

[The_Patriot]

Main players.

Matterson 9

Thompson 8

Benji 8.5

Farah 7

Brooks 7

Twal 6.5

Mikaele 7.5

Aloiai 8.5

Momo 7.5

Nofo 6.5

Garner 7

Clarke 6.5

The rest i couldnt care less

 

[earl]

@Madge That is a fair point. He probably shouldn't be included.

 

[TIGER]

Packerlino 0.5

The rest somewhere between 4 and 8

 

[Tigerboy]

All crap

 

[BalmainJnr]


We should do a ticker rating, could be interesting.