Galloway

[hybrid_tiger]

He was our best forward Sirro, and we clearly struggled for go forward when he was off the field.

I agree with you on Heighington (another discussion but IMO he hinders out attack badly) but not on this one. We have other players who can do what you are looking for, Galloway was strong in attack and defense and made good meters in a badly beaten side.

 

[king_sirro]

Dont agree with me on something i said about Heighno 12 months ago, because he changed my opinion. The one time today Heighno was in an altercation he took the next hit up like a man…...thats all im asking of Galloway

 

[hybrid_tiger]

Heighington gets dominated in nearly every tackle, and gets in the way of our attack more often than not. I admire his work rate but he doesn't have the impact Galloway has.

Have you ever seen Heighington hammer a player in defense?

 

[Geo]

Ive just watch the replay and Galloway was the only bloke in our side that went continually forward when on the field….hit hard and often in defense too.....

 

[Enfield_Feds]

Galloway was our best….yet again.

 

[innsaneink]

I too again thought Keef was our best early on….dunno what you want from him KS, your clearly in the monority - again.
You keep bringing up other players, Keith is Keith and I think you just need to accept that, he goes forward, does his job, is disciplined.
Hard to please

 

[king_sirro]

I too again thought Keef was our best early on….dunno what you want from him KS, your clearly in the monority - again.
You keep bringing up other players, Keith is Keith and I think you just need to accept that, he goes forward, does his job, is disciplined.
Hard to please

Yeh maybe your right, Keith is Keith…..goes forward but doesnt inforce. I agree

 

[king_sirro]

I too again thought Keef was our best early on….dunno what you want from him KS, your clearly in the monority - again.
You keep bringing up other players, Keith is Keith and I think you just need to accept that, he goes forward, does his job, is disciplined.
Hard to please

Yeh maybe your right, Keith is Keith…..goes forward but doesnt enforce. I agree

 

[Vicious]

Big Keith is no superstar, but at the same time I don`t think there are too many better props running around at the moment. Put it this way, i`d like to have another couple like him. He and Aaron Woods are doing there part in getting us going forward, the others aren`t doing a lot.

 

[innsaneink]

And wade mack dont have the balance and speed of Dugan, Ayshford dont have the strength of Inglis, Marshall dont have a boot like Soward, Heighno doesnt have Gallens aggro & go forward, Brown doesnt have Fergusons talents etc etc et yawwwn
He enforces plenny

 

[tiger05]

Keith was good today. Heighno in my opinion was our best forward but there are times when he annoys me.

Keith was our second best forward. He carts it up and defends well and that is all I want from him.

 

[king_sirro]

And wade mack dont have the balance and speed of Dugan, Ayshford dont have the strength of Inglis, Marshall dont have a boot like Soward, Heighno doesnt have Gallens aggro & go forward, Brown doesnt have Fergusons talents etc etc et yawwwn
He enforces plenny

Didnt think i compared Keith to anyone else…....but dont let that stop your argument

 

[cunno]

I agree with a comment from Allan Towle in another thread when he said Galloway should be given more game time by playing more than two stints like he does now. Keith has been one of our better forwards this year and was again today. More game time gives him further opportunities and also is a way of Sheens showing his faith in him as a leader of our pack thereby reinforcing belief, expectations and role. As for Heighno, he plays above his weight, gives his all and his workload would be missed if he wasn't there.

 

[stryker]

A pet peeve of mine as well Cunno…he just doesnt get enough game time.

 

[cunno]

A pet peeve of mine as well Cunno…he just doesnt get enough game time.

Hopefully he'll get more game time against souths, I still can't forget last years game against Souths at the SCG, please not a repeat!

 

[Muffstar]

Galloway was ok I thought. Dwyer is the one who is living on his reputation on THAT tackle last year. Keep going Blue !

 

[innsaneink]

And wade mack dont have the balance and speed of Dugan, Ayshford dont have the strength of Inglis, Marshall dont have a boot like Soward, Heighno doesnt have Gallens aggro & go forward, Brown doesnt have Fergusons talents etc etc et yawwwn
He enforces plenny

Didnt think i compared Keith to anyone else…....but dont let that stop your argument

I think you did

Matt Scott
Paul Harrigan

My post was pointing out all players have someone else better in front of them

Youre never happy, thats your problem.

 

[happy_tiger]

I thought Sauce was one of our best Today with MacKinnon , Heighington Benji and Shirnack .Led the pack well .

 

[Muffstar]

I thought Sauce was one of our best Today with MacKinnon , Heighington Benji and Shirnack .Led the pack well .

yeah agree with you.

 

[Goose]

I thought Galloway was good again, King Sirro you're right, he is not Paul Harragon, but gees, not many are!! he is in the top handful of props in the last 20 years.
Galloway takes the ball forward well, is a strong defender, he is a very good prop despite not heading to the hall of fame with blokes like Harragon and Roach.
As for Dwyer living off that tackle, I think the reverse, I think he is paying for it, people want him to come out and pull off the hit of the year every week!