Gibbs suspended for THREE matches

[Craegus]

OK, so, as i understand it, these are allowed:

[](http://img137.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=95401_0296776631800_122_83lo.jpg)
[](http://img230.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=95403_695088-johnathan-thurston_122_165lo.jpg)
[](http://img24.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=95404_431229-jamie-soward-pic-courtesy-channel-9_122_100lo.jpg)
|

But this is not:
[](http://img23.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=95402_986186-dtstory-bryce-gibbs_122_411lo.jpg)

:angry: :deadhorse:

Could someone explain the first THREE instances to me.

The first two I know, not sure about the third.

1) Soward kicks at the ball/face while being fended off by Inglis. Games Missed - 0

2) Thurston kicks at the face of Williams. The kick breaks Williams cheek. Games Missed - 0

 

[Ryan]

The first two I know, not sure about the third.

1) Soward kicks at the ball/face while being fended off by Inglis. Games Missed - 0

2) Thurston kicks at the face of Williams. The kick breaks Williams cheek. Games Missed - 0

3) Soward has a naw on Ballin's forearm. He jumped up telling his team mates about it, but did not make an 'official complaint'. Games Missed - 0

 

[senexx]

What rounds were these?

 

[Tigerfansince85]

OK, so, as i understand it, these are allowed:

[](http://img137.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=95401_0296776631800_122_83lo.jpg)
[](http://img230.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=95403_695088-johnathan-thurston_122_165lo.jpg)
[](http://img24.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=95404_431229-jamie-soward-pic-courtesy-channel-9_122_100lo.jpg)
|

But this is not:
[](http://img23.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=95402_986186-dtstory-bryce-gibbs_122_411lo.jpg)

:angry: :deadhorse:

You should send this to all the footy and sports shows.

See if any of them are game to air it :slight_smile:

 

[chilbury]

OK, so, as i understand it, these are allowed:

[](http://img137.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=95401_0296776631800_122_83lo.jpg)
[](http://img230.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=95403_695088-johnathan-thurston_122_165lo.jpg)
[](http://img24.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=95404_431229-jamie-soward-pic-courtesy-channel-9_122_100lo.jpg)
|

But this is not:
[](http://img23.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=95402_986186-dtstory-bryce-gibbs_122_411lo.jpg)

:angry: :deadhorse:

You should send this to all the footy and sports shows.

Bloody rigged The Magpies have always been hated by the Elite for years even as a joint venture we still cop it, Us fibros will never die :righton:

See if any of them are game to air it :slight_smile:

 

[beachtiger]

I can understand the comparisons being made and that in the context of things he probably didn't deserve 3 weeks especially as we got an 8 point try against us which started the shift of momentum.

But in saying that Gibbs is a serial offender when it comes to stupid penalties and anyone trying to defend this is kidding themselves, it is a real shame that Gibbsy still has that in his game becasue as someone who has never really rated him I think he has come on really good this season and we are now going to miss him for the run home…wasteed aggression there.

 

[T91]

Look out there out to get us,its a conspiracy against the mighty tiges. Gotta love this forum.

Haha. Don't worry about it though Gazza, the NRL will let the Tigers win in 2012\. :unamused:

 

[chilbury]

Look out there out to get us,its a conspiracy against the mighty tiges. Gotta love this forum.

Haha. Don't worry about it though Gazza, the NRL will let the Tigers win in 2012\. :unamused:

Do you know how many sports around the World have been busted for inside cheating even our own Cricketers have been busted for betting in dodgy deals
you never know when it comes to lots of money its so easy to fudge the books dude !
You never know..

 

[diedpretty]

It almost feels as if people dont want us in the finals…

They don't - they never have - just look at the history books at how Wests and Balmain have been treated - nothing has changed.

 

[diedpretty]

I can understand the comparisons being made and that in the context of things he probably didn't deserve 3 weeks especially as we got an 8 point try against us which started the shift of momentum.

But in saying that Gibbs is a serial offender when it comes to stupid penalties and anyone trying to defend this is kidding themselves, it is a real shame that Gibbsy still has that in his game becasue as someone who has never really rated him I think he has come on really good this season and we are now going to miss him for the run home…wasteed aggression there.

I don't think anyone is trying to defend Gibbs actions - some believe they may have been unintended but no one is denying he didn't do it - what everyone is complaining about is the inconsistency in citing and sentencing especially especially against the perceived elite sides.

 

[tiger_one]

Agree with previous posts that Gibbs action was inintentional and he's been harshly treated, especially compared to other incidents through 09.
I don't like the inconsistencies.

And why wasn't Hayne fronting the judiciary?

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

Yeh, Inglis 2 weeks Gibbs 3 weeks. go figure.

 

[izotope]

Yeh, Inglis 2 weeks Gibbs 3 weeks. go figure.

yeah but inglis is innocent until proven guilty, whereas brett stewart broke club/nrl rules.
Completely seperate to the judiciary.

still bullshit though, oh well.. couldve been avoided if he just kept his cool.

 

[Tigermac]

OK, so, as i understand it, these are allowed:

[](http://img137.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=95401_0296776631800_122_83lo.jpg)
[](http://img230.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=95403_695088-johnathan-thurston_122_165lo.jpg)
[](http://img24.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=95404_431229-jamie-soward-pic-courtesy-channel-9_122_100lo.jpg)
|

But this is not:
[](http://img23.imagevenue.com/img.php?image=95402_986186-dtstory-bryce-gibbs_122_411lo.jpg)

:angry: :deadhorse:

You should send this to all the footy and sports shows.

See if any of them are game to air it :slight_smile:

The guys on the footy show reckon it was a joke that he was suspended for 3 weeks.
Is Andrew Voss a closed Wests Tigers supporter? He has picked them again this week

 

[tiger_tigers]

Agree with previous posts that Gibbs action was inintentional and he's been harshly treated, especially compared to other incidents through 09.
I don't like the inconsistencies.

And why wasn't Hayne fronting the judiciary?

well thats easy … haynes the face of the NRL atm lmfao ....after stewart stuffed up , and then inglis......
all four offences deserved suspensions imho.....but we all know our past has a way of catching up .....

 

[Kul]

[No message]