Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

achilles said:
Its a simple yes no question on the point i posted about which seems difficult to answer.

If you dont want to answer it dont but don't hijack the point i was trying to make.

Im just saying do people think its a bad thing for the club to forget about Doueihi form at 6 in those games.

Those games happened. His injury happened and the whole team went bad after that there were factors around his form drop.
Click to expand...
It’s not a simply yes or no though . Because if I say yes you’re going to carry on about you being right, and me being full of shit , and if I say no you’re going to accuse me of being dishonest . It’s a loaded question designed to reframe everything in a binary answer to validate yourself .
I’ll say it one more time - he had good individual performances . The team didn’t perform well , the structures were shit in attack and sloppy /disjointed . I thought our edges were starved of good ball . In all those games . But did he play well . By what metric ? Because often I would see him go alone and score and everyone sing his praises … when the easy option was to give the ball on , draw and pass and stroll over .
Thats what I see . he’s not a very good half , but a good footy player.
 
Lestronge said:
It’s not a simply yes or no though . Because if I say yes you’re going to carry on about you being right, and me being full of shit , and if I say no you’re going to accuse me of being dishonest . It’s a loaded question designed to reframe everything in a binary answer to validate yourself .
I’ll say it one more time - he had good individual performances . The team didn’t perform well , the structures were shit in attack and sloppy /disjointed . I thought our edges were starved of good ball . In all those games . But did he play well . By what metric ? Because often I would see him go alone and score and everyone sing his praises … when the easy option was to give the ball on , draw and pass and stroll over .
Thats what I see . he’s not a very good half , but a good footy player.
Click to expand...
Wow
 
achilles said:
Yeh he backs himself just unsure he considers himself week week in weel out first grader yet which understandable because no one has backed him as yet
Click to expand...
He is No where near a First grader hence why he hasnt been backed. I keep hearing Madden on this Forum if he is our first choice half we are an absolute joke. Hes kicking game reaches the height and length of an U/10s game
 
GNR4LIFE said:
His kicking game is reserve grade standard. He plays direct though. That’s about the only positive. He tries, I’ll give him that. But he’s just not up
Click to expand...

tigeress said:
In my opinion Madden is one of our better players. To me he always seems with it and switched on and there are no dramas around him, he just gets on with the job at hand. To me we need more like him at this club.
Click to expand...
You cant be serious. Madden is one of our better players. Were in massive trouble for this to be even quietly thought of in ones head , let alone said out load. Madden should not be playing FG unless we have an injured riddled season in that area. He does give his all that i agree with but hes just not at that level in every other parts of the game.
 
Modman said:
He is No where near a First grader hence why he hasnt been backed. I keep hearing Madden on this Forum if he is our first choice half we are an absolute joke. Hes kicking game reaches the height and length of an U/10s game
Click to expand...

Yeh but there not many perfection no 7s out there for the tigers
 
Modman said:
You cant be serious. Madden is one of our better players. Were in massive trouble for this to be even quietly thought of in ones head , let alone said out load. Madden should not be playing FG unless we have an injured riddled season in that area. He does give his all that i agree with but hes just not at that level in every other parts of the game.
Click to expand...
It’s a real shame if he could figure out to hit the ball consistently in the middle his overall game would improve astronomically. Man at times does he lack power. And it really hurts the team. It means the team can get trapped on our own line
 
LeichhardtTiger said:
To be honest, there is only one song that should ever be played at a Grand Final. I realise this may be a contentious call, but Ladies and Gentlemen, I give you Tiger Legend, Jack Riewoldt and Mr Brightside.
Click to expand...

Richmond is a great club, and I think they’ll kick hard into 2027. They have so many outstanding juniors.

Unfortunately, the Swans let themselves down this year with the “party before the performance” attitude.

A couple of mates of mine reckon it was actually a honey trap, and they got caught out with the early celebrations.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 5,880 (members: 4, guests: 5,876)
Back
Top