How was Marshall a nominee?

[TigerCrib]

Despite those stats, there is no way he was top 4.

What were his stats on

Tackles made?
Tackles missed?
Kick meters?
Runs made?
Meters made in attack?
Errors?

…and most importantly, how many times did he stand up in a clutch situation when we were in an arm wrestle and get us home?

Why does it always have to hinge on one person? From the talent on the list there are plenty of others out there on the field that could stand up and make something happen…...

 

[Goose]

Marshall was mistake ridden, but led the way in Try assists, the scoring plays are the important ones, that is enough to get you in the top 4, but the mistakes mean you dont win it.

 

[stryker]

[
Why does it always have to hinge on one person? From the talent on the list there are plenty of others out there on the field that could stand up and make something happen…...

It doesnt normally but with us it usually does.

Benji did not have a great year - that was plain to see irrespective of the stats. It usually does come down to him as he is supposed to be our playmaker, is an international captain, has played top grade for 8 years, is the most gifted player in the team….shall I go on?