Tiger_heart
Well-known member
So, we are likely to need to win six of our remaining eight games to qualify for finals for the first time since 2011.
Note: longest current drought of any team.
And it looks lik we'll lose Api for the rest of the season...
Now, admittely we are still only four points out of the eight, so the optimists out there will point to a "we are still mathematically in" .. Whilst this is a correct statement, after this performance, and to some extent the one last week, do we really deserve to end our 15-year finals drought? Does it really only take a couple of (inexperienced) opposition front rowers to run through our pack? Is it really part of the game plan to continually run side ways, and only have to rely on one player (Douheiui) to show ANY creativity with the ball?
Is playing a career winger in the centres a good idea?
And to add salt to injury, this is what Benji said:
“To be honest, our discipline, attention to detail, and care wasn't good enough, so full credit to the Dragons, because they earned their win”
“We had a chance to turn up today and have a real crack at it, but again we weren't good enough”
So what does this say about the belief that exists in this team or how they approach what would be considered "key" games in the context of our season? Who is in charge, the doctor or the patients?
In another thread, the Panthers were mentioned as one club that was in a similar position. Thanks to AI, below is a side by side comparison, which is self explanatory:
Direct Comparison: Penrith Rebuild vs. Wests Tigers Reality
So perhas the subject in this thread should be more one that reads "Don't be disappointed when we don't make the 8's" - because until some very hard decisons are made, we'll remain stuck in the same quicksand we've been since 2011. Or maybe even 2005.
Note: longest current drought of any team.
And it looks lik we'll lose Api for the rest of the season...
Now, admittely we are still only four points out of the eight, so the optimists out there will point to a "we are still mathematically in" .. Whilst this is a correct statement, after this performance, and to some extent the one last week, do we really deserve to end our 15-year finals drought? Does it really only take a couple of (inexperienced) opposition front rowers to run through our pack? Is it really part of the game plan to continually run side ways, and only have to rely on one player (Douheiui) to show ANY creativity with the ball?
Is playing a career winger in the centres a good idea?
And to add salt to injury, this is what Benji said:
“To be honest, our discipline, attention to detail, and care wasn't good enough, so full credit to the Dragons, because they earned their win”
“We had a chance to turn up today and have a real crack at it, but again we weren't good enough”
So what does this say about the belief that exists in this team or how they approach what would be considered "key" games in the context of our season? Who is in charge, the doctor or the patients?
In another thread, the Panthers were mentioned as one club that was in a similar position. Thanks to AI, below is a side by side comparison, which is self explanatory:
Direct Comparison: Penrith Rebuild vs. Wests Tigers Reality
| Operational Pillar | How Penrith Fixed It | Where Wests Tigers Are Stuck |
|---|---|---|
| Boardroom | Appointed an authoritative GM (Gould) to absorb media heat and control football ops. | Factional leagues-club politics and owner interference continually override executives. |
| Coaching | Stuck by coaches through tough years; gave Ivan Cleary total roster control. | Sacked 6 head coaches since 2012, completely disrupting playing styles. |
| Roster Focus | 85% local juniors supported by 2–3 targeted elite veteran signings. | High turnover of expensive, outsourced players with low club affinity. |
| Geographics | Centred entirely in Penrith and the Central West region. | Fractured identity split between inner-west Balmain and south-west Campbelltown. |
| Culture | "Next man up" mentality; junior systems play identical tactics to the NRL team. | No unified defensive or tactical identity spanning junior to senior grades. |