Ikin: Harry Grant "not developed"

[Deleted member 3518]

Actions not words. Stefano, Blore, Seyfarth, Laurie, Talau, Kepaoa tell a different story. Having the best young talent gravitate to WTs and come into the NRL is the only response. I believe by the time WTs' narrative is out there, we will be turning away players like Mitchell because he is simply not a player who has the consistency of performance WTs' expect.

As for Liddle, perhaps our best re-signing in recent times. For me, he is the glue that will bind the Club and a future Captain.

Just because a young player is good doesn’t make him a future captain. Doueihi is the future captain.

Not only is he good on the field, Liddle is articulate and in all his interviews I have watched presents the WTs in a favourable light.

As for Doueihi, great player but not captain material.

What ? Really ? You don’t think that hitup off the back fence , the way the boys rally around him, and his overt passion for the club arnt captain material . Not to mention his on field ability , and the fact barring injury and a complete form slump from hell , he’s going to be pencilled into the 13 for the majority of his career .
I think he’s a ball hog , at times , but not because he wants the glory , but because he thinks he needs to do it by himself at times . To me that’s maturity , and trust more than anything .
I disagree with you on this one mate .

 

[pawsandclaws1]

Actions not words. Stefano, Blore, Seyfarth, Laurie, Talau, Kepaoa tell a different story. Having the best young talent gravitate to WTs and come into the NRL is the only response. I believe by the time WTs' narrative is out there, we will be turning away players like Mitchell because he is simply not a player who has the consistency of performance WTs' expect.

As for Liddle, perhaps our best re-signing in recent times. For me, he is the glue that will bind the Club and a future Captain.

Just because a young player is good doesn’t make him a future captain. Doueihi is the future captain.

Not only is he good on the field, Liddle is articulate and in all his interviews I have watched presents the WTs in a favourable light.

As for Doueihi, great player but not captain material.

What ? Really ? You don’t think that hitup off the back fence , the way the boys rally around him, and his overt passion for the club arnt captain material . Not to mention his on field ability , and the fact barring injury and a complete form slump from hell , he’s going to be pencilled into the 13 for the majority of his career .
I think he’s a ball hog , at times , but not because he wants the glory , but because he thinks he needs to do it by himself at times . To me that’s maturity , and trust more than anything .
I disagree with you on this one mate .

Everyone has a different view on players and I won't change opinions on a football forum. Liddle is a vastly underrated player as we know through reading the forum. He may not be the best player but his is right up there with them. Off the field he is articulate, presents very well and he gets his message across. To me an audience would warm to him.

 

[Deleted member 3518]

Actions not words. Stefano, Blore, Seyfarth, Laurie, Talau, Kepaoa tell a different story. Having the best young talent gravitate to WTs and come into the NRL is the only response. I believe by the time WTs' narrative is out there, we will be turning away players like Mitchell because he is simply not a player who has the consistency of performance WTs' expect.

As for Liddle, perhaps our best re-signing in recent times. For me, he is the glue that will bind the Club and a future Captain.

Just because a young player is good doesn’t make him a future captain. Doueihi is the future captain.

Not only is he good on the field, Liddle is articulate and in all his interviews I have watched presents the WTs in a favourable light.

As for Doueihi, great player but not captain material.

What ? Really ? You don’t think that hitup off the back fence , the way the boys rally around him, and his overt passion for the club arnt captain material . Not to mention his on field ability , and the fact barring injury and a complete form slump from hell , he’s going to be pencilled into the 13 for the majority of his career .
I think he’s a ball hog , at times , but not because he wants the glory , but because he thinks he needs to do it by himself at times . To me that’s maturity , and trust more than anything .
I disagree with you on this one mate .

Everyone has a different view on players and I won't change opinions on a football forum. Liddle is a vastly underrated player as we know through reading the forum. He may not be the best player but his is right up there with them. Off the field he is articulate, presents very well and he gets his message across. To me an audience would warm to him.

Yea I agree on Liddle . I just disagreed on the AD stuff. But each to thier own

 

[hodgo]

Actions not words. Stefano, Blore, Seyfarth, Laurie, Talau, Kepaoa tell a different story. Having the best young talent gravitate to WTs and come into the NRL is the only response. I believe by the time WTs' narrative is out there, we will be turning away players like Mitchell because he is simply not a player who has the consistency of performance WTs' expect.

As for Liddle, perhaps our best re-signing in recent times. For me, he is the glue that will bind the Club and a future Captain.

Just because a young player is good doesn’t make him a future captain. Doueihi is the future captain.

Not only is he good on the field, Liddle is articulate and in all his interviews I have watched presents the WTs in a favourable light.

As for Doueihi, great player but not captain material.

What ? Really ? You don’t think that hitup off the back fence , the way the boys rally around him, and his overt passion for the club arnt captain material . Not to mention his on field ability , and the fact barring injury and a complete form slump from hell , he’s going to be pencilled into the 13 for the majority of his career .
I think he’s a ball hog , at times , but not because he wants the glory , but because he thinks he needs to do it by himself at times . To me that’s maturity , and trust more than anything .
I disagree with you on this one mate .

Everyone has a different view on players and I won't change opinions on a football forum. Liddle is a vastly underrated player as we know through reading the forum. He may not be the best player but his is right up there with them. Off the field he is articulate, presents very well and he gets his message across. To me an audience would warm to him.

i personally dont totally agree. I think he's improving and playing good football and for the price, he is definitely an asset. But he isn't close to the top hookers yet. hopefully, he continues on an upward projectory and can stay injury free because he seems to have all the right tools.

 

[BZN]

All I know is that I’m proud to have Madge at the club and really believe in him...date back to his stand off with ivan at the nines tournament. He bleeds for this club and that’s what I love most. However I do believe he needs support and it’s great to see the club has identified that

:hugging_face: :+1: :+1: :+1: :+1: