Is there any ex WT's players you would take back

[happy_tiger]

This could get pretty explosive , that's not the idea

Forget why they left and what fit's our current's needs , who would you want ??

For me Taupau , he left on pretty good terms

Tough call though JAC gives us the need for speed out wide

Thoughts ?

 

[tigerap]

Can’t see the none of the above button…..

 

[TCL]

I went with Addo Carr. Moses would win my vote for someone you don't won't back. Ever.

 

[jadtiger]

I went with Addo Carr. Moses would win my vote for someone you don't won't back. Ever.

Agree on both points

 

[Demps]

Taupau is a hype machine.
Isn't delivering for Manly atm.

Addo Car is a yes.
Lodge for ISC! Lol…

We could use Austin.

 

[upthetigers]

Bit surprised with the Tapau votes. He's done nothing at Manly.

 

[happy_tiger]

Taupau is a hype machine.
Isn't delivering for Manly atm.

Addo Car is a yes.
Lodge for ISC! Lol…

We could use Austin.

Taupau had 15 TB's last night 240 odd metres and 43 tackles

 

[upthetigers]

Taupau is a hype machine.
Isn't delivering for Manly atm.

Addo Car is a yes.
Lodge for ISC! Lol…

We could use Austin.

Taupau had 15 TB's last night 240 odd metres and 43 tackles

He's definitely not doing that most weeks.

 

[Demps]

Taupau is a hype machine.
Isn't delivering for Manly atm.

Addo Car is a yes.
Lodge for ISC! Lol…

We could use Austin.

Taupau had 15 TB's last night 240 odd metres and 43 tackles

He's definitely not doing that most weeks.

He's a flop but he's probably the best in that team atm…

He's a lazy sleeper usually.
Not needed.

 

[happy_tiger]

Taupau is a hype machine.
Isn't delivering for Manly atm.

Addo Car is a yes.
Lodge for ISC! Lol…

We could use Austin.

Taupau had 15 TB's last night 240 odd metres and 43 tackles

He's definitely not doing that most weeks.

Its the first time he has played real big minutes

He rolled his ankle up in Gladstone , probably from lolling so much when Jackson planted one on DCE

 

[upthetigers]

Taupau is a hype machine.
Isn't delivering for Manly atm.

Addo Car is a yes.
Lodge for ISC! Lol…

We could use Austin.

Taupau had 15 TB's last night 240 odd metres and 43 tackles

He's definitely not doing that most weeks.

He's a flop but he's probably the best in that team atm…

He's a lazy sleeper usually.
Not needed.

Yep, he has a lot of errors in his game too. Cause he's always looking to offload.

 

[cqtiger]

The need for speed.
JAC
In reality none will come back, methinks

 

[king_sirro]

I'd take Tedesco yesterday

 

[newtiger]

I picked Teddy I still think he is a super star, i’d just wire his jaw together so he couldn’t do any of those stupid press conferences.

 

[Demps]

Taupau had 15 TB's last night 240 odd metres and 43 tackles

He's definitely not doing that most weeks.

He's a flop but he's probably the best in that team atm…

He's a lazy sleeper usually.
Not needed.

Yep, he has a lot of errors in his game too. Cause he's always looking to offload.

He was good @ the tigers and first year at Manly…
I'd take him as an impact bench player but yeah, expecting a lot of errors and penalties.
He's a very marketable player & supposedly the strongest bench & deadlift around but yeah, we can do without...

Addo-Carr on the other hand, what a beast,

 

[Russell]

I'll second the question - Why isn't there a "Don't want any of that list back" vote?

There never is - frustrating.

 

[greatodensraven]

Teddy & Addo Carr.

 

[Swordy]

None of them fit our new culture, potentially JAC only. Teddy on potential talent, but he doesn't fit if it's not all about him.

 

[Tigerstruck]

Teddy & Addo Carr.

x2

Back Five:

1\. Teddy
2\. Thommo
3\. Marsters
4\. MCK/Naiqama
5\. JAC

 

[Chicken_Faced_Killa]

JAC is the obvious choice. Quality winger which is an area we need to improve.