Jason Taylor isn't signed for next year...

[Guest]

he is close to doing a really good job…....

he is making to many dumb mistakes.....

and you wonder why people dont take your opinions seriously Steve.... :blush:

And yet those same people reckon a Rankin/Halatau dummy half combination with Lovett in the centres is a great move.

I think I'd rather not be taken seriously.

Top stuff there mate.

Don't worry steve, you're not taken seriously :laughing:

 

[stevetiger]

I think Taylor has been considerably worse than all those coaches excluding Lamb.

hahaha "considerably"? Feel free at any time to rationally explain that one.

Taylor ball & the Farah debacle. Those two put him pretty close to the top in my opinion.

Fair enough. Sheens did have a considerably better run. But Pearce had the Field and McGuinness cocaine scandals plus chose to resign whilst Potter had his own Farah (and Benji) debacle. Neither developed talent the way Taylor has nor did they manage injury the way he has. Taylor ball was a half-season thing that he had the humility to scrap after his players complained about it, although the bombs at the end of sets seems to still be a staple of our play. It took Sheens 2.5 years to move John Morris from the halves completely. Plenty of coaches would rather cut off their nose to spite their face when their tactics are questioned.

This is a fair point. Taylor to me seems stubborn or stupid but maybe a lot of coaches are like that.

Sheens though transformed our team and came up with the right game plan to give us good seasons. He also never had the same problems managing the team.

I also think Morris in the halves was terrible but it's not as bad as playing Robbie in reserves. Hopefully the Robbie selection doesn't go on as long as the Morris selection did.

 

[tig_prmz]

Lewis was moved on from Penrith without fuss, so was Stewart at Manly…Only difference is other clubs wanted them.

Jennings, Soward, Peats, Morgan, Gibbs, Heigington, Galloway. All without a fuss. Farah and his supporters seem to thin he's above all that though.

definitely not a farah supporter but he is probably one of two real legends in the short history of this club. all the other players you mentioned don't compare to what farah is (or was) to the club.

still doesn't give him the right to make the comments he's made. was and always will be egocentric and smartarse.