Oh please spare me the "he's made it but we haven't so spare the criticism"
That's just BS.
They're professionals as are actors singers and politicians, in the public eye and under public scrutiny
Getting flustered over a comment Mark...For a person who I thought knows a few things in life you should give credit where its due...and yes he has made it and I don't care to much about polititians or actors....
Talk about avoiding the point... If we go by your logic how long should we give him credit for getting to the level he's a and we're not at?
And when do we start evaluating and criticising or praising his current efforts?
I don't care about pollies singers or actors either but theyre under public scrutiny for their performance just as Josh and all.pro.players are and to suggest otherwise is ridiculous
You can get personal and throw out words like "flustered" & " I thought you knew more" just shows you got nothing really other then give him credit for getting
to a level we didn't reach... I think we do that by buying memberships and attending games, because without us they have nothing
HE may be in the public eye and get scrutenised for his performance,but at what level do you stop personally name calling and degrading him ….that's the point Ink and I have got plenty not nothing when it comes to morals.....
As for membership,merchandise and support,I pay mine as do others,I love everything WTs...but I draw the line on belittling or personal name calling players or coaches on a public forum,particularly if someone is down on their form or has personal issues...I have given my opinion of Josh through this thread to the point that I said he is not at NRL level at the moment,however his form prior to coming here was good,even to the point of SOO selection..
But as I said it is my choice to scutinise his performance as I have just mentioned in a respectful manner...
He is still worth something to the right club ...however WT's aren't that club ...especially for that sort of money
I agree the money WTs paid is way overs,but that's not JRs fault...we may not be the club he should be at,but he is doing his best after a horrific run of injuries and his off field issues...he can be fantastic in CC for the younger ones,its just his price tag that affects everyone at the moment...
But that's the problem for me ....many of us were saying when he signed he won't mix well with Brooks and was having injury issues
Why can't the so called "experts" at our club see these things
Things look different now , but how we can be going into 2020 without an NRL standard hooker is beyond belief
He was a PR signing