JT HAS NO CLUE - JUST ASK RANKIN

[GNR4LIFE]

Just a thought. But maybe the fact we didn't beat the Dragons by 50 was evidence that we aren't a better side than what people claim. Again just a thought.

 

[Snake]

2 points out of the top 8.

 

[stevetiger]

Just a thought. But maybe the fact we didn't beat the Dragons by 50 was evidence that we aren't a better side than what people claim. Again just a thought.

Or we are a worse coached team ? I mean there were probably 12 points against us just by playing Lovett in the centres.

We also had the SOO hooker in reserve grade.

With that going against us we still looked a lot lot better than Saints. There were two tries that Moses was involved in that to me shows how good we can be. Naiqama ran a beautiful line and Moses threw a beautiful ball when there was a little bit of space created just by the speed of our play. The run that Moses made and then offloaded to Aloiai was also pretty impressive.

Those plays show talent in areas that I've heard that we are weak in.

I rate our squad. We have talent all over the park.

 

[tigerman80]

Just a thought. But maybe the fact we didn't beat the Dragons by 50 was evidence that we aren't a better side than what people claim. Again just a thought.

Again you will go round in circles, blame everyone but just wont call a spade a spade. Lets talk about the Dragons game alone, and you reckon a decent coach would have done what JT done.

1\. No back on the bench - yet moves rankin to hooker
2\. Lovett to the centres (cost us 12 points)
3\. Edwards meant to play hooker ( cant even cut it as a second rower in first grade).

These baffling decisions that JT comes up with are the reason i cant see him as our long term option and hope he isnt around next year. But trying to defend me by saying our roster isnt that good, really. Weve pretty much been injury free, our team is almost the same week in week out. Moses, brooks and tedesco have played almost 2 years together now with the rest of our backline. We should be top "9".

 

[tigerman80]

I would take JT over McGregor, McFadden and probably Nathan Brown so there are worse in the competition lets be honest. The reality is he is a battler and has spent enough time as a FG coach for it to be evident he is below average.

We need to grow up as a club/supporter base and look to more proven coaches with a better track record. I would be targeting Cleary, Maguire, Brad Arthur, Hassler. This Farah vs Taylor battle has clouded minds. Farah, whilst a club legend is past his best on big cash and Taylor is a below standard first grade coach.

Nearly all of what you say i agree with i would take any of the coaches you mention as an upgrade on what we have with Brad Arthur as a preference with Cleary 2nd choice hassler would also be ok we need to get a decent coach what we have is holding the club back

Yes but look at what McGregor and Brown have playing roster wise. We have a much better roster than both of them and we are still sitting behind the dragons and got beaten by newcastle. The thing keeping us alive is our brillance in attack. For me i will judge JT on our defence. Thats probably why he was hired and what he claimed he would fix. Sitting second last in defence and getting worse. Honestly watching the gsmes live, i dont understsnd how our edge defence and in particular our right hand side is so bad yet not accountable for it. So i agree lets get an experienced coach who can take full control with no baggage or hidden agendas. That probably means Farah has to go too and so be it. One point i will say is thAt for a new coach to achieve success i think our management need to get fully behind him and back him 100%, in fairness to JT i dont think he ever really had that from management. This whole Farah thing is either them throwing JT under a bus, or getting him to do the dirty work for them.

I stopped reading when you said we are still behind the Dragons which is a lie.

Oh your right my whole argument goes the down the drain because we have the same points as the dragons but ahead on points differential. Another one who just follows me around, do you and that insane imbecile take in turns lol. Must be a boring life old man.

 

[cqtiger]

Nearly all of what you say i agree with i would take any of the coaches you mention as an upgrade on what we have with Brad Arthur as a preference with Cleary 2nd choice hassler would also be ok we need to get a decent coach what we have is holding the club back

Yes but look at what McGregor and Brown have playing roster wise. We have a much better roster than both of them and we are still sitting behind the dragons and got beaten by newcastle. The thing keeping us alive is our brillance in attack. For me i will judge JT on our defence. Thats probably why he was hired and what he claimed he would fix. Sitting second last in defence and getting worse. Honestly watching the gsmes live, i dont understsnd how our edge defence and in particular our right hand side is so bad yet not accountable for it. So i agree lets get an experienced coach who can take full control with no baggage or hidden agendas. That probably means Farah has to go too and so be it. One point i will say is thAt for a new coach to achieve success i think our management need to get fully behind him and back him 100%, in fairness to JT i dont think he ever really had that from management. This whole Farah thing is either them throwing JT under a bus, or getting him to do the dirty work for them.

I stopped reading when you said we are still behind the Dragons which is a lie.

Oh your right my whole argument goes the down the drain because we have the same points as the dragons but ahead on points differential. Another one who just follows me around, do you and that insane imbecile take in turns lol. Must be a boring life old man.

Why the argument when you were caught out making an inaccurate statement. Check the competition ladder, we are in above the dragons. This is what happens when you post on emotion. Double check what you are going to post before you hit the 'Submit' button.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Nearly all of what you say i agree with i would take any of the coaches you mention as an upgrade on what we have with Brad Arthur as a preference with Cleary 2nd choice hassler would also be ok we need to get a decent coach what we have is holding the club back

Yes but look at what McGregor and Brown have playing roster wise. We have a much better roster than both of them and we are still sitting behind the dragons and got beaten by newcastle. The thing keeping us alive is our brillance in attack. For me i will judge JT on our defence. Thats probably why he was hired and what he claimed he would fix. Sitting second last in defence and getting worse. Honestly watching the gsmes live, i dont understsnd how our edge defence and in particular our right hand side is so bad yet not accountable for it. So i agree lets get an experienced coach who can take full control with no baggage or hidden agendas. That probably means Farah has to go too and so be it. One point i will say is thAt for a new coach to achieve success i think our management need to get fully behind him and back him 100%, in fairness to JT i dont think he ever really had that from management. This whole Farah thing is either them throwing JT under a bus, or getting him to do the dirty work for them.

I stopped reading when you said we are still behind the Dragons which is a lie.

Oh your right my whole argument goes the down the drain because we have the same points as the dragons but ahead on points differential. Another one who just follows me around, do you and that insane imbecile take in turns lol. Must be a boring life old man.

Lol im younger than you.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Apologies TM80\. You pass yourself off as such an expert, i thought maybe you'd have known the actual state of the ladder before shooting your mouth.

 

[tigerman80]

Yes but look at what McGregor and Brown have playing roster wise. We have a much better roster than both of them and we are still sitting behind the dragons and got beaten by newcastle. The thing keeping us alive is our brillance in attack. For me i will judge JT on our defence. Thats probably why he was hired and what he claimed he would fix. Sitting second last in defence and getting worse. Honestly watching the gsmes live, i dont understsnd how our edge defence and in particular our right hand side is so bad yet not accountable for it. So i agree lets get an experienced coach who can take full control with no baggage or hidden agendas. That probably means Farah has to go too and so be it. One point i will say is thAt for a new coach to achieve success i think our management need to get fully behind him and back him 100%, in fairness to JT i dont think he ever really had that from management. This whole Farah thing is either them throwing JT under a bus, or getting him to do the dirty work for them.

I stopped reading when you said we are still behind the Dragons which is a lie.

Oh your right my whole argument goes the down the drain because we have the same points as the dragons but ahead on points differential. Another one who just follows me around, do you and that insane imbecile take in turns lol. Must be a boring life old man.

Why the argument when you were caught out making an inaccurate statement. Check the competition ladder, we are in above the dragons. This is what happens when you post on emotion. Double check what you are going to post before you hit the 'Submit' button.

Im sorry for upsetting you, yes we are 10th And they are 11th, you guys caught me out real good lol. Im glad you agree with my other statements in that post :roll

 

[Love_the_WestsTigers]

Probably because the plan going in was for Edwards to play hooker but he had to be used cover the injuries to Grant/Lawrence.

Yes Edward's at hooker :roll

Yes and thats because Taylor has seen him there in ISP on a couple of occasions getting to dummy half before the hooker got there

All a joke this recent selection, Felise was going top gun and get gets dropped for a bloke who under performs in ISP at best

all a shamble

 

[stryker]

Just a thought. But maybe the fact we didn't beat the Dragons by 50 was evidence that we aren't a better side than what people claim. Again just a thought.

Yeah you're right. Totally unorganised without a proper number 9.

 

[tigerman80]

Apologies TM80\. You pass yourself off as such an expert, i thought maybe you'd have known the actual state of the ladder before shooting your mouth.

Im glad you agree with everything else i said, but must be hard to bring yourself round to admit most of it is true lol. Younger than me, and you already have lonely old man syndrome, gee life must be hard lol. I could almost get you for stalking soon lol. All i have to do is post and bam you crawl out from the gutter to shoot it down lol.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Apologies TM80\. You pass yourself off as such an expert, i thought maybe you'd have known the actual state of the ladder before shooting your mouth.

Im glad you agree with everything else i said, but must be hard to bring yourself round to admit most of it is true lol. Younger than me, and you already have lonely old man syndrome, gee life must be hard lol. I could almost get you for stalking soon lol. All i have to do is post and bam you crawl out from the gutter to shoot it down lol.

As i said, i stopped reading after your second or third sentence so i have no idea what your other points were because they weren't worth reading after your lie about us being below the Dragons.

 

[innsaneink]

Yes but look at what McGregor and Brown have playing roster wise. We have a much better roster than both of them and we are still sitting behind the dragons and got beaten by newcastle. The thing keeping us alive is our brillance in attack. For me i will judge JT on our defence. Thats probably why he was hired and what he claimed he would fix. Sitting second last in defence and getting worse. Honestly watching the gsmes live, i dont understsnd how our edge defence and in particular our right hand side is so bad yet not accountable for it. So i agree lets get an experienced coach who can take full control with no baggage or hidden agendas. That probably means Farah has to go too and so be it. One point i will say is thAt for a new coach to achieve success i think our management need to get fully behind him and back him 100%, in fairness to JT i dont think he ever really had that from management. This whole Farah thing is either them throwing JT under a bus, or getting him to do the dirty work for them.

I stopped reading when you said we are still behind the Dragons which is a lie.

Oh your right my whole argument goes the down the drain because we have the same points as the dragons but ahead on points differential. Another one who just follows me around, do you and that insane imbecile take in turns lol. Must be a boring life old man.

Why the argument when you were caught out making an inaccurate statement. Check the competition ladder, we are in above the dragons. This is what happens when you post on emotion. Double check what you are going to post before you hit the 'Submit' button.

Not to mention the selective quoting in the OP, the crap about Rankin and hooker, JT losing the shed…blah blah
As they say... Don't let the truth get in the way of a good story... And he has the hide to suggest others have a boring life after his selective quoting.... Hypocrisy of the highest order.

Exposing liars and BS artists like TM80 isn't boring.

 

[tigerman80]

I stopped reading when you said we are still behind the Dragons which is a lie.

Oh your right my whole argument goes the down the drain because we have the same points as the dragons but ahead on points differential. Another one who just follows me around, do you and that insane imbecile take in turns lol. Must be a boring life old man.

Why the argument when you were caught out making an inaccurate statement. Check the competition ladder, we are in above the dragons. This is what happens when you post on emotion. Double check what you are going to post before you hit the 'Submit' button.

Not to mention the selective quoting in the OP, the crap about Rankin and hooker, JT losing the shed…blah blah
As they say... Don't let the truth get in the way of a good story... And he has the hide to suggest others have a boring life after his selective quoting.... Hypocrisy of the highest order.

Exposing liars and BS artists like TM80 isn't boring.

Insaneidiot nobody cares what you and your girlfriend GRNLOWLIFE write. You will defend JT in right and wrong no matter what he does. Selective quoting, Rankin clearly states that its a beat up that farah isnt getting enough quality ball to the halves. His words not mine mate lol. Your so called defence guru has us second last in defence or is that also farahs fault. You just sound stupid and morinic when you defend JT no matter what. Lovett at centres please lol, Edwards and Rankin playing hooker please, our right side defence please. Im a tigers supporter and want whats best for my team, your a JT supporter, big difference between us. Your obsession over my posts and JT is revolting, now once again go away.

 

[Cosimo_Zaretti]

I can accept that it's probably time for Robbie, but Dene Halatau does not have an 80 minute game any more so that leaves us with a 20-30 minute hole.

I can't accept that we have more 'cohesiveness' with Jordan Rankin at dummy half than with Robbie coming off the bench for a spell, and I don't see any impact in Joel Edwards.

You'd really have to be determined to get rid of a player before you'd replace them with Joel Edwards and then have to run Rankin at hooker.

The glaring flaw in Taylor's plan is Halatau's minutes.

 

[GNR4LIFE]

I'd have JJ ahead of Edwards.

 

[Needaname]

Oh your right my whole argument goes the down the drain because we have the same points as the dragons but ahead on points differential. Another one who just follows me around, do you and that insane imbecile take in turns lol. Must be a boring life old man.

Why the argument when you were caught out making an inaccurate statement. Check the competition ladder, we are in above the dragons. This is what happens when you post on emotion. Double check what you are going to post before you hit the 'Submit' button.

Not to mention the selective quoting in the OP, the crap about Rankin and hooker, JT losing the shed…blah blah
As they say... Don't let the truth get in the way of a good story... And he has the hide to suggest others have a boring life after his selective quoting.... Hypocrisy of the highest order.

Exposing liars and BS artists like TM80 isn't boring.

Insaneidiot nobody cares what you and your girlfriend GRNLOWLIFE write. You will defend JT in right and wrong no matter what he does. Selective quoting, Rankin clearly states that its a beat up that farah isnt getting enough quality ball to the halves. His words not mine mate lol. Your so called defence guru has us second last in defence or is that also farahs fault. You just sound stupid and morinic when you defend JT no matter what. Lovett at centres please lol, Edwards and Rankin playing hooker please, our right side defence please. Im a tigers supporter and want whats best for my team, your a JT supporter, big difference between us. Your obsession over my posts and JT is revolting, now once again go away.

How old are you,
No really?

 

[stevetiger]

Just a thought. But maybe the fact we didn't beat the Dragons by 50 was evidence that we aren't a better side than what people claim. Again just a thought.

Yeah you're right. Totally unorganised without a proper number 9.

These types of comments stating that we aren't that good a team are funny aren't they.

 

[stevetiger]

I'd have JJ ahead of Edwards.

Definitely. It'd be better though just to play Robbie at 9.