Live game thread - Tigers V Cowboys

[Tiger5150]

My biggest issue with Reynolds, is things like when Brooks was tackled and played the ball on the 5th tackle during the 1st half. We had 2 forwards put on a play on the last, this is when you need your 2nd playmaker and most experienced player to step in and demand the ball. These sorts of things happen too often with Reynolds, he is not there when he should be, if it was a one off then fair enough but it is not a one off.

I saw Brooks get tackled three times on the 5th, leaving the sixth play tackle option up to someone else.
I really think we need a half that can manage the game, even the sixth play, because it's not Brooks specialty.


Like Reynolds who TWICE passed it to a prop on the 6th? (lucky on the first that the Cowboys couldbt believe it).

Was it Anasta who gave it to Reynolds for not taking control when Brooks was tackled? Seems a terribly individual action to not be in position to takeover from your halves partner when he is tackled on the fifth tackle.


Exactly. Reynolds had a terrible game. He was very lucky that our attack and their defence in the first half overrode his stupidity. He got SO lucky on that first try, Brooks was calling for it on the left and on his right he had both props and Twal on the last, and he passed to Musgrove. That thing he was doing screaming up out of the line, in our own ten was terrifying me, luckily Cowboys were so bad they couldnt capitalise on it and he stopped doing it after no doubt a prompt from Madge at half time.

What I don't quite understand is we score 34 points in 40 minutes, ***mostly set up by Reynolds***, passes and kicks, and people are still bagging him. No one even made a break through his rushing out of the line in defence, in fact the opposition didn't even score a point. Yes, he threw an intercept, only because he was trying something which, if it connected was most certainly another Tigers try. With Reynolds starting, we've won by a margin and gone awful close to last years Grand Finalist. What more do you want?
And using an Anasta observation to bag a bloke? Says it all really.

You have a very different recollection of the first half than I do.

Try 1 REynolds gets a TA by screwing up and passing to a prop on the last (Brooks was calling for it left and as soon as Musgrove got it, Garner was pointing back for the pass, it was an error).

Try 2 REynolds passes it to Douiehi who puts BJ in space. Reynolds did nothing other than standard catch and pass.

Try 3 Reynolds a panicked catch and pass to Nofo after Grants kick into the back of the cowboys. Try set up by great work by Nofo and Mbye, nothing to do with Reynolds.

Try 4 Reynolds did zero and didnt touch the ball, Grant sets up Alioia.

Try 5 Reynolds nowhere near it, doesnt touch the ball. Grant -> Brooks -> Mbye ->Jennings.

Try 6 - Reynolds kick results in a try. Not a good kick, didnt go to hand, landed 20m short of the line, but it was his kick and it did result in a try.

So Reynolds screwed up and resulted in the first try and then puts in a mediocre kick on the back of a great Nofo break that after some pinball results in a try.......but the 34points were ***mostly*** set up by REynolds? You might have to walk me through how that works.

 

[Tiger5150]

My biggest issue with Reynolds, is things like when Brooks was tackled and played the ball on the 5th tackle during the 1st half. We had 2 forwards put on a play on the last, this is when you need your 2nd playmaker and most experienced player to step in and demand the ball. These sorts of things happen too often with Reynolds, he is not there when he should be, if it was a one off then fair enough but it is not a one off.

I saw Brooks get tackled three times on the 5th, leaving the sixth play tackle option up to someone else.
I really think we need a half that can manage the game, even the sixth play, because it's not Brooks specialty.


Like Reynolds who TWICE passed it to a prop on the 6th? (lucky on the first that the Cowboys couldbt believe it).

Was it Anasta who gave it to Reynolds for not taking control when Brooks was tackled? Seems a terribly individual action to not be in position to takeover from your halves partner when he is tackled on the fifth tackle.


Exactly. Reynolds had a terrible game. He was very lucky that our attack and their defence in the first half overrode his stupidity. He got SO lucky on that first try, Brooks was calling for it on the left and on his right he had both props and Twal on the last, and he passed to Musgrove. That thing he was doing screaming up out of the line, in our own ten was terrifying me, luckily Cowboys were so bad they couldnt capitalise on it and he stopped doing it after no doubt a prompt from Madge at half time.

What I don't quite understand is we score 34 points in 40 minutes, mostly set up by Reynolds, passes and kicks, and people are still bagging him. No one even made a break through his rushing out of the line in defence, in fact the opposition didn't even score a point. Yes, he threw an intercept, only because he was trying something which, if it connected was most certainly another Tigers try. With Reynolds starting, we've won by a margin and gone awful close to last years Grand Finalist. What more do you want?
And using an Anasta observation to bag a bloke? Says it all really.

Reynolds TWICE passed to a prop on the last tackle, Kicked on the 3rd when we were getting pumped, threw an intercept that was NEVER going to hit Garner and continually put defenders around him underpressure all night, All this from our no6, a playmaker. It was a poor game and was hidden by the result.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

My biggest issue with Reynolds, is things like when Brooks was tackled and played the ball on the 5th tackle during the 1st half. We had 2 forwards put on a play on the last, this is when you need your 2nd playmaker and most experienced player to step in and demand the ball. These sorts of things happen too often with Reynolds, he is not there when he should be, if it was a one off then fair enough but it is not a one off.

I saw Brooks get tackled three times on the 5th, leaving the sixth play tackle option up to someone else.
I really think we need a half that can manage the game, even the sixth play, because it's not Brooks specialty.


Like Reynolds who TWICE passed it to a prop on the 6th? (lucky on the first that the Cowboys couldbt believe it).

Was it Anasta who gave it to Reynolds for not taking control when Brooks was tackled? Seems a terribly individual action to not be in position to takeover from your halves partner when he is tackled on the fifth tackle.


Exactly. Reynolds had a terrible game. He was very lucky that our attack and their defence in the first half overrode his stupidity. He got SO lucky on that first try, Brooks was calling for it on the left and on his right he had both props and Twal on the last, and he passed to Musgrove. That thing he was doing screaming up out of the line, in our own ten was terrifying me, luckily Cowboys were so bad they couldnt capitalise on it and he stopped doing it after no doubt a prompt from Madge at half time.

What I don't quite understand is we score 34 points in 40 minutes, mostly set up by Reynolds, passes and kicks, and people are still bagging him. No one even made a break through his rushing out of the line in defence, in fact the opposition didn't even score a point. Yes, he threw an intercept, only because he was trying something which, if it connected was most certainly another Tigers try. With Reynolds starting, we've won by a margin and gone awful close to last years Grand Finalist. What more do you want?
And using an Anasta observation to bag a bloke? Says it all really.

Reynolds dropped the ball from the kick off resulting in us having to defend 3 sets on our tryline. His poorly executed kick on the 3 tackle straight to the Cowboy player put the team under further pressure. His continued rushing out of the line was noticeable. My point is that all this may go unnoticed in a win against a team travelling poorly. The top teams would have taken notice. A player on $800k should not be making these fundamental errors. I'd rather promote a rookie and let that player learn through making rookie mistakes.

 

[cochise]

My biggest issue with Reynolds, is things like when Brooks was tackled and played the ball on the 5th tackle during the 1st half. We had 2 forwards put on a play on the last, this is when you need your 2nd playmaker and most experienced player to step in and demand the ball. These sorts of things happen too often with Reynolds, he is not there when he should be, if it was a one off then fair enough but it is not a one off.

I saw Brooks get tackled three times on the 5th, leaving the sixth play tackle option up to someone else.
I really think we need a half that can manage the game, even the sixth play, because it's not Brooks specialty.


Like Reynolds who TWICE passed it to a prop on the 6th? (lucky on the first that the Cowboys couldbt believe it).

Was it Anasta who gave it to Reynolds for not taking control when Brooks was tackled? Seems a terribly individual action to not be in position to takeover from your halves partner when he is tackled on the fifth tackle.


Exactly. Reynolds had a terrible game. He was very lucky that our attack and their defence in the first half overrode his stupidity. He got SO lucky on that first try, Brooks was calling for it on the left and on his right he had both props and Twal on the last, and he passed to Musgrove. That thing he was doing screaming up out of the line, in our own ten was terrifying me, luckily Cowboys were so bad they couldnt capitalise on it and he stopped doing it after no doubt a prompt from Madge at half time.

What I don't quite understand is we score 34 points in 40 minutes, ***mostly set up by Reynolds***, passes and kicks, and people are still bagging him. No one even made a break through his rushing out of the line in defence, in fact the opposition didn't even score a point. Yes, he threw an intercept, only because he was trying something which, if it connected was most certainly another Tigers try. With Reynolds starting, we've won by a margin and gone awful close to last years Grand Finalist. What more do you want?
And using an Anasta observation to bag a bloke? Says it all really.

You have a very different recollection of the first half than I do.

Try 1 REynolds gets a TA by screwing up and passing to a prop on the last (Brooks was calling for it left and as soon as Musgrove got it, Garner was pointing back for the pass, it was an error).

Try 2 REynolds passes it to Douiehi who puts BJ in space. Reynolds did nothing other than standard catch and pass.

Try 3 Reynolds a panicked catch and pass to Nofo after Grants kick into the back of the cowboys. Try set up by great work by Nofo and Mbye, nothing to do with Reynolds.

Try 4 Reynolds did zero and didnt touch the ball, Grant sets up Alioia.

Try 5 Reynolds nowhere near it, doesnt touch the ball. Grant -Brooks -Mbye ->Jennings.

Try 6 - Reynolds kick results in a try. Not a good kick, didnt go to hand, landed 20m short of the line, but it was his kick and it did result in a try.

So Reynolds screwed up and resulted in the first try and then puts in a mediocre kick on the back of a great Nofo break that after some pinball results in a try.......but the 34points were ***mostly*** set up by REynolds? You might have to walk me through how that works.

Very well said mate, the Cowboys defense was non existent in that 1st half. The ball Reynolds threw for the 1st try was a very nice pass, but outside of that I thought he was terrible.

 

[pawsandclaws1]

My biggest issue with Reynolds, is things like when Brooks was tackled and played the ball on the 5th tackle during the 1st half. We had 2 forwards put on a play on the last, this is when you need your 2nd playmaker and most experienced player to step in and demand the ball. These sorts of things happen too often with Reynolds, he is not there when he should be, if it was a one off then fair enough but it is not a one off.

I saw Brooks get tackled three times on the 5th, leaving the sixth play tackle option up to someone else.
I really think we need a half that can manage the game, even the sixth play, because it's not Brooks specialty.


Like Reynolds who TWICE passed it to a prop on the 6th? (lucky on the first that the Cowboys couldbt believe it).

Was it Anasta who gave it to Reynolds for not taking control when Brooks was tackled? Seems a terribly individual action to not be in position to takeover from your halves partner when he is tackled on the fifth tackle.


Exactly. Reynolds had a terrible game. He was very lucky that our attack and their defence in the first half overrode his stupidity. He got SO lucky on that first try, Brooks was calling for it on the left and on his right he had both props and Twal on the last, and he passed to Musgrove. That thing he was doing screaming up out of the line, in our own ten was terrifying me, luckily Cowboys were so bad they couldnt capitalise on it and he stopped doing it after no doubt a prompt from Madge at half time.

What I don't quite understand is we score 34 points in 40 minutes, mostly set up by Reynolds, passes and kicks, and people are still bagging him. No one even made a break through his rushing out of the line in defence, in fact the opposition didn't even score a point. Yes, he threw an intercept, only because he was trying something which, if it connected was most certainly another Tigers try. With Reynolds starting, we've won by a margin and gone awful close to last years Grand Finalist. What more do you want?
And using an Anasta observation to bag a bloke? Says it all really.

Don't let your feelings for Anasta hide the fact Reynolds was not where he should have been to assist his halves partner. Anasta was correct in his criticism. And from what Maguire said after the game, throwing a low percentage pass and conceding more points instead of closing out the game was inconsistent with his expectations.

 

[hobbo1]

My biggest issue with Reynolds, is things like when Brooks was tackled and played the ball on the 5th tackle during the 1st half. We had 2 forwards put on a play on the last, this is when you need your 2nd playmaker and most experienced player to step in and demand the ball. These sorts of things happen too often with Reynolds, he is not there when he should be, if it was a one off then fair enough but it is not a one off.

I saw Brooks get tackled three times on the 5th, leaving the sixth play tackle option up to someone else.
I really think we need a half that can manage the game, even the sixth play, because it's not Brooks specialty.


Like Reynolds who TWICE passed it to a prop on the 6th? (lucky on the first that the Cowboys couldbt believe it).

Was it Anasta who gave it to Reynolds for not taking control when Brooks was tackled? Seems a terribly individual action to not be in position to takeover from your halves partner when he is tackled on the fifth tackle.


Exactly. Reynolds had a terrible game. He was very lucky that our attack and their defence in the first half overrode his stupidity. He got SO lucky on that first try, Brooks was calling for it on the left and on his right he had both props and Twal on the last, and he passed to Musgrove. That thing he was doing screaming up out of the line, in our own ten was terrifying me, luckily Cowboys were so bad they couldnt capitalise on it and he stopped doing it after no doubt a prompt from Madge at half time.

What I don't quite understand is we score 34 points in 40 minutes, ***mostly set up by Reynolds***, passes and kicks, and people are still bagging him. No one even made a break through his rushing out of the line in defence, in fact the opposition didn't even score a point. Yes, he threw an intercept, only because he was trying something which, if it connected was most certainly another Tigers try. With Reynolds starting, we've won by a margin and gone awful close to last years Grand Finalist. What more do you want?
And using an Anasta observation to bag a bloke? Says it all really.

You have a very different recollection of the first half than I do.

Try 1 REynolds gets a TA by screwing up and passing to a prop on the last (Brooks was calling for it left and as soon as Musgrove got it, Garner was pointing back for the pass, it was an error).

Try 2 REynolds passes it to Douiehi who puts BJ in space. Reynolds did nothing other than standard catch and pass.

Try 3 Reynolds a panicked catch and pass to Nofo after Grants kick into the back of the cowboys. Try set up by great work by Nofo and Mbye, nothing to do with Reynolds.

Try 4 Reynolds did zero and didnt touch the ball, Grant sets up Alioia.

Try 5 Reynolds nowhere near it, doesnt touch the ball. Grant -Brooks -Mbye ->Jennings.

Try 6 - Reynolds kick results in a try. Not a good kick, didnt go to hand, landed 20m short of the line, but it was his kick and it did result in a try.

So Reynolds screwed up and resulted in the first try and then puts in a mediocre kick on the back of a great Nofo break that after some pinball results in a try.......but the 34points were ***mostly*** set up by REynolds? You might have to walk me through how that works.

Very well said mate, the Cowboys defense was non existent in that 1st half. The ball Reynolds threw for the 1st try was a very nice pass, but outside of that I thought he was terrible.

Chee Kam deserves a mention for TRY 6
That was a beautiful deft touch !

 

[Guest]

My biggest issue with Reynolds, is things like when Brooks was tackled and played the ball on the 5th tackle during the 1st half. We had 2 forwards put on a play on the last, this is when you need your 2nd playmaker and most experienced player to step in and demand the ball. These sorts of things happen too often with Reynolds, he is not there when he should be, if it was a one off then fair enough but it is not a one off.

I saw Brooks get tackled three times on the 5th, leaving the sixth play tackle option up to someone else.
I really think we need a half that can manage the game, even the sixth play, because it's not Brooks specialty.


Like Reynolds who TWICE passed it to a prop on the 6th? (lucky on the first that the Cowboys couldbt believe it).

Was it Anasta who gave it to Reynolds for not taking control when Brooks was tackled? Seems a terribly individual action to not be in position to takeover from your halves partner when he is tackled on the fifth tackle.


Exactly. Reynolds had a terrible game. He was very lucky that our attack and their defence in the first half overrode his stupidity. He got SO lucky on that first try, Brooks was calling for it on the left and on his right he had both props and Twal on the last, and he passed to Musgrove. That thing he was doing screaming up out of the line, in our own ten was terrifying me, luckily Cowboys were so bad they couldnt capitalise on it and he stopped doing it after no doubt a prompt from Madge at half time.

What I don't quite understand is we score 34 points in 40 minutes, ***mostly set up by Reynolds***, passes and kicks, and people are still bagging him. No one even made a break through his rushing out of the line in defence, in fact the opposition didn't even score a point. Yes, he threw an intercept, only because he was trying something which, if it connected was most certainly another Tigers try. With Reynolds starting, we've won by a margin and gone awful close to last years Grand Finalist. What more do you want?
And using an Anasta observation to bag a bloke? Says it all really.

You have a very different recollection of the first half than I do.

Try 1 REynolds gets a TA by screwing up and passing to a prop on the last (Brooks was calling for it left and as soon as Musgrove got it, Garner was pointing back for the pass, it was an error).

Try 2 REynolds passes it to Douiehi who puts BJ in space. Reynolds did nothing other than standard catch and pass.

Try 3 Reynolds a panicked catch and pass to Nofo after Grants kick into the back of the cowboys. Try set up by great work by Nofo and Mbye, nothing to do with Reynolds.

Try 4 Reynolds did zero and didnt touch the ball, Grant sets up Alioia.

Try 5 Reynolds nowhere near it, doesnt touch the ball. Grant -Brooks -Mbye ->Jennings.

Try 6 - Reynolds kick results in a try. Not a good kick, didnt go to hand, landed 20m short of the line, but it was his kick and it did result in a try.

So Reynolds screwed up and resulted in the first try and then puts in a mediocre kick on the back of a great Nofo break that after some pinball results in a try.......but the 34points were ***mostly*** set up by REynolds? You might have to walk me through how that works.

Very well said mate, the Cowboys defense was non existent in that 1st half. The ball Reynolds threw for the 1st try was a very nice pass, but outside of that I thought he was terrible.

Chee Kam deserves a mention for TRY 6
That was a beautiful deft touch !

I would argue no one else in the comp could have set that try up:joy:

 

[Geo]

Try 6 - Reynolds kick results in a try. Not a good kick, didnt go to hand, landed 20m short of the line, but it was his kick and it did result in a try.

I have to add that Chee-Kam with his eyes closed not even looking at the ball facing Marsters who was also not looking at the ball ..takes an enormous amount of skill..I would say no one before or after in the history of Rugbeh League could pull that off ever again..

 

[Geo]

My biggest issue with Reynolds, is things like when Brooks was tackled and played the ball on the 5th tackle during the 1st half. We had 2 forwards put on a play on the last, this is when you need your 2nd playmaker and most experienced player to step in and demand the ball. These sorts of things happen too often with Reynolds, he is not there when he should be, if it was a one off then fair enough but it is not a one off.

I saw Brooks get tackled three times on the 5th, leaving the sixth play tackle option up to someone else.
I really think we need a half that can manage the game, even the sixth play, because it's not Brooks specialty.


Like Reynolds who TWICE passed it to a prop on the 6th? (lucky on the first that the Cowboys couldbt believe it).

Was it Anasta who gave it to Reynolds for not taking control when Brooks was tackled? Seems a terribly individual action to not be in position to takeover from your halves partner when he is tackled on the fifth tackle.


Exactly. Reynolds had a terrible game. He was very lucky that our attack and their defence in the first half overrode his stupidity. He got SO lucky on that first try, Brooks was calling for it on the left and on his right he had both props and Twal on the last, and he passed to Musgrove. That thing he was doing screaming up out of the line, in our own ten was terrifying me, luckily Cowboys were so bad they couldnt capitalise on it and he stopped doing it after no doubt a prompt from Madge at half time.

What I don't quite understand is we score 34 points in 40 minutes, ***mostly set up by Reynolds***, passes and kicks, and people are still bagging him. No one even made a break through his rushing out of the line in defence, in fact the opposition didn't even score a point. Yes, he threw an intercept, only because he was trying something which, if it connected was most certainly another Tigers try. With Reynolds starting, we've won by a margin and gone awful close to last years Grand Finalist. What more do you want?
And using an Anasta observation to bag a bloke? Says it all really.

You have a very different recollection of the first half than I do.

Try 1 REynolds gets a TA by screwing up and passing to a prop on the last (Brooks was calling for it left and as soon as Musgrove got it, Garner was pointing back for the pass, it was an error).

Try 2 REynolds passes it to Douiehi who puts BJ in space. Reynolds did nothing other than standard catch and pass.

Try 3 Reynolds a panicked catch and pass to Nofo after Grants kick into the back of the cowboys. Try set up by great work by Nofo and Mbye, nothing to do with Reynolds.

Try 4 Reynolds did zero and didnt touch the ball, Grant sets up Alioia.

Try 5 Reynolds nowhere near it, doesnt touch the ball. Grant -Brooks -Mbye ->Jennings.

Try 6 - Reynolds kick results in a try. Not a good kick, didnt go to hand, landed 20m short of the line, but it was his kick and it did result in a try.

So Reynolds screwed up and resulted in the first try and then puts in a mediocre kick on the back of a great Nofo break that after some pinball results in a try.......but the 34points were ***mostly*** set up by REynolds? You might have to walk me through how that works.

Very well said mate, the Cowboys defense was non existent in that 1st half. The ball Reynolds threw for the 1st try was a very nice pass, but outside of that I thought he was terrible.

Chee Kam deserves a mention for TRY 6
That was a beautiful deft touch !

@willow beat me too it..

 

[hobbo1]

My biggest issue with Reynolds, is things like when Brooks was tackled and played the ball on the 5th tackle during the 1st half. We had 2 forwards put on a play on the last, this is when you need your 2nd playmaker and most experienced player to step in and demand the ball. These sorts of things happen too often with Reynolds, he is not there when he should be, if it was a one off then fair enough but it is not a one off.

I saw Brooks get tackled three times on the 5th, leaving the sixth play tackle option up to someone else.
I really think we need a half that can manage the game, even the sixth play, because it's not Brooks specialty.


Like Reynolds who TWICE passed it to a prop on the 6th? (lucky on the first that the Cowboys couldbt believe it).

Was it Anasta who gave it to Reynolds for not taking control when Brooks was tackled? Seems a terribly individual action to not be in position to takeover from your halves partner when he is tackled on the fifth tackle.


Exactly. Reynolds had a terrible game. He was very lucky that our attack and their defence in the first half overrode his stupidity. He got SO lucky on that first try, Brooks was calling for it on the left and on his right he had both props and Twal on the last, and he passed to Musgrove. That thing he was doing screaming up out of the line, in our own ten was terrifying me, luckily Cowboys were so bad they couldnt capitalise on it and he stopped doing it after no doubt a prompt from Madge at half time.

What I don't quite understand is we score 34 points in 40 minutes, ***mostly set up by Reynolds***, passes and kicks, and people are still bagging him. No one even made a break through his rushing out of the line in defence, in fact the opposition didn't even score a point. Yes, he threw an intercept, only because he was trying something which, if it connected was most certainly another Tigers try. With Reynolds starting, we've won by a margin and gone awful close to last years Grand Finalist. What more do you want?
And using an Anasta observation to bag a bloke? Says it all really.

You have a very different recollection of the first half than I do.

Try 1 REynolds gets a TA by screwing up and passing to a prop on the last (Brooks was calling for it left and as soon as Musgrove got it, Garner was pointing back for the pass, it was an error).

Try 2 REynolds passes it to Douiehi who puts BJ in space. Reynolds did nothing other than standard catch and pass.

Try 3 Reynolds a panicked catch and pass to Nofo after Grants kick into the back of the cowboys. Try set up by great work by Nofo and Mbye, nothing to do with Reynolds.

Try 4 Reynolds did zero and didnt touch the ball, Grant sets up Alioia.

Try 5 Reynolds nowhere near it, doesnt touch the ball. Grant -Brooks -Mbye ->Jennings.

Try 6 - Reynolds kick results in a try. Not a good kick, didnt go to hand, landed 20m short of the line, but it was his kick and it did result in a try.

So Reynolds screwed up and resulted in the first try and then puts in a mediocre kick on the back of a great Nofo break that after some pinball results in a try.......but the 34points were ***mostly*** set up by REynolds? You might have to walk me through how that works.

Very well said mate, the Cowboys defense was non existent in that 1st half. The ball Reynolds threw for the 1st try was a very nice pass, but outside of that I thought he was terrible.

Chee Kam deserves a mention for TRY 6
That was a beautiful deft touch !

@willow beat me too it..

I’m surprised West Ham haven’t spoke to his manager ..

@happy_tiger

 

[JC99]

Chee Kam is the best play maker ever. Assisted one off his foot without even looking and assisted one off his head against roosters in 2018 😂

 

[hobbo1]

Chee Kam is the best play maker ever. Assisted one off his foot without even looking and assisted one off his head against roosters in 2018 😂

Keep bagging him but he always produces ..
Don’t forget he single handedly won 2 games last year

 

[JC99]

Chee Kam is the best play maker ever. Assisted one off his foot without even looking and assisted one off his head against roosters in 2018 ?

Keep bagging him but he always produces ..
Don’t forget he single handedly won 2 games last year

He’s got some skills for sure. Never would’ve thought it when he first played for us he’s come a long way

 

[Geo]

Chee Kam is the best play maker ever. Assisted one off his foot without even looking and assisted one off his head against roosters in 2018 ?

Keep bagging him but he always produces ..
Don’t forget he single handedly won 2 games last year

He did drop it cold which led to a Cowgirls TRY next set..

 

[hobbo1]

Chee Kam is the best play maker ever. Assisted one off his foot without even looking and assisted one off his head against roosters in 2018 ?

Keep bagging him but he always produces ..
Don’t forget he single handedly won 2 games last year

He did drop it cold which led to a Cowgirls TRY next set..

Can’t always be perfect...
He’s won us more games than your mate
?

 

[tigerballs]

My biggest issue with Reynolds, is things like when Brooks was tackled and played the ball on the 5th tackle during the 1st half. We had 2 forwards put on a play on the last, this is when you need your 2nd playmaker and most experienced player to step in and demand the ball. These sorts of things happen too often with Reynolds, he is not there when he should be, if it was a one off then fair enough but it is not a one off.

I saw Brooks get tackled three times on the 5th, leaving the sixth play tackle option up to someone else.
I really think we need a half that can manage the game, even the sixth play, because it's not Brooks specialty.


Like Reynolds who TWICE passed it to a prop on the 6th? (lucky on the first that the Cowboys couldbt believe it).

Was it Anasta who gave it to Reynolds for not taking control when Brooks was tackled? Seems a terribly individual action to not be in position to takeover from your halves partner when he is tackled on the fifth tackle.


Exactly. Reynolds had a terrible game. He was very lucky that our attack and their defence in the first half overrode his stupidity. He got SO lucky on that first try, Brooks was calling for it on the left and on his right he had both props and Twal on the last, and he passed to Musgrove. That thing he was doing screaming up out of the line, in our own ten was terrifying me, luckily Cowboys were so bad they couldnt capitalise on it and he stopped doing it after no doubt a prompt from Madge at half time.

What I don't quite understand is we score 34 points in 40 minutes, ***mostly set up by Reynolds***, passes and kicks, and people are still bagging him. No one even made a break through his rushing out of the line in defence, in fact the opposition didn't even score a point. Yes, he threw an intercept, only because he was trying something which, if it connected was most certainly another Tigers try. With Reynolds starting, we've won by a margin and gone awful close to last years Grand Finalist. What more do you want?
And using an Anasta observation to bag a bloke? Says it all really.

You have a very different recollection of the first half than I do.

Try 1 REynolds gets a TA by screwing up and passing to a prop on the last (Brooks was calling for it left and as soon as Musgrove got it, Garner was pointing back for the pass, it was an error).

Try 2 REynolds passes it to Douiehi who puts BJ in space. Reynolds did nothing other than standard catch and pass.

Try 3 Reynolds a panicked catch and pass to Nofo after Grants kick into the back of the cowboys. Try set up by great work by Nofo and Mbye, nothing to do with Reynolds.

Try 4 Reynolds did zero and didnt touch the ball, Grant sets up Alioia.

Try 5 Reynolds nowhere near it, doesnt touch the ball. Grant -Brooks -Mbye ->Jennings.

Try 6 - Reynolds kick results in a try. Not a good kick, didnt go to hand, landed 20m short of the line, but it was his kick and it did result in a try.

So Reynolds screwed up and resulted in the first try and then puts in a mediocre kick on the back of a great Nofo break that after some pinball results in a try.......but the 34points were ***mostly*** set up by REynolds? You might have to walk me through how that works.

So basically, what you're saying is, Reynolds made an error by throwing a pass which led to a try and should instead have thrown the ball wide to a halfback who was going to do what?
Douiehi's pass put BJ into space to score was worth noting but Reynolds pass to put Douiehi into space was just a standard catch and pass.
Great work by Nofo and Mbye, panicked pass from Reynolds. Why can't it be great work from JR to recover the ball and pass to the man in the best position to do something.
His kick that led to a try went to a bloke who tried to catch it with his eyes closed, perfectly placed if he looked up to catch it.
He's had a hand in 4 of the 6 tries. If Brooks had done the same you'd be naming him in the SOO side as captain.
He's rushing up out of the line is so noticeable. Yep, so noticeable the opposition couldn't score a point in the first half.
You're bagging a bloke who's having a proper go, something that's been missing for a while. Give us all a break.

 

[Geo]

Chee Kam is the best play maker ever. Assisted one off his foot without even looking and assisted one off his head against roosters in 2018 ?

Keep bagging him but he always produces ..
Don’t forget he single handedly won 2 games last year

He did drop it cold which led to a Cowgirls TRY next set..

Can’t always be perfect...
He’s won us more games than your mate
?

You know that's not true and since you brought up my mate if it had of been him who dropped it you would have made 30 posts in this game thread at the time of how crap he is

 

[hobbo1]

Chee Kam is the best play maker ever. Assisted one off his foot without even looking and assisted one off his head against roosters in 2018 ?

Keep bagging him but he always produces ..
Don’t forget he single handedly won 2 games last year

He did drop it cold which led to a Cowgirls TRY next set..

Can’t always be perfect...
He’s won us more games than your mate
?

You know that's not true and since you brought up my mate if it had of been him who dropped it you would have made 30 posts in this game thread at the time of how crap he is

Nah never !
It’s a team game after all .
Jennings still sucked though ?

 

[Geo]

Chee Kam is the best play maker ever. Assisted one off his foot without even looking and assisted one off his head against roosters in 2018 ?

Keep bagging him but he always produces ..
Don’t forget he single handedly won 2 games last year

He did drop it cold which led to a Cowgirls TRY next set..

Can’t always be perfect...
He’s won us more games than your mate
?

You know that's not true and since you brought up my mate if it had of been him who dropped it you would have made 30 posts in this game thread at the time of how crap he is

Nah never !
It’s a team game after all .
Jennings still sucked though ?

Oh man ..I'm bookmarking this post for eternity..lol

 

[TieDye]

Chee Kam is the best play maker ever. Assisted one off his foot without even looking and assisted one off his head against roosters in 2018 ?

Keep bagging him but he always produces ..
Don’t forget he single handedly won 2 games last year

He did drop it cold which led to a Cowgirls TRY next set..

Can’t always be perfect...
He’s won us more games than your mate
?

You know that's not true and since you brought up my mate if it had of been him who dropped it you would have made 30 posts in this game thread at the time of how crap he is

Nah never !
It’s a team game after all .
Jennings still sucked though ?


Oh man ..I'm bookmarking this post for eternity..lol

Geo.