Long-time Tigers did not breach cap

Discussion_Bot

New member
Tigers stalwarts Robbie Farah and Bryce Gibbs have unwittingly found themselves at the centre of the club's $187,140 salary cap breach, which furious Wests officials believe was imposed on a dubious technicality over long-serving player allowances. The Tigers comfortably topped a list of five clubs - including Gold Coast, St George Illawarra, Parramatta and Canberra - that were yesterday fined for breaking last year's cap. The NRL, however, came down hard on the Tigers for applying long-serving player discounts to both Farah and Gibbs 12 months ago. As exclusively revealed by The Daily Telegraph last year, the joint venture claimed a $100,000 exemption for the pair, who were graded at Jersey Flegg level with its respective junior feeder clubs Balmain (Farah) and Western Suburbs (Gibbs) in 2002. Under NRL rules, players are eligible for the discount when they have served eight seasons after being graded in Toyota Cup. But Farah and Gibbs graduated before the National Youth Competition was introduced and the Tigers argued its previous Under-20s equivalent, Jersey Flegg, should be seen as an equivalent for the purposes of the exemption. Salary Cap auditor Ian Schubert disagreed, claiming that pre-Toyota Cup players could only be graded through the open-age NSW Cup. Tigers CEO Stephen Humphreys and Schubert have been engaged in a running battle over the rule's interpretation for the past year, with the Tigers also claiming Farah should be exempted because he became an international in 2002 after debuting for Lebanon. Speaking to The Daily Telegraph last night, Humphreys also disputed the remaining $87,140 breach - which was in lieu of educational expenses and living away from home allowances for younger players. He indicated the club would argue its case to NRL boss David Gallop. [Source](http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/nrl/long-time-tigers-did-not-breach-cap/story-e6frfgbo-1226054271381)
 
OK, let's get this straight - Bryce and Robbie's years of service don't count because they didn't play in a competition that didn't exist at the time (the Toyota Cup). Well, they won't get a fair hearing from Gallop, but that argument should take about three minutes to demolish in an actual court of law. Ridiculous.
 
@Paris Cobbs said:
OK, let's get this straight - Bryce and Robbie's years of service don't count because they didn't play in a competition that didn't exist at the time (the Toyota Cup). Well, they won't get a fair hearing from Gallop, but that argument should take about three minutes to demolish in an actual court of law. Ridiculous.

Agreed and yeah I don't expect they'll get a fair hearing at all. Jersey Flegg should count, they are long serving players, the NRL appear to be splitting hairs here.
 
I think I heard/read that the reason Jersey Flegg does not count is because some clubs (I assume those outside NSW) did not have a Flegg team. Aren't all the News Limited clubs among those without Flegg teams?
 
Should be zero shouldn't it? Since they made their debut the following year…?
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 
@Kul said:
Should be zero shouldn't it? Since they made their debut the following year…?
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED

Are you sure Kul ?? I thought Fulton Gibbs were 2 years later , but probably wrong
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top