Lui has to be sacked cant tackle

  • Thread starter Thread starter Dreamers
  • Start date Start date
don't understand why the coaching staff don't listen to fans we all want moltzen at halfback and lui sacked and they refuse to listen to us, might as well not waste our breath!
 
@drummertim said:
don't understand why the coaching staff don't listen to fans we all want moltzen at halfback and lui sacked and they refuse to listen to us, might as well not waste our breath!

Not everyone…. and not many on here would have the experience that Camp Concord has in regards to team selection.

Sounds like a smart move not to listen to the Fans on here!!!
 
@drummertim said:
don't understand why the coaching staff don't listen to fans we all want moltzen at halfback and lui sacked and they refuse to listen to us, might as well not waste our breath!

That's where you're wrong. We don't all want Moltzen at halfback and nor do we want Lui sacked. Might as well not waste your breath with nonsense comments like that.
 
Stick with Lui for the next few weeks and if by the time Lawrence gets back things are not great make changes then .Thw whole team needs to take resposibility for our attacking issues and if we stick a more relaible defender with Lui (Ellis or Fulton) that will help with his confidence .
 
@happy tiger said:
The reason teams focus on Lui in attack is because of the bloke beside him also Dwyer . They both can miss a few tackles and it gives you two targets in the line side by side . Fulton should be moved next to Lui and I think you will find that teams will not target Lui so often .

hmm after 30 minutes when he comes on the field.St george would have been up 30 nil by that time.
 
Well it can be Ellis then Still think I prefer Fulton starting with Dwyer off bench anyway . Both Dwyer and Fulton are being used in the wrong way anyway
 
@Dreamers said:
He is the worst half back in this competition ,he cant TACKLE ,when are they finally going to drop him ,he offers nothing for us ,he just walks around doing nothing ,SACK HIM ,

sack him?
can we sack you?
 
Pokies ,Are you related to Lui ,you must be watching a different game then the rest of us ,Lui is hopeless face the facts
 
Mtd ,You are another one that knows nothing about rugby league ,have you ever picked up a football ,Or are you one of those people that just thinks the world is wonderful even all the people in jail ????
 
@Dreamers said:
Pokies ,Are you related to Lui ,you must be watching a different game then the rest of us ,Lui is hopeless face the facts

Haha, related to Lui? nah mate not as far as i know.
If you think hes hopeless then we must be watching a different game.
 
It's always interesting hearing what others think of the game.

There was a chap a few rows behind me in the LR Stans upper decks with more grease in his hair the our oil slick enducing ground announcer just giving it to Fulton the entire time he was on and also Lui but praising Moltzen for everything he did.
 
I love the concept that if someone disagrees with you, they obviously know nothing about league and/or are blind to reality. Plenty of strong opinions but not much evidence or statistics.
 
@Yossarian said:
I love the concept that if someone disagrees with you, they obviously know nothing about league and/or are blind to reality.

more often than not in my case its true.. i rock
 
@mtd said:
@Yossarian said:
I love the concept that if someone disagrees with you, they obviously know nothing about league and/or are blind to reality.

more often than not in my case its true.. i rock

Well you know what they say about self praise…
 
Nothing but a shirt-grabber in defence. Until he learns to lean with the shoulders he should be dropped to NSW Cup. I've been a fan of his although to be honest we have been lacking the spark for weeks now. In my opinion i don't think Moltz is the answer either. Moltzen seems to lack in his organizational skills for mine and i honestly believe Miller may have exactly what we need.

A young fella with a bunch of confidence who isn't afraid to tell the old blokes what to do, has good defence, a wicked step and speed, pretty damn good goalkicker, has a good kicking game and won't hide on the football field. Best of all he is a half back and know's how to direct the play. To my best recollection Lui and Moltz both prefer 5/8 when playing in the halves.
 
Missed 10 tackles last night which must be close to a record. Really needs to improve this side of his game. Funny thing is, he is capable of quite good defence but sometimes he doesn't seem to commit himself as much as he should.

The try Newcastle scored was not his fault. Halves should not be making one-on-one tackles on big forwards on the line but it's a Wests Tigers tradition for this to happen…
 
@paulgeorge said:
I agree with dumping Lui, but seriously who! have we got to replace him…...zippo, the cupbard is bare....that's what happens when we over pay players who don't put in every week and only make an appearence for 15 minutes a game. I seriously should think we should change our strip to black with a silver fern on it.

Mate we have the single most exciting halfback prospect the Tigers have ever had waiting in the wings. It is a matter of when, not if.
 
A few weeks ago people on here were talking up Lui as Joey, Sterlo and Thursty rolled into 1, now everyone is saying he is no good at all!!

truth is he is a young half, with talent and defiencies, learning his craft

Im worried about his defence but im more worried about our continual poor fith tackle options, and rudderless play. My personal opinion is that he is a bad match for Benji, i would consider making him the reserve back, and playing Moltz at half.
 
Back
Top