Lui or Moltzen?

[Livai]

I think this is a tough topic because there both great players and congrats to moltzen for his double on friday. however while wade is out i think mitch brown should be the back up full back without a doubt.http://www.weststigersforum.com/forum/posting.php?mode=post&f=2&time=1303698221#

 

[cktiger]

Seems that Sheens is fixated with playing Moltzen at fullback - for God knows what reason.
IMO leave him at half . Lui again made dumb mistakes ( not the only one I admit) and was the usual speedbump in the defensive line.

 

[alexaki]

Are you Guys serious?.. Moltzen doesn't come close to Lui…

 

[IronTiger]

Lui is the best natural 7 this club has had since Prince. In his first game back to score and set up a try is a great effort. Yes his defence may have been suspect but he has been out for 3 weeks he will as he has shown since coming into 1st grade improve.

Moltz should be our regular Utility with Brown at FB. Moltz can do a job at 1,6,7,9 & Centre if need be and you can't underestimate the importance of having a good utility player in your squad.

 

[chalabi.yousuf]

It's a tough choise between lui and molts but tim has done more work with the tigers
\
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED

 

[king_sirro]

At the moment if this was a fight, the boxing commision wouldnt even sanction the fight, its a miss match. Lui by KO

 

[Guest]

It's a tough choise between lui and molts but tim has done more work with the tigers
\
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED

What's that got to do with anything? On current form it's not contest, Lui first and daylight second.

 

[jadtiger]

Seriously its no contest Lui is a natural half Moltz isnt

 

[alexaki]

Seriously its no contest Lui is a natural half Moltz isnt

can anyone tell me what Moltz is…?

 

[innsaneink]

Seriously its no contest Lui is a natural half Moltz isnt

can anyone tell me what Moltz is…?

He's a good bloke
Popular
Apparently good looking
Well liked
Adored even
Idolised

 

[king_sirro]

Seriously its no contest Lui is a natural half Moltz isnt

can anyone tell me what Moltz is…?

a 5/8

 

[Lukic]

Lui is not a natural half. He's a 5/8th through and through. I don't know where this Lui is a halfback idea came about from?

 

[vman]

Moltzen is a crap fullback doesn't contest for the ball and all the other crap that people come up with so he shouldn't be in the side. Lui doesn't seem to be able to make a tackle but no one says get him out of the side. They both have week points but they both have strong points rather have both in the side than have neither.

 

[Mrs_T]

Lui - 7, Moltz - 14.

 

[tig_prmz]

He's a good bloke
Popular
Apparently good looking
Well liked
Adored even
Idolised

that^

a 5/8

and that^

and apparently he is gonna be a Rabbit 😕

 

[happy_tiger]

Lui - 7, Moltz - 14.

x2 Mrs T Moltzen won't make this starting team at full strength

 

[sunshine_coast_tiger]

Lui is not a natural half. He's a 5/8th through and through. I don't know where this Lui is a halfback idea came about from?

I agree he is a better five eighth than half. However we have the best #6 in the NRL so as others (eg Thurston etc..) Lui has moved to #7 and he is very good in this position as well. He is the best halfback we have and will end up being among the top 5 in the NRL. I for one do not see Moltzen ever getting the starting #7 at the Tigers if Lui is fit. Even if Lui was injured, I would be tempted to start Miller at #7 instead of Moltzen. Moltzen best spot in our squad is #14, if he doesn't like that he can go elsewhere.

 

[Tiger_Watto]

Seriously its no contest Lui is a natural half Moltz isnt

can anyone tell me what Moltz is…?

He's a good bloke
Popular
Apparently good looking
Well liked
Adored even
Idolised

And apparently very fashionable… I've seen a few photos of him out and about and he has this lovely scarf wrapped around his neck. Not sure if its the right fashion for the pub, but he would undoubtedly be very popular up Oxford Street way 😕

 

[Muffstar]

Seriously its no contest Lui is a natural half Moltz isnt

can anyone tell me what Moltz is…?

He's a good bloke
Popular
Apparently good looking
Well liked
Adored even
Idolised

And apparently very fashionable… I've seen a few photos of him out and about and he has this lovely scarf wrapped around his neck. Not sure if its the right fashion for the pub, but he would undoubtedly be very popular up Oxford Street way 😕

Bit of inuendo ?

 

[happy_tiger]

Lui is not a natural half. He's a 5/8th through and through. I don't know where this Lui is a halfback idea came about from?

I agree he is a better five eighth than half. However we have the best #6 in the NRL so as others (eg Thurston etc..) Lui has moved to #7 and he is very good in this position as well. He is the best halfback we have and will end up being among the top 5 in the NRL. I for one do not see Moltzen ever getting the starting #7 at the Tigers if Lui is fit. Even if Lui was injured, I would be tempted to start Miller at #7 instead of Moltzen. Moltzen best spot in our squad is #14, if he doesn't like that he can go elsewhere.

Well the Lui at halfback thing is working far better than any other 7 we have at the club will be in the immediate future . Miller is a work in progress still imo