Luke Brooks #167

[TigerMitch05]

IMHO i would like olakau'atu for brooks can fulton pull some magic for that

 

[earl]

So the Tigers 2 year offer “ in excess of a million” wasnt too far from the mark?

See you later bud

I think it was also the crap he copped for a long time.

Bad for us. Good for Manly. I wish him well.

 

[Tom Shines]

I think it was also the crap he copped for a long time.

Bad for us. Good for Manly. I wish him well.

Manly fans will be no different if he plays poorly

 

[earl]

Where's all the clowns that said there was no interest in the game for him?

If you haven't figured it out yet people have no freaken idea. I love how people jump up and down and state he has no offers. He is an above average NRL half. He was always going to get offers.

 

[tigerap]

4 year deal at Manly....good luck to him....I hope he goes well inside of DCE

 

[earl]

Manly fans will be no different if he plays poorly

Nonsense. He has copped it unfairly when playing for us.

 

[Tom Shines]

Nonsense. He has copped it unfairly when playing for us.

Nonsense? I live in Manly and know what their fans are like..

 

[You Know Who]

About time sanity prevailed.

 

[earl]

Nonsense? I live in Manly and know what their fans are like..

It is complete and utter nonsense because Brooks has copped it at this club for years as being the sole focus for us being so terrible. It's not going to be like that.

 

[Tom Shines]

It is complete and utter nonsense because Brooks has copped it at this club for years as being the sole focus for us being so terrible. It's not going to be like that.

Im telling you as someone who has seen it first hand for decades… Manly fans will be the same if he plays like he has played here

 

[WesternSuburbsBoy]

Where's all the clowns that said there was no interest in the game for him?

Look at who his player agent is then look at the player agents of the players Manly have signed lately... coincidence? I think not, Seibs did the same thing at Brisbane & it's what cost him his job.

 

[earl]

Im telling you as someone who has seen it first hand for decades… Manly fans will be the same if he plays like he has played here

I can't see it but you are entitled to your opinion. I also disagree with the comment if he plays like he plays here. You have to need glasses to tell me he has been poor this season. He is clearly one of our best players.

 

[Tom Shines]

I can't see it but you are entitled to your opinion. I also disagree with the comment if he plays like he plays here. You have to need glasses to tell me he has been poor this season. He is clearly one of our best players.

Take my word for it…

The team has won three games this year…

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

So the Tigers 2 year offer “ in excess of a million” wasnt too far from the mark?

See you later bud

If its a 3yr deal at around 2 mil he's surpassed our offer by a decent margin, but if its 4 like someone was just saying its in the ballpark. Moses probably just wants all his clients out of here so he can hold clubs over a barrel again.

 

[earl]

Look at who his player agent is then look at the player agents of the players Manly have signed lately... coincidence? I think not, Seibs did the same thing at Brisbane & it's what cost him his job.

This has nothing at all to do with the point that was made though. The argument on here is that no one else wants him.

If Moses had me on his roster I can pretty much guarantee I wouldn't get a 2 million dollar contract over 3 years.

He is an above average half in the NRL. It is what it is.

 

[Tom Shines]

If its a 3yr deal at around 2 mil he's surpassed our offer by a decent margin, but if its 4 like someone was just saying its in the ballpark. Moses probably just wants all his clients out of here so he can hold clubs over a barrel again.

he was offered around $600k a year here and has supposedly signed for $667 there

 

[Merlot]

I can't see it but you are entitled to your opinion. I also disagree with the comment if he plays like he plays here. You have to need glasses to tell me he has been poor this season. He is clearly one of our best players.

thats it,go out swinging Earl,as we wave Brooks goodbye

 

[WesternSuburbsBoy]

This has nothing at all to do with the point that was made though. The argument on here is that no one else wants him.

If Moses had me on his roster I can pretty much guarantee I wouldn't get a 2 million dollar contract over 3 years.

He is an above average half in the NRL. It is what it is.

I think it does though... are you telling me there would've been league wide interest for Talau?

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

he was offered around $600k a year here and has supposedly signed for $667 there

$70-80 k a yr difference and still in Sydney i know what i'd be doing, no pressure on him at Manly. In any event our offer was $550 but i dont know if we upped that or not, seems like he wanted out so good luck to him.

 

[earl]

I think it does though... are you telling me there would've been league wide interest for Talau?

No but there is enough interest. I sold a unit years ago. We got one buyer. It was enough.