Luke Brooks - Mega Thread

Brooks, AD, JH are as useless as one another. None of them are going to shine in this squad.

i couldn’t give a flying f what any of the players think or where they want to play. it be like putting the patience in charge of the asylum.

none of them have achieved anything at the WT. I cant see either of them changing our fortunes until the rest of the squad pulls up it’s socks.
 
Cant argue with all the comments about petulant behaviour and whose behaving like grown ups as not many of them are but I just feel Douehi has more talent than Brooks .Just my opinion
 
“He doesn’t trust anyone who is walking the hallways there at the Tigers, if the players don’t trust who is in charge it just shows you the disconnect there at the club,” Fox League’s Yvonne Sampson said.

I distrust anything which comes out of the cesspool which is fox media but what she said is probably not that far from the truth.Our administration is at Trump, who is a convicted Rapist and Felon/Boris Johnson levels of integrity and competence
 
Its clear that either Hooper is making up crap or someone at the club really wants us to move Brooks on.

2 weeks ago Brooks was reported to be dropped well before the team was picked (don’t see how it would be true anyway).

Then AD wants to play 5/8th or no position putting pressure on Brooks

Before that the swapies stories with the Knights and Bulldogs had been flowing but Brooks denied them.

Can’t see it coming from Sheens, Lee would just blurt a comment out so it must be at either Pascoe or the board level.

Regardless its a rabble & a disgrace how various things are being played out.
 
Brooks, AD, JH are as useless as one another. None of them are going to shine in this squad.

i couldn’t give a flying f what any of the players think or where they want to play. it be like putting the patience in charge of the asylum.

none of them have achieved anything at the WT. I cant see either of them changing our fortunes until the rest of the squad pulls up it’s socks.
Bit tough on Hastings mate,at least he showed leadership and if you go by stats handled the ball far more than the others ever did...he has a foot injury and keeps playing for the team,he has played what 14 games here compared to Brooks and AD...
When Hastings looks for support runners they are nowhere to be seen...and thats the problem not JH...
 

NRL NEWS: Brooks fumes over Tigers leaks, Blues call up Townsend, Dogs rookie OK after 'scary concussion'​

The Roar - 1h ago
React1 Comment
1657150433368.png
Wests Tigers five-eighth Luke Brooks is fuming over the constant leaks at the club which led to speculation he was going to be dropped recently.
Brooks has held his position heading into Saturday night’s clash with Parramatta despite scuttlebutt suggesting he was going to be dumped leading into last week’s trip to Auckland.
Adam Doueihi has been picked at centre in his first run-on game since returning via the bench from a torn ACL.
“I did see it. It was pretty disappointing that it came out in the media and in the end obviously it wasn’t true,” Brooks said.
“I think it came from a place where it probably shouldn’t have and that is what is frustrating sometimes about this club, a fair few stories get leaked out and I think it comes from people a lot higher than us.
“In the end, it obviously didn’t happen because I played. It’s just another thing (that happens at the club)… what can you do?”
 
How long do we have to continue to watch Brooks kick the ball out on the full, give away 7 tackle sets, kick the ball into the other teams legs before you accept that he has contributed about as much as John Morris did during his time at the club?
Another 9 years or so.

And somehow all of the repeated getting the basics wrong you've listed above will still be the fault of:

the forward pack
coach
halves partner
fan base (unsure if the paying members are also to blame - Lee?)
he just needs a better team around him
etc
ad infinitum.
 
Another 9 years or so.

And somehow all of the repeated getting the basics wrong you've listed above will still be the fault of:

the forward pack
coach
halves partner
fan base (unsure if the paying members are also to blame - Lee?)
he just needs a better team around him
etc
ad infinitum.

you forgot height of players.
 
Its clear that either Hooper is making up crap or someone at the club really wants us to move Brooks on.

2 weeks ago Brooks was reported to be dropped well before the team was picked (don’t see how it would be true anyway).

Then AD wants to play 5/8th or no position putting pressure on Brooks

Before that the swapies stories with the Knights and Bulldogs had been flowing but Brooks denied them.

Can’t see it coming from Sheens, Lee would just blurt a comment out so it must be at either Pascoe or the board level.

Regardless its a rabble & a disgrace how various things are being played out.
Our club has more hole and leaks than a sieve.
 
With due respect to Luke Brooks, and I am not going to be overly critical of his playing career, but if he was a better footballer there would be far less rumour and innuendo about him.

Maybe there are leaks from HQ (as opposed to simple rumour-mongering by journos), but Luke Brooks has brought that scrutiny upon himself.

I think he's an average footballer, not a horrible one, not a good one, but unfortunately for him he's always had a large profile and never managed to perform to that level. It's unfortunate for him that Tigers are crying out for a "saviour" and Luke Brooks is not that person.

On the other hand Luke Brooks has pocketed hundreds of thousands of dollars a year to be an average halfback, and has rarely been in a position of facing much competition or being dropped (good halfbacks are hard to come by).

Not to mention the fact that we knew Hastings was signed over a year ago and Doueihi has never hidden the fact he wants to play halves; plus we had Mbye last year. So it's not as if Brooks has not had adequate warning that his position is under increasing jeopardy due to the emergence of other halves candidates.

So for him to be frustrated about leaks or negative comments... well if he was a better player that would be less of an issue.

ALSO there's been a tonne of gossip about Brooks to Newcastle this year, and that's certainly not coming from Tigers HQ. So is Brooks going to complain about rumour that he might be dropped, from within Tigers, but be fine about agitation by the Knights and his management about a possible release?
 

Members online

Back
Top