Luke Brooks - Mega Thread

No he doesn't...
That's just the narrow directive talking.
I didn't say Brooks was good (Or great)
- I said he's playing better football than the other halves at the club,
Has been all year (Bar maybe 1-2 "arguable" games) Which he is.

Madden is a dunce...
That's why he's still the half in the team coming second last in reserve grade.

If he was the god send he's made out to be here - Surely he would be absolutely tearing it up in Ressies, And that team would be killing it.
Or some other club would snap him up out of reserve grade. But none have. He’s where he is for a reason, just like Brooks. Be as ignorant as you like, but no player who plays nearly 200 games, plays that many due to a fluke. A half isn’t like a prop or back rower that are a dime a dozen. As the old saying goes, they don’t grow on trees. And you don’t play that many games if you don’t have what it takes. Regardless of what people sitting on their lounges think.
 
Or some other club would snap him up out of reserve grade. But none have. He’s where he is for a reason, just like Brooks. Be as ignorant as you like, but no player who plays nearly 200 games, plays that many due to a fluke. A half isn’t like a prop or back rower that are a dime a dozen. As the old saying goes, they don’t grow on trees. And you don’t play that many games if you don’t have what it takes. Regardless of what people sitting on their lounges think.

It's funny that Madden is so highly rated here, Way better than Brooks and all that Jazz...
But he can't even do in ressies what is demanded of Brooks at NRL.

If he's not doing it in Ressies, It's laughable to think he's going to magically do it in NRL...
 
Brooks would carve up in England. That's his next destination don't see him playing NRL again. Put him out to pasture
How can you not see a player whose played nearly 200 games not getting another NRL gig? There’s absolutely zero evidence to indicate that another club would not take him. None.
 
One of the problems is that when you are wanting to offload a player, at the very least he needs to be a regular first grader, to show he is worth buying. So the club is kind of caught between a rock and a hard place..But even so, an and allowing the the scarcity of half backs, I don't see clubs falling over themselves to sign him...
 
2024 a club will snap up Brooks
why would a club rush in 2023 he is contracted to Tigers and on 1 million allegedly.
A smart club would low ball the Tigers and offer 200k and make Tigers pay 900k which would be stupid
 
How can you not see a player whose played nearly 200 games not getting another NRL gig? There’s absolutely zero evidence to indicate that another club would not take him. None.
At a pay cut, sure another club may be interested, just as any other "bargain basement" player (eg James Roberts for us) but I wouldn't expect them to use him other than of "utility" value. like Mbye, .And if there is zero evidence, then there is also 0 evidence of club wanting him (other than the usual speculative media reports)..
 
One of the problems is that when you are wanting to offload a player, at the very least he needs to be a regular first grader, to show he is worth buying. So the club is kind of caught between a rock and a hard place..But even so, an and allowing the the scarcity of half backs, I don't see clubs falling over themselves to sign him...
I don’t think that’s the case at all. He’s in first grade because there are no better options. Who is the club holding back?
 
How can you not see a player whose played nearly 200 games not getting another NRL gig? There’s absolutely zero evidence to indicate that another club would not take him. None.

The Blind narrative (Hatred)
Milford got another gig,
Ash Taylor got another gig
Cooper Johns is the Storms back up half....
He'll get a gig - Rest assured of that...
- Sheens might even decide to keep him.

The best thing is, He'll be running around next year and all those here that hang on every single second of his game will be able to continue the narrative again for a few more years...
 
At a pay cut, sure another club may be interested, just as any other "bargain basement" player (eg James Roberts for us) but I wouldn't expect them to use him other than of "utility" value. like Mbye, .And if there is zero evidence, then there is also 0 evidence of club wanting him (other than the usual speculative media reports)..
Another ridiculous belief. He‘s not going anywhere at a bargain basement price. At a minimum, it will still be in the neighbourhood of 500k. How many halves who have played as many games as him, are earning bottom dollar? None. His experience alone will get him a good deal.
 
The Blind narrative (Hatred)
Milford got another gig,
Ash Taylor got another gig
Cooper Johns is the Storms back up half....
He'll get a gig - Rest assured of that...
- Sheens might even decide to keep him.

The best thing is, He'll be running around next year and all those here that hang on every single second of his game will be able to continue the narrative again for a few more years...
I believe that is the most likely scenario with his contract at what Sheens believes it should be.
 
At a pay cut, sure another club may be interested, just as any other "bargain basement" player (eg James Roberts for us) but I wouldn't expect them to use him other than of "utility" value. like Mbye, .And if there is zero evidence, then there is also 0 evidence of club wanting him (other than the usual speculative media reports)..

You'll find that 99.5% of the time - When a player remains contracted, He isn't radared by other teams...
Luke Brooks hasn't been off contract since we signed him early 2017.
Outside that - He's never been permitted to speak to other clubs.

That's why there's zero evidence.
 
I believe that is the most likely scenario with his contract at what Sheens believes it should be.

I wouldn't be shocked if Brooks is re-negotiated at all.

As much as everyone wants them too, Or hopes they maybe could
The other Halves currently at the club aren't unseating him.
They just aren't.

I wish All our halves were playing better and getting results - I also believe we have bigger issues than the halves atm and have done for many, many years....
(Centres and Second Rowers anyone?)

If there's a better half - Lets get him, I don't think Doueihi has done enough at 5/8 to be guaranteed anything - If there's one of them going, Get him too...

To be completely honest, There is no one at the club next year I don't feel we could upgrade drastically on outside the Hooker and Back Rower....
No One.

Furthermore - Our current ladder position indicates that to be the case also.
 
You'll find that 99.5% of the time - When a player remains contracted, He isn't radared by other teams...
Luke Brooks hasn't been off contract since we signed him early 2017.
Outside that - He's never been permitted to speak to other clubs.

That's why there's zero evidence.
Except there is evidence. Didn’t Cam Smith confirm Bellamy’s interest?
 
How can you not see a player whose played nearly 200 games not getting another NRL gig? There’s absolutely zero evidence to indicate that another club would not take him. None.
I have my opinion you have yours. I can't think of a team that could use him right now. Other teams see what we see also. He's cooked in the NRL.
 
Pure and simply he has to earn his salary.
The Blind narrative (Hatred)
Milford got another gig,
Ash Taylor got another gig
Cooper Johns is the Storms back up half....
He'll get a gig - Rest assured of that...
- Sheens might even decide to keep him.

The best thing is, He'll be running around next year and all those here that hang on every single second of his game will be able to continue the narrative again for a few more years...
He will get another gig but in terms of balancing the cap for our team he has to be the best player and he just can't deliver - just like Mybe and Reynolds. He knows it and the pressure will be worst next year when he is on more - and mentally he is not that player. He proves it over and over again.
 
If he was cooked he’d be nowhere near first grade. It’s just an inaccurate statement.
He isn't playing first grade standard what are you talking about? We only play him because of we can't dump a million dollar a year player to reggies. Makes management look bad.
You're searching for debate today old mate.
 
  • Like
Reactions: PJ_
He isn't playing first grade standard what are you talking about? We only play him because of we can't dump a million dollar a year player to reggies. Makes management look bad.
You're searching for debate today old mate.
Reynolds and packer certainly found reserve grade on big money here...
With the same coach...

We've done it plenty - You saying we can't is just rubbish
 
Reynolds and packer certainly found reserve grade on big money here...
With the same coach...

We've done it plenty - You saying we can't is just rubbish
No club wants to do that though. No value to Brooks or us. Brooks is finally starting to talk about a future elsewhere. Shame it hasn't worked out but in the best interest of all we need to help him move on.
 

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top