Luke Brooks

Status
Not open for further replies.
@lee-s-fedora said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487144) said:
Brooks 6 Hastings 7 should be the go id be very surprised if brooks holds the 7 next year

Why would our player of the year not hold his spot? I think the discussion should now be whats the plan for Hastings, cos it ain’t at 7.
 
Brooks is an out and out 6 hes a good player dont get me wrong but he's not a 7 he doesn't talk he doesn't organise we need to move him to 6 Hastings 7 Peachy 13
 
@hobbo1 said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1486783) said:
Bump
Punt him

![50F7704F-108A-4FDF-9295-082B569B8D73.jpeg](/assets/uploads/files/1633413071418-50f7704f-108a-4fdf-9295-082b569b8d73.jpeg)

Most ironic moment ever 🤣
 
@lee-s-fedora said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487186) said:
Brooks is an out and out 6 hes a good player dont get me wrong but he's not a 7 he doesn't talk he doesn't organise we need to move him to 6 Hastings 7 Peachy 13

When AD recovers then what….
 
@lee-s-fedora said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487245) said:
Once AD recovers put brooks at 14 he can swap with liddle at hooker

Our player of the year will not be coming off the bench. Hastings though…
 
The fact that brooks was player of year is beyond me weeks ago alot of people wanted him gone now cause he won our player of the year everyone is singing his praises should of been AD or daine to win
 
@tigerap said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487243) said:
@lee-s-fedora said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487186) said:
Brooks is an out and out 6 hes a good player dont get me wrong but he's not a 7 he doesn't talk he doesn't organise we need to move him to 6 Hastings 7 Peachy 13

When AD recovers then what….

I think Madge plans to play AD in the centres.
 
@lee-s-fedora said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487276) said:
The fact that brooks was player of year is beyond me weeks ago alot of people wanted him gone now cause he won our player of the year everyone is singing his praises should of been AD or daine to win

I cannot wait till the Luke Brooks era is over.

Why the club persisted with him for so many years I will never understand.

Failed experiment.
 
@oldschooltiger said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487278) said:
@tigerap said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487243) said:
@lee-s-fedora said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487186) said:
Brooks is an out and out 6 hes a good player dont get me wrong but he's not a 7 he doesn't talk he doesn't organise we need to move him to 6 Hastings 7 Peachy 13

When AD recovers then what….

I think Madge plans to play AD in the centres.

Madge won't have much say when he inevitably loses his job.
 
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487274) said:
@lee-s-fedora said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487245) said:
Once AD recovers put brooks at 14 he can swap with liddle at hooker

Our player of the year will not be coming off the bench. Hastings though…

I think you have there the crux of the next crisis to face WT. 2022 season will bring all this to a head - Brooks #7 and Madge persistence in his belief / mania Brooks can be a #7, when there are other options with the club (Hastings) and Sheens etc who probably will see it differently.

Edit- If Maguire keeps shuffling Doueihi about to suit Broooks preference why would Doueihi want to stay at the club.
 
@2005magic said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487285) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487274) said:
@lee-s-fedora said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487245) said:
Once AD recovers put brooks at 14 he can swap with liddle at hooker

Our player of the year will not be coming off the bench. Hastings though…

I think you have there the crux of the next crisis to face WT. 2022 season will bring all this to a head - Brooks #7 and Madge persistence in his belief / mania Brooks can be a #7, when there are other options with the club (Hastings) and Sheens etc who probably will see it differently.

Edit- If Maguire keeps shuffling Doueihi about to suit Broooks preference why would Doueihi want to stay at the club.

Shuffling Doueihi has nothing to do with our player of the year. Adam is a centre.
 
Seems funny that our player of the year was voted by the same coaches who were judged so incompetent they got the boot. Madge has to wake up or he’s next. At least we know who the real coach killer is now.
 
Brooks and Maguire are at odds with each other because they both carry the pressure of being most responsible.
Maguire is the only coach to drop Brooks. Accountabilty has never gone well with players at the club - "eggshells" leak.
Maguire can't afford to persist with him at 7, if the results are not up to standard or he has no hope of keeping his job.
 
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487289) said:
@2005magic said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487285) said:
@gnr4life said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487274) said:
@lee-s-fedora said in [Luke Brooks](/post/1487245) said:
Once AD recovers put brooks at 14 he can swap with liddle at hooker

Our player of the year will not be coming off the bench. Hastings though…

I think you have there the crux of the next crisis to face WT. 2022 season will bring all this to a head - Brooks #7 and Madge persistence in his belief / mania Brooks can be a #7, when there are other options with the club (Hastings) and Sheens etc who probably will see it differently.

Edit- If Maguire keeps shuffling Doueihi about to suit Broooks preference why would Doueihi want to stay at the club.

Shuffling Doueihi has nothing to do with our player of the year. Adam is a centre.

Brooks has nothing to do with our player of the year either.
A pigs trotter in a velvet glove.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Members online

Back
Top