Madge Maguire - Mega Thread

[GNR4LIFE]

Is Toovey really an upgrade? I see him as a very similar coach to Madge

Only 2 coaches who could turn us into anything are Bellamy and Bennett. We’re a project only the best coaches of all time could get something out of.

 

[jadtiger]

Is Toovey really an upgrade? I see him as a very similar coach to Madge

I really like Toovey as a coach but i honestly dont know how he would go because he hasnt coached for quite a while and the game has changed massively

 

[WT2K]

Reynolds and Bennett combo

 

[Alex Seyfarth's #1 Fan]

[Round 5 press conference](https://www.nrl.com/tv/matches/telstra-premiership/2021/round-5/wests-tigers-round-5/)

Madge super emotional.

 

[blakewp]

I wonder if Madge will be having dreams about Luke Brooks.... for the rest of his life. “I was a premiership coach. I thought I knew it all. Then I met Brooksy...”

 

[hobbo1]

Is Toovey really an upgrade? I see him as a very similar coach to Madge

Only 2 coaches who could turn us into anything are Bellamy and Bennett. We’re a project only the best coaches of all time could get something out of.

Last week Gus Gould said ...
If you took the top 5 teams coaches and placed them in the bottom 5 teams , the bottom 5 teams would be all top 5 teams in 4 years ..

 

[tig_prmz]

I wonder if Madge will be having dreams about Luke Brooks.... for the rest of his life. “I was a premiership coach. I thought I knew it all. Then I met Brooksy...”

Every coach probably thinks the same about WT- Taylor, cleary, potter, madge..

 

[hobbo1]

I wonder if Madge will be having dreams about Luke Brooks.... for the rest of his life. “I was a premiership coach. I thought I knew it all. Then I met Brooksy...”

Every coach probably thinks the same about WT- Taylor, cleary, potter, madge..

I liked Potter !

 

[leonard day]

i dont think madge and his assistant coaches have anything to offer anymore, it looks like we have to pay out another person for a couple of seasons, whos behind all of these decisions made, year after year, bad decisions on buying coaches and buying players, i know madge has had his chance and has failed terribly, so he has to go, how about the other people who ok the decisions on who we buy, the ones who tick it off, these people dont know what they are doing, they must not be watching the games, all they dont know anything about the game, they must go as well, we want quality nothing else will do

 

[voice_of_reason]

Sacking Madge is not the solution - we'd just be starting again waiting for the new coach to get 'the team he wants'.

Like it or not, we need to stick tight.

 

[hobbo1]

Bring back Potter !

 

[Snake]

I strongly recommended that the club waited until mid season for an extension ... if that was the case I would of signed John Morris tomorrow !

 

[hobbo1]

Sacking Madge is not the solution - we'd just be starting again waiting for the new coach to get 'the team he wants'.

Like it or not, we need to stick tight.

It’s not the team he wants but is it !
It’s the team nobody else wants !
You know I’m correct 😂

 

[Mac_tiger]

Inept home team, beaten by inept away team, presided over by inept bunker. No one can coach this rabble.

 

[kiwitiger]

I'm just watching the eels v dragons and thinking how madge is probably what parra need. He might just get them a premiership. He is not a rebuild coach.
I'd give @happy_tiger lefty and @hobbo1 righty to have Hook as our coach right now. Story on nrl.com about how he gets the group to have a coffee/beer together and get to know each other is what we need

 

[Cairnstigers]

Well I'm turning 53 this year
I have experienced one day of euphoria with this team in all that time
One bloody day
I must be crazy
That's just about it for me for the rest of this year
I'm not watching or following this garbage any more
I will enjoy my weekends with my wife and our dog relaxing and walking the beach to Palmcove
I feel so gutted because every year we dish up the same garbage
There is absolutely no pride in our Jersey or our Club
These guys are no putting in 100%
Our defence is what loses us our games
We have players that have been at our club to long that can't catch a ball and can't defend
We all know who they are and we all need to admit it
I don't care if they are loyal
We need to win games for our club and most importantly our supporters
If we don't we will loose our supporters
I am so close to switching off permanently as I believe many of us have and will

Madge must switch the team up
We have some good young players in reserves
It is the only thing,ONLY THING, that will keep me interested for this year

We will not make the 8 so we have nothing to loose
To play on to avoid the spoon is not acceptable
Give our young players a bloody go
I am talking Simpkin Simpkins Amone Gebbie Fitzgibbon and Madden
Add but a bloody elite performer
Enough is enough

 

[Leck]

What I can’t understand is how Justin Holbrook has managed to take the Titans from dead last in 2019, to 9th in 2020 to a team that now looks like a top 8 certainty in 2021.

On paper their team was no better than ours last year, but their effort and his game plan was and is light years ahead of Madge’s.

 

[Snake]

What I can’t understand is how Justin Holbrook has managed to take the Titans from dead last in 2019, to 9th in 2020 to a team that now looks like a top 8 certainty in 2021.

On paper their team was no better than ours last year, but their effort and his game plan was and is light years ahead of Madge’s.

Maybe the guy can coach !

 

[innsaneink]

Don't think I've been on here for a sack a coach thread. Should be interesting. But, I think it's only a matter of time before it happens.

We used to have lots a sack sheens threads....sack JT were amusing, potter not many I recall he was Mr. Nice guy

Interesting sharks have made the finals under Morris last two years and he's getting the flick for an untried rookie... Very different standards

 

[BAGNF05]

Bloke shows 100x more passion than the guys in jerseys