Magic round *Spoilers..

[hobbo1]

Geez that was soft to penalise Liam Martin for that.

Why wasn’t he sent to the bin????

Raised forearm...nothing to see under the new rules if you’re a pamfer player ?

 

[tony soprano]

How sidbwe loose against gc

 

[diedpretty]

Dragons gonna have 6 blokes suspended next week

The review committee will be sitting for days - if they follow through on all those on report and apply the blowtorch as the NRL want most teams will be missing players next week.

 

[JC99]

Dragons gonna have 6 blokes suspended next week

The review committee will be sitting for days - if they follow through on all those on report and apply the blowtorch as the NRL want most teams will be missing players next week.

Somehow we avoided any issues at judiciary

 

[innsaneink]

Need both Melbourne and Penrith 13+ for my multi!

How many legs Al?

7 :grin: :grin: :grin:

Nice

Would've been the first 8/8 round for me in tips in about 8 seasons.... Forgot my tips missed our game ☹️

 

[cochise]

Need both Melbourne and Penrith 13+ for my multi!

How many legs Al?

7 :grin: :grin: :grin:

Nice

Would've been the first 8/8 round for me in tips in about 8 seasons.... Forgot my tips missed our game ☹️

I got 8 for 8 and used my joker

 

[AL The Tiger]

Need both Melbourne and Penrith 13+ for my multi!

How many legs Al?

7 :grin: :grin: :grin:

Nice

Would've been the first 8/8 round for me in tips in about 8 seasons.... Forgot my tips missed our game ☹️

Yea I put money on all games except for ours... Genuinely thought we would lose the game and stuck to my rule of never betting against the Tigs

 

[TheDaBoss]

Might need a bigger judicary for the amount of blokes in there

 

[mike]

Need both Melbourne and Penrith 13+ for my multi!

How many legs Al?

7 :grin: :grin: :grin:

Nice

Would've been the first 8/8 round for me in tips in about 8 seasons.... Forgot my tips missed our game ☹️

I got 8 for 8 and used my joker

Yep 8 from 8 for me as well

 

[TigerSJ]

There is a lot of fallout from this round thanks to the PV crackdown on high tackles and professional fouls. Most of the games were ruined by sin-bins and send-offs. 13 v 12 is impossible under the new version of the game and NRL need to revise what happened this weekend.
Not a fan of Cronk at all but he did say one thing smart in commentary- they simply need to look closer at the difference between an incident going on report and getting 10mins in the bin. The latter should be reserved for incidents that show intent or stupid/careless behaviour. When something is clearly reflex or clearly an accident/unavoidable then a penalty and putting it on report is probably enough punishment.

 

[voice_of_reason]

Not a fan of Cronk at all but he did say one thing smart in commentary- they simply need to look closer at the difference between an incident going on report and getting 10mins in the bin. The latter should be reserved for incidents that show intent or stupid/careless behaviour. When something is clearly reflex or clearly an accident/unavoidable then a penalty and putting it on report is probably enough punishment.

The problem with this is an accident or unavoidable incident can still cause a team to lose a player for the rest of the game whilst the offending team gets to keep their full complement.

I'm still of the belief if a player goes for an HIA for foul play there should be a sin bin on the offender. If the player fails his HIA, then the offending player also can't return (but can be interchanged after 10 minutes).

 

[TigerSJ]

Not a fan of Cronk at all but he did say one thing smart in commentary- they simply need to look closer at the difference between an incident going on report and getting 10mins in the bin. The latter should be reserved for incidents that show intent or stupid/careless behaviour. When something is clearly reflex or clearly an accident/unavoidable then a penalty and putting it on report is probably enough punishment.

The problem with this is an accident or unavoidable incident can still cause a team to lose a player for the rest of the game whilst the offending team gets to keep their full complement.

I'm still of the belief if a player goes for an HIA for foul play there should be a sin bin on the offender. If the player fails his HIA, then the offending player also can't return (but can be interchanged after 10 minutes).

See your point VOR, and that seems like a good option you have suggested.

 

[OzLuke]

What absolutely bugged the bejesus out of me this magic round wasn't the amount of sin bins, or the blow out scores, but Cooper Cronk's voice in commentary.
God almighty this guy just rambles on and on about every little thing, and he describes every minute detail in every play like Paul Bettany from A Knight's Tale....
Just keep it to a minimum Cronk. It's worse than Gould going on a tirade.....
Rant over. Thanks for reading

 

[jadtiger]

What absolutely bugged the bejesus out of me this magic round wasn't the amount of sin bins, or the blow out scores, but Cooper Cronk's voice in commentary.
God almighty this guy just rambles on and on about every little thing, and he describes every minute detail in every play like Paul Bettany from A Knight's Tale....
Just keep it to a minimum Cronk. It's worse than Gould going on a tirade.....
Rant over. Thanks for reading

He is not good but i would prefer 2 hours of Cronk rather than 5 seconds of Ginane he is as bad as Hadley

 

[OzLuke]

What absolutely bugged the bejesus out of me this magic round wasn't the amount of sin bins, or the blow out scores, but Cooper Cronk's voice in commentary.
God almighty this guy just rambles on and on about every little thing, and he describes every minute detail in every play like Paul Bettany from A Knight's Tale....
Just keep it to a minimum Cronk. It's worse than Gould going on a tirade.....
Rant over. Thanks for reading


He is not good but i would prefer 2 hours of Cronk rather than 5 seconds of Ginane he is as bad as Hadley

crikey...I'd rather inane Ginane