Marion Seve to replace Nofo?

[king_sirro]

If he goes well again tomorrow I think we have to roll the Dice and play him.

If good judges rated him better then Watene-Zelesniak and Sione Matu-utia then that's enough for me. Give the kid a crack

 

[supercoach]

If he goes well again tomorrow I think we have to roll the Dice and play him.

If good judges rated him better then Watene-Zelesniak and Sione Matu-utia then that's enough for me. Give the kid a crack

Agreed our season is all but over,now is the time to give him ago, rather than the conservative option of Houeter or Milone

 

[Yossarian]

Well given Taylor's previous comments it won't be Lawrence so I guess him and Hoeter are the favourites.

 

[tig_prmz]

missed the first half, what happened to noffa?

 

[supercoach]

missed the first half, what happened to noffa?

Other than cost us 12 points with terrible defensive reads, he stuffed his knee. I do not think its a reconstruction job, but would imagine a few weeks on the side line

 

[Geo]

Won't happen ….bit yeah why not...Think it will be Hoeter.....

Naiqama could be in strife with his pinky...

 

[stevetiger]

I think that is the best option.

 

[fergiefurr]

Hoeter wing only please. Steve for sure, Milone isn't up to it.

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0_

 

[Milky]

We will have to replace Naiqama and Nofa, possibly also Richards.

 

[fergiefurr]

possibly also Richards.

We can only hope

_Posted using RoarFEED 4.2.0_

 

[Guest]

If he goes well again tomorrow I think we have to roll the Dice and play him.

If good judges rated him better then Watene-Zelesniak and Sione Matu-utia then that's enough for me. Give the kid a crack

Yeah I'd agree with this Sirro. Need to cast an eye to our future talent and Seve is the next cap of the ranks IMO.

 

[happy_tiger]

If he goes well again tomorrow I think we have to roll the Dice and play him.

If good judges rated him better then Watene-Zelesniak and Sione Matu-utia then that's enough for me. Give the kid a crack

Yeah I'd agree with this Sirro. Need to cast an eye to our future talent and Seve is the next cap of the ranks IMO.

Anyone surprised that JT hasn't given Fine another run ??

Sorry forgot to add that Milone and Hoeter can't be judged off their limited appearances as well

 

[king_sirro]

If he goes well again tomorrow I think we have to roll the Dice and play him.

If good judges rated him better then Watene-Zelesniak and Sione Matu-utia then that's enough for me. Give the kid a crack

Yeah I'd agree with this Sirro. Need to cast an eye to our future talent and Seve is the next cap of the ranks IMO.

Anyone surprised that JT hasn't given Fine another run ??

Sorry forgot to add that Milone and Hoeter can't be judged off their limited appearances as well

Fine spent a few weeks injured but that being said it does appear he has no chance of a call up under Taylor. He was worth another look in FG IMO but it looks unlikely

 

[greatodensraven]

Someone mentioned a while back that Fletcher believed Fine was the standout in NSW cup. I just assumed that he hadn't had a call-up to 1sts yet due to injury.

 

[Russell]

What is wrong with these guys - why would Kevy not play with the pinky.
Have they heard of strapping it up. What are these people marshmellows.

As for Patty - should not be a problem, didn't look that bad to me.

The best thing to happen last night was Nofa going off - otherwise he would have let in another half a dozen tries. I'll say it again Imo - HE IS NOT A CENTRE.
I say give Marion Seve a go - Hoeter is not a centre either, so it is either Milone or Seve.

Let them fight it out this year - if one comes good we are laughing, if not we need to buy an experienced centre with some speed as soon as some coin becomes available. t

 

[simonthetiger]

Id push Kevvie into centre and Hoeter onto the wing!

 

[pacman]

Seve went well again this arvo in the u20s. Seems to be a cut above the rest in a rather inconsistent team. I'd give him a crack if at all possible over Milone/Hoeter. Nofa to wing next year when Richards hangs up the boots.

 

[Goose]

Im torn here.
I don't rate Milone, and feel Hoeter has been terrible at Centre.
Seve IMO is a long term option, my concern is that I am not sure he is physically ready and would be concerned about his body holding up.

 

[Tiger_Watto]

I know this isnt a solution for Nofo, but I'd be blooding Seve on the Wing for a good 3-4 months before moving him to Centre.

This would allow him to get up to speed with the pace and intensity of the NRL compared to NYC/State Cup. He simply wouldnt be physical enough to handle defending at Centre at this stage.

If we are done for 2015, is it time to make the call on Richards?

 

[Sabre]

I know this isnt a solution for Nofo, but I'd be blooding Seve on the Wing for a good 3-4 months before moving him to Centre.

This would allow him to get up to speed with the pace and intensity of the NRL compared to NYC/State Cup. He simply wouldnt be physical enough to handle defending at Centre at this stage.

**If we are done for 2015, is it time to make the call on Richards?**

The call as in dropping him to NSW Cup or deciding whether to re-sign him?
Assuming it's the former, I don't think we should. He deserves to go out as a first grader.