Mbye is the worst fullback in the competition

[WeHaveCheeKam]

Not buying the he is injured thing. It has no link to alot of the mistakes he is making.

- Poor Defender
- Guaranteed to drop a few balls each week
- Limited ball playing ability
- Suss under the high ball
- Offers little in attack

He is the worst first choice fullback in the competition.

 

[WeHaveCheeKam]

The fact people were raving about his game last week (It was just the norm of what other fullbacks do for other clubs on a normal week), shows where he is at.

 

[Harvey]

I have slammed him all year. Thought he was good last week & that the garbage may have been a result of injury.

He is terrible under the high ball, ball playing is average, defence is terrible and the worst thing (for a captain) is that he seems to lack passion and makes limited effort

 

[GNR4LIFE]

The fact people were raving about his game last week (It was just the norm of what other fullbacks do for other clubs on a normal week), shows where he is at.

I was a bit mythed seeing everyone wrap him last week. Besides him saving a try by running a kick into touch, I didn’t notice anything else he did.

 

[happy_tiger]

Some clubs have 3 fullbacks better than Mbye ....pity we aren't one of them

600 k from memory ...lol

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Some clubs have 3 fullbacks better than Mbye ....pity we aren't one of them

600 k from memory ...lol

Which the Dogs are heavily subsidising thankfull.

 

[WeHaveCheeKam]

Some clubs have 3 fullbacks better than Mbye ....pity we aren't one of them

600 k from memory ...lol

Which the Dogs are heavily subsidising thankfull.

Just for this year though right? We have to pay the next 2-3 years in full?

 

[GNR4LIFE]

Some clubs have 3 fullbacks better than Mbye ....pity we aren't one of them

600 k from memory ...lol

Which the Dogs are heavily subsidising thankfull.

Just for this year though right? We have to pay the next 2-3 years in full?

This year and next.

 

[momo_amp_medo]

Rocks and diamonds I’m afraid.
Confidence is everything and on what he showed us tonight that’s just not there.
It’s really dangerous for a team to see their (c) in such poor form. We are in trouble on number of fronts but fixing this situation is a priority.

 

[Snake]

Masters was totally poor he needs to be dropped ...this type of performance is becoming the norm these days , he is not a centre to slow and very lazy , Momo in next week or the coach is a joke !

 

[TIGERAURA]

Masters was totally poor he needs to be dropped ...this type of performance is becoming the norm these days , he is not a centre to slow and very lazy , Momo in next week or the coach is a joke !

Agree... Including half the team...
Since we lost our orange jerseys we have lost our MOJO ( not a wests dig ) seriously it has ripped our soul out not only losing but looking colourless....

 

[TYGA]

I’m afraid Cleary has left Madge with some absolute monster long contracts that will cause us pain for years Mbye, Reynolds, Packer between them earn 1.8m a year.

 

[Sunnycoast_tiger]

Make Mbye the bench utility player and buy a good fullback. Who cares if Mbye only plays 2mins per week.

 

[Spartan117]

I’m afraid Cleary has left Madge with some absolute monster long contracts that will cause us pain for years Mbye, Reynolds, Packer between them earn 1.8m a year.

Dont forget matalino

 

[WeHaveCheeKam]

I’m afraid Cleary has left Madge with some absolute monster long contracts that will cause us pain for years Mbye, Reynolds, Packer between them earn 1.8m a year.

You are right. Realistically all are 300-400k MAX players (some would say if that), and are all getting between 600-750k. Add McQueen and Nofolomu in there and theres a lot of guys who realistically all would play reserve grade if at another club on big coin.

 

[BenzaTiger]

Moses to Centre
Thompson FB
IMO

 

[upthetigers]

His decision making tonight you can't put down to injury.

We have no leaders at this club, Moses was a surprise selection as captain but the reality is no one else was an obvious selection.

Hard to be optimistic about the future. When Farah leaves god help us Brooks will look like a deer in the headlights. We've gone through a rebuild at the club and we already need another one it's laughable.

 

[Bob]

He was really bad... I’d have Thompson there myself, and I’m not a huge fan of him either.

Our whole team lacks punch, Farah although he did some good things was still pushing passes a rookie would make.

Our forwards really are pedestrian, We have really started to go back to the old sheens tactic of running at the markers.

I prefer liddle at 9 if he can stay on the park. Won’t be popular but I’d have move Farah to the 13 and run the defensive line.

 

[Demps]

Mbye has no concrete position....

Played fullback, centre, 5/8, half, hooker at the doggies and tbh he sucked at all of them with centre probably being his most decent because he had the least to do compared to the other positions.

He's fast - in space - but obviously doesn't go looking for it or create it.
He's in no way safe under the high ball and his defence is average.

As stated - he's been said to be an "athlete" but not a "footballer."
We're stuck with him... and as mentioned, along with the NZ dud front rowers, broken down Reynolds and over-rated Esan.

Very unfortunate. Was almost "our year..." until round 1 lol...

 

[tigerap]

Can’t argue with your very valid points...sheet Cleary has left us a mess for the next 4 years with his recruitment