McKinnon

[Yossarian]

Do you think that he may have trouble bending over to the ball on the ground because of his dodgy hamstrings??? thoughts??? i think that canterbury may have been targeting him due to this???

If that's the case he should never have gone out there and he's partly to blame for that. Personally it looked like his timing was hopelessly out of sync.

 

[sameulcon]

He was constantly out of position all night and took an age to the get to the ball. He was so slow. Surely Sheens has watched enough football to never pick him again.

 

[tiger05]

He was constantly out of position all night and took an age to the get to the ball. He was so slow. Surely Sheens has watched enough football to never pick him again.

I doubt it. Plenty of posters here are still backing him up. Sheens is usually slower than most posters on here.

 

[tigers05]

His our only option at the moment noone else is standing up, I thought Brown on the back of last year but his play has been average this year

 

[alien]

Can all the people that have rated McKinnon in the past please post on this thread.

**Consider it an admission that you have no idea about rugby league**.

That sounds funny coming from you.

McKinnon had an awful game but he normally plays alot better than that and he is a better fullback than Moltzen. I wouldn't mind if Brown got another go at fullback. Brown went ok at fullback towards the end of last year.

 

[tiger05]

Can all the people that have rated McKinnon in the past please post on this thread.

**Consider it an admission that you have no idea about rugby league**.

That sounds funny coming from you.

McKinnon had an awful game but he normally plays alot better than that and he is a better fullback than Moltzen. I wouldn't mind if Brown got another go at fullback. Brown went ok at fullback towards the end of last year.

It wasn't a joke and why do I get the impression you are agreeing with me.

 

[slacko]

I think I liked him at the warriors, he wasn't too bad there.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED

 

[alien]

Tiger05 your opinion is purely based on your love for having Moltzen in the team.

Yeah but you would think that he would want Moltzen at halfback. That would atleast make sense.

 

[alien]

Can all the people that have rated McKinnon in the past please post on this thread.

**Consider it an admission that you have no idea about rugby league**.

That sounds funny coming from you.

McKinnon had an awful game but he normally plays alot better than that and he is a better fullback than Moltzen. I wouldn't mind if Brown got another go at fullback. Brown went ok at fullback towards the end of last year.

It wasn't a joke and why do I get the impression you are agreeing with me.

I do agree that he had a bad game but he normally doesn't play like he did against the Bulldogs.

 

[crouching_tiger]

The difference between hindsight and foresight hey Mr. 48%??
And just to think how much Gallant ONLY asked for to stay, yet you forced him out of the club to dish up this sort of rubbish.

 

[Chris]

Gallant couldnt even be a regular for the Cowboys when Bowen was out injured. Defensively he's a speed hump and the cowboys have identified that, that's why he spends his time in their reggies.

 

[Cultured_Bogan]

Can all the people that have rated McKinnon in the past please post on this thread.

**Consider it an admission that you have no idea about rugby league**.

That sounds funny coming from you.

McKinnon had an awful game but he normally plays alot better than that and he is a better fullback than Moltzen. I wouldn't mind if Brown got another go at fullback. Brown went ok at fullback towards the end of last year.

It wasn't a joke and why do I get the impression you are agreeing with me.

I do agree that he had a bad game but he normally doesn't play like he did against the Bulldogs.

Alien is spot on. McKinnon had a barry, but is still by and far the best fullback at the club, followed by Brown.

Take the goggles off.

 

[tiger05]

Alien is spot on. McKinnon had a barry, but is still by and far the best fullback at the club, followed by Brown.

Take the goggles off.

Guys - I thought this discussion was over and I was right. The club recognizes that McKInnon is not the answer to our fullback problems. I reckon most supporters are waking up to it.

Unfortunately there will always be a couple of slow coaches who take their time figuring it out. That's alright - as long as your a Tigers supporter your alright in my eyes.

 

[hybrid_tiger]

McKinnon had a shocker but he remains a better fullback than Moltzen.

Personally I think Brown did nothing wrong last season to be moved from fullback this year.

 

[clontarfkid]

If u really want to win a premiership,u need at no 1 who has real impact & tryscorying potency in this key position like a Slater/Stewart/Hayne/Dugan/Gidley//Boyd/Barba/Gardner/Bowen/Minichello…hey ,that just about the entire comp covered except for us!
Neither Brown nor Moltzen have this capability,McKinnon had it once but these days has one foot on QF1 to London & the other at the physio
Our mastercoach has done it again...

 

[Twodogs]

MacKinnon was a stopgap and he did his job. What's the plan for next year?