MOLTZEN INJURED

[redemption]

IMO Moltzen has a better passing game running game and short kicking game all over LUI….but he can play fullback albiet not as good as in the halves....so...

1 more thing BENJI loves the bloke,,,wot Benji wants Benji gets when it comes to Sheens.....time will tell

Footy is back
:sign: woot woot

And they are ALL 5/8TH NOT HALFBACKS... :crazy

could not agree more!

but i'd go further, his long kicking is also better, **and his defence is better**, and clearly as a much lower mistake rate.

I dont think they are even close in ability. Moltzen may end up at fullback, and I rate him in that role.

I have said it earlier, I think those that are saying how well Lui finished the season well, are over emphasising the saints game, Lui was very good in that game, look back one earlier and watch the Canberra game and to a lesser extent the Roosters game (particuarly from about the 70 minute) and after watching that tell me how good he finished the year. 2 very frustrating nights.

I have no doubt he has potential, but as it stands lui has a way to go, and we have a man who has 8 wins from 8 starts at half…impressive record

One example to justify your above hyperbole would not go astray!!!!!

As for Geo…...................................... he loves boys from the either Wests or the Central Coast........

 

[Geo]

Well Red…...................when u have watched them from kids grow into FG the YEAH you do get ummm PRIDE...

 

[Gobbs]

The beauty of depth….Get well Moltz

 

[Kul]

IMO Moltzen has a better passing game running game and short kicking game all over LUI….but he can play fullback albiet not as good as in the halves....so...

1 more thing BENJI loves the bloke,,,wot Benji wants Benji gets when it comes to Sheens.....time will tell

Footy is back
:sign: woot woot

And they are ALL 5/8TH NOT HALFBACKS... :crazy

could not agree more!

but i'd go further, his long kicking is also better, **and his defence is better**, and clearly as a much lower mistake rate.

I dont think they are even close in ability. Moltzen may end up at fullback, and I rate him in that role.

I have said it earlier, I think those that are saying how well Lui finished the season well, are over emphasising the saints game, Lui was very good in that game, look back one earlier and watch the Canberra game and to a lesser extent the Roosters game (particuarly from about the 70 minute) and after watching that tell me how good he finished the year. 2 very frustrating nights.

I have no doubt he has potential, but as it stands lui has a way to go, and we have a man who has 8 wins from 8 starts at half…impressive record

One example to justify your above hyperbole would not go astray!!!!!

As for Geo…...................................... he loves boys from the either Wests or the Central Coast........

and Lui's straight from Beattie Street, Balmain?
\
\
Can't wait for the ANZAC weekend! Moltz and Lui in the halves :smiley:

 

[hammertime]

IMO Moltzen has a better passing game running game and short kicking game all over LUI….but he can play fullback albiet not as good as in the halves....so...

1 more thing BENJI loves the bloke,,,wot Benji wants Benji gets when it comes to Sheens.....time will tell

Footy is back
:sign: woot woot

And they are ALL 5/8TH NOT HALFBACKS... :crazy

could not agree more!

but i'd go further, his long kicking is also better, **and his defence is better**, and clearly as a much lower mistake rate.

I dont think they are even close in ability. Moltzen may end up at fullback, and I rate him in that role.

I have said it earlier, I think those that are saying how well Lui finished the season well, are over emphasising the saints game, Lui was very good in that game, look back one earlier and watch the Canberra game and to a lesser extent the Roosters game (particuarly from about the 70 minute) and after watching that tell me how good he finished the year. 2 very frustrating nights.

I have no doubt he has potential, but as it stands lui has a way to go, and we have a man who has 8 wins from 8 starts at half…impressive record

One example to justify your above hyperbole would not go astray!!!!!

As for Geo…...................................... he loves boys from the either Wests or the Central Coast........

Lui had a couple of awesome try saving tackles during the year. Holding up fellas over the line.

The one thing that stands out for me is that Lui, after being 19 and 1 year in the NRL, was one of the better halfbacks in the comp. He helped the NYC team to the grand final. With age, experience, and more influence in the games, this kid is going to be something special.

 

[skando2005]

I'm glad Tim is getting the rest his ankle needs. I don't think he will have any problems coming back from the injury. It's nice to have a Lui option at #7, but I'd just as soon see Moltzen at that position. He consistently makes better decisions at Half than Lui does, and no one can deny the winning streak the Tigers have when Tim is at #7\. As for fullback, we have McKinnon and Brown working well there and I am not sure the position suites Moltzen. I'd just as soon leave him at #7.

Just my thoughts from across the pond.