OFFICIAL Moses Mbye [Discussion]

[CocaCola]

Mbye should only make 1 call as captain, and that is to demote himself of the role.

 

[boonboon]

To give him some credit - he is a centre/fullback playing at hooker and he made 59 tackles and only missed 1 all be it one that lead to a try.

 

[getagrip]

Must be his turn to get dropped. Hope it is from a great height

 

[Tcat]

3 certain things in life.

Death
Taxes and
Mbye not playing in the NRL ever again when his contract with us is finished.

 

[Hangonaminute]

To give him some credit - he is a centre/fullback playing at hooker and he made 59 tackles and only missed 1 all be it one that lead to a try.

The thing is, he's neither a centre or a fullback or a half or a hooker.

Name another captain that doesn't have a position.

When you realise that you can't, you'll understand why the Tigers are a shipwreck

 

[Fade.To.Black]

To give him some credit - he is a centre/fullback playing at hooker and he made 59 tackles and only missed 1 all be it one that lead to a try.

That is fair enough. Didn't realise he made that many tackles.
Make him number 14, take the captaincy off him and also the goalkicking duties as well though.

 

[Harvey]

He should be playing fullback or in the halves. Based on his form this year it would be in reserve grade, but outside of those positions (and maybe even there) he is a stop gap.

 

[Guest]

I'd love to drop him for next week but with Walters injured along with Grant our hands are tied. I think we will see Liddle on the bench though.

 

[hobbo1]

I'd love to drop him for next week but with Walters injured along with Grant our hands are tied. I think we will see Liddle on the bench though.

I’d drop him and play Reynolds at 9
Couldn’t be any worse !

 

[ElleryHanley]

I'd love to drop him for next week but with Walters injured along with Grant our hands are tied. I think we will see Liddle on the bench though.

If he has to stay in the team due to injuries, then so be it...

But there is no way he can captain the club again. It has to end.

Make Packer captain and Josh VC.

It just can't be allowed to go on. I have supported Madge on most things, but this one he has got completely wrong and he has to be big enough to move on.

 

[boonboon]

I'd love to drop him for next week but with Walters injured along with Grant our hands are tied. I think we will see Liddle on the bench though.

I’d drop him and play Reynolds at 9
Couldn’t be any worse !

Reynolds should be at 6 - 5 games with him and Brooks in the halves and 4 of them v Cowbs, DOgs, Panthers, Raiders are our 4 best of the year

 

[hobbo1]

I'd love to drop him for next week but with Walters injured along with Grant our hands are tied. I think we will see Liddle on the bench though.

I’d drop him and play Reynolds at 9
Couldn’t be any worse !

Reynolds should be at 6 - 5 games with him and Brooks in the halves and 4 of them v Cowbs, DOgs, Panthers, Raiders are our 4 best of the year

I can’t recall who’s played where against who but I’ll take your word for it !

 

[TYGA]

He’s just not a first grader anymore in any position. He’s a liability to the team and I’m surprised he’s as bad as he’s been but truth be told his best is past him. He was never great but at least a solid first grader.

It’s a real shame what Cleary did with this roster but it stems way before him we lost all our crop of juniors and we have to rebuild. No ones signing here we have to go with youth.

 

[rah53]

I was happy as NSW supporter when he was selected for Qld. Win for the Blues.

I'm just really upset at how much we are paying him to contribute very little.

I know a couple of Doggies supporters who were glad to see home leave, but were devastated about Reynolds leaving.

 

[Magpie1969]

Needs to go even if we have to pay all his exit costs.

 

[ElleryHanley]

I was happy as NSW supporter when he was selected for Qld. Win for the Blues.

I'm just really upset at how much we are paying him to contribute very little.

I know a couple of Doggies supporters who were glad to see home leave, but were devastated about Reynolds leaving.

I have a mate who is a massive Dogs fan. When Mbye left he was positively ecstatic. Kind of like us when Esan Marsters left...he had seen enough and could not believe anyone took on the contract.

He was upset when JR left..but also laughed and said "750 is ridiculous...half that max and only for the effort...good luck'.

 

[momo_amp_medo]

This is the scoop of the year and Brooks at the same time , watching him run and pass to anyone around him is pathetic!

Gotta laugh. We are being smashed in the forwards, and can't complete a set to save ourselves and you guys want to get rid of the Brooks and Mbye.

Yep ..... it’s an age old Rugby league prerequisite .....
forwards win you the games and the backs are there for entertainment.

 

[Harvey]

I would keep Reynolds over Mbye in a heartbeat. I think that if we move Mbye on we are going to get stuck paying a load of the freight

 

[rah53]

I was happy as NSW supporter when he was selected for Qld. Win for the Blues.

I'm just really upset at how much we are paying him to contribute very little.

I know a couple of Doggies supporters who were glad to see home leave, but were devastated about Reynolds leaving.

I have a mate who is a massive Dogs fan. When Mbye left he was positively ecstatic. Kind of like us when Esan Marsters left...he had seen enough and could not believe anyone took on the contract.

He was upset when JR left..but also laughed and said "750 is ridiculous...half that max and only for the effort...good luck'.

750 for some they were upset about leaving, but we're paying Mbye 950! Someone they were happy that left.

 

[momo_amp_medo]

I was happy as NSW supporter when he was selected for Qld. Win for the Blues.

I'm just really upset at how much we are paying him to contribute very little.

I know a couple of Doggies supporters who were glad to see home leave, but were devastated about Reynolds leaving.

I have a mate who is a massive Dogs fan. When Mbye left he was positively ecstatic. Kind of like us when Esan Marsters left...he had seen enough and could not believe anyone took on the contract.

He was upset when JR left..but also laughed and said "750 is ridiculous...half that max and only for the effort...good luck'.

750 for some they were upset about leaving, but we're paying Mbye 950! Someone they were happy that left.

My understanding is that we did not pay full freight for initial 2 seasons of his contract.
Subsidy by bulldogs is however now over.