Most over rated player in 2010

  • Thread starter Thread starter summers
  • Start date Start date
@summers said:
just felt like seeing which teams/players will be over rated in 2010

i believe that this year people will realise what a rubbish player ennis is. i reckon he will struggle and that farah will dominate so much that no other hooker will be mentioned for nsw this year
Click to expand...

I think the only way Farah will play Origin again is through injury. NSW have no goal kickers and Ennis is now the Dogs kicker, so he'll walk into the side. Robbie is twice the player he is, but the fact is we won with Ennis and he's our only kicker. Doesnt matter that if Robbie played that last Origin with our pack dominating we would have won by 20, the selectors wont think like that.
 
@smeghead said:
Jarrod Mullen. Always talked up as Origin material. Never delivers

Kurt Gidley - Seriosly what is the hubbub over him. I will never understand it. He is a good utility but no star.

The Sammut kid from the 'riff: Had hair like a famous boggerballer at one stage and very little else
Click to expand...

I agree with all of that, but dont expect anyone to agree with my selection for most overrated…...........Heighington
 
@king sirro said:
I think the only way Farah will play Origin again is through injury. NSW have no goal kickers and Ennis is now the Dogs kicker, so he'll walk into the side. Robbie is twice the player he is, but the fact is we won with Ennis and he's our only kicker. Doesnt matter that if Robbie played that last Origin with our pack dominating we would have won by 20, the selectors wont think like that.
Click to expand...

Guys - Im starting to think that Robbie is not goinng to be in the Rep mix for much longer due to his own performances on this stage.

I hate to say it but almost every rep outing has been a negative one for our Captain.

Even the play that led to the lost ball and final Indig try was knocked out of his hands.
 
@Spartan117 said:
@king sirro said:
I think the only way Farah will play Origin again is through injury. NSW have no goal kickers and Ennis is now the Dogs kicker, so he'll walk into the side. Robbie is twice the player he is, but the fact is we won with Ennis and he's our only kicker. Doesnt matter that if Robbie played that last Origin with our pack dominating we would have won by 20, the selectors wont think like that.

Guys - Im starting to think that Robbie is not goinng to be in the Rep mix for much longer due to his own performances on this stage.

I hate to say it but almost every rep outing has been a negative one for our Captain.

Even the play that led to the lost ball and final Indig try was knocked out of his hands.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Agree completely, I think that if Farah makes this years origin (which I believe he will after being picked for Australia) and blows it then that may close the door on his rep career for good.
 
@king sirro said:
I agree with all of that, but dont expect anyone to agree with my selection for most overrated…...........Heighington
Click to expand...

:laughing: Good one
 
@Geo. said:
@king sirro said:
I agree with all of that, but dont expect anyone to agree with my selection for most overrated…...........Heighington

:laughing: Good one
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

In 2008 he was rated as the most underrated…
 
@willow said:
@Geo. said:
@king sirro said:
I agree with all of that, but dont expect anyone to agree with my selection for most overrated…...........Heighington

:laughing: Good one

In 2008 he was rated as the most underrated…
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

They say a week is a long time in footy, 12 months is a lifetime…......a lot can change. Hopefully in the next 12 months he'll be back to the 08 underrated version.
 
@Spartan117 said:
Guys - Im starting to think that Robbie is not goinng to be in the Rep mix for much longer due to his own performances on this stage.

I hate to say it but almost every rep outing has been a negative one for our Captain.
Click to expand...

He outplayed Ennis by 100% in the City Country last year.
 
city country wow…. mullen played well in that and look how is origin debut turned out.... farah hasn't played anything like his potential in the biggest games where as ennis has been very consistent... Most overated will be none other than Jamie Soward.. closely followed by brett white
 
Jamie Soward was really good last year.

Heighington isn't over-rated. He was playing with niggling injuries last year and hopefully he gets more of a rest during games this year so when he is on the field he is more effective and not too tired to do good hitups.
 
Parra are hyped about the return of Tahu - they are already calling for him to be in Origin - well buggered if he is taking Chris Lawrence's spot!

I don't think Tahu is going to have much of an impact…he never really established himself in Yawnion...
 
Gidley - like smeg's said, i just can't see what the hype is about. He's a good solid player, but that's it.

Just quietly, from what i'm reading on this forum i think we might be over-hyping our own team, but i hope not.
 
@Centaur said:
Parra are hyped about the return of Tahu - they are already calling for him to be in Origin - well buggered if he is taking Chris Lawrence's spot!

I don't think Tahu is going to have much of an impact…he never really established himself in Yawnion...
Click to expand...

Never seen Timana Tahu play have you….
 
@Rorko said:
@Centaur said:
Parra are hyped about the return of Tahu - they are already calling for him to be in Origin - well buggered if he is taking Chris Lawrence's spot!

I don't think Tahu is going to have much of an impact…he never really established himself in Yawnion...

Never seen Timana Tahu play have you….
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Well to be fair he was injured alot and rode the pine in Onion for a while so it is possible there is an entire generation who has rarely seen him.

Time will tell if he can cut it in the NRL again
 
would of been able to see him play in the Indigenous team until they rules him not eligiable due to not playing in the NRL yet they let Burgesss play it was great the young chaps got a run though
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Staff online

Members online

Total: 860 (members: 44, guests: 816)
Back
Top