Most over rated player in 2010

  • Thread starter Thread starter summers
  • Start date Start date
@yeenar69 said:
would of been able to see him play in the Indigenous team until they rules him not eligiable due to not playing in the NRL yet they let Burgesss play it was great the young chaps got a run though
Click to expand...

They didn't let Tahu play because in his last game for Parra before jumping ship he picked up a 1 game suspension. That was his game he missed.
 
@Icon said:
Gidley - like smeg's said, i just can't see what the hype is about. He's a good solid player, but that's it.
Click to expand...

Gidley is a solid fullback who can go all day, he doesn't offer anything super, yet there is a belief amongst selectors that he is a utility.
 
@Marshall_magic said:
@Icon said:
Gidley - like smeg's said, i just can't see what the hype is about. He's a good solid player, but that's it.

Gidley is a solid fullback who can go all day, he doesn't offer anything super, yet there is a belief amongst selectors that he is a utility.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

He is a good utility. He should be the NSW number 14.
 
@Rorko said:
@Centaur said:
Parra are hyped about the return of Tahu - they are already calling for him to be in Origin - well buggered if he is taking Chris Lawrence's spot!

I don't think Tahu is going to have much of an impact…he never really established himself in Yawnion...

Never seen Timana Tahu play have you….
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Not recently - spent a lot of time injured or coming off the bench for the Tah's from memory.
 
The Sammut kid from the 'riff: Had hair like a famous boggerballer at one stage and very little else

Check out the new look Sammut in today's Telecrap, hair flowing, porno mo and new tat, trouble is, either 'he' or the 'tat artist' :laughing: can't spell 'existence'.
 
@Marshall_magic said:
Sandow, he's rubbish and will further be shown up for it in 2010.
Click to expand...

Actually i think the opppsite, he has a massive forward pack infront of him this year and i feel he is the sort of player to take full advantage of that.

I think the parra will not be the all conquering behemoth everyone, inthe press that is, wants them to be. If Hayne doesn;t fire they don't the same way we dont if Robbie or Benji don't but they dont have anyone else.

St George will have a good year, but not as good as us.
 
@IronTiger said:
@Marshall_magic said:
Sandow, he's rubbish and will further be shown up for it in 2010.

Actually i think the opppsite, he has a massive forward pack infront of him this year and i feel he is the sort of player to take full advantage of that.

I think the parra will not be the all conquering behemoth everyone, inthe press that is, wants them to be. If Hayne doesn;t fire they don't the same way we dont if Robbie or Benji don't but they dont have anyone else.

St George will have a good year, but not as good as us.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

If Sandow is ordinary again this year he has no place in the NRL. A halves combo of Morris and Fitzhenry would look decent behind that pack.
 
@Zaibatsu said:
I think it will be Israel Folau this season, something tells me he is on the slide.
Click to expand...

He still isn't back to 100% after that injury is he. Thought he was gonna score a run away try in the All Stars game but he just didn't have the pace did he.
 
@alien said:
@Marshall_magic said:
@Icon said:
Gidley - like smeg's said, i just can't see what the hype is about. He's a good solid player, but that's it.

Gidley is a solid fullback who can go all day, he doesn't offer anything super, yet there is a belief amongst selectors that he is a utility.

He is a good utility. He should be the NSW number 14.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Disagree, he offers nothing from the bench, and has never delivered for NSW. His strength in his game is his endurance, which is not utilised from the bench, plus at fullback guys like Hayne and Stewart offer so much more.
 
trent barrett for sure, always has been and always will be over rated
 
After watching the Dragons V Bulldogs game tonight …
How did Darius Boyd ever play Origin AND pull on the green and gold?! He is utter crap.

And don't even get me started on Jamal Idris. He and Tony Williams have the worst defence out of the backs in the game.
 
@hybrid_tiger said:
@smeghead said:
Kurt Gidley - Seriosly what is the hubbub over him. I will never understand it. He is a good utility but no star.

Winner winner.

Except he's not even a utility. That's a myth too.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Well Phil Gould loves him because they brought him in as 18th man when he was Origin coach, Andrew Johns is fanatical about him, no surprises there and he seems to be another of Laurie Daley's favourites as well.

I'd still go:
1\. Ennis
2\. Gidley
3\. Cooper
4\. Idris
5\. Simpson
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 366 (members: 8, guests: 358)
Back
Top