Noddy and The Little General

Demps said:
Sad truth.

He's a machine in cup.
Needs to develope further.
Click to expand...

Love his passion & he is a ranga but if people focused more on his contributions and how he tracks on the park he is well below NRL standard. Would go as far as saying behind Kelma he has been our worst forward this year.
 
Mighty_Tiger said:
Love his passion & he is a ranga but if people focused more on his contributions and how he tracks on the park he is well below NRL standard. Would go as far as saying behind Kelma he has been our worst forward this year.
Click to expand...
He's a prospect.

But you're right, he's way off.

I like him, I wish he could play cup all year with an aim to be ready for grade next year but we're desperate.

As @stryker 69 said... we need players to replace what we're losing and ones that can have a dig.
 
Demps said:
He's a prospect.

But you're right, he's way off.

I like him, I wish he could play cup all year with an aim to be ready for grade next year but we're desperate.

As @stryker 69 said... we need players to replace what we're losing and ones that can have a dig.
Click to expand...

I won’t write him off, his effort is there but this year he is coming last for minutes and meters made out of all players in the NRL & is averaging 31mtrs a game.

Maybe Madge played him wrong no idea, guess we will find out.

Forwards aren’t just tackle machines especially as a backrower/prop.

He hasn’t made 50mtrs in a game this year outside of today when he made 58mtrs, before today he played 3 x 80mins games as well.
 
Mighty_Tiger said:
I won’t write him off, his effort is there but this year he is coming last for minutes and meters made out of all players in the NRL & is averaging 31mtrs a game.

Maybe Madge played him wrong no idea, guess we will find out.

Forwards aren’t just tackle machines especially as a backrower/prop.

He hasn’t made 50mtrs in a game this year outside of today when he made 58mtrs, before today he played 3 x 80mins games as well.
Click to expand...
Clearly not good enough.
The forwards were embarrassing.

Unless we make some further signings there isn't much to look forward to.
 
Demps said:
Brooks is an overwhelming issue with this team.

Today, it was across the board.
Click to expand...
The club has plagued his career turning him into something he is not (an organising half)

Running 5/8 is more his role which was hugely evident next to a dominant voice in Hastings (Atleast in the Parra / south’s games)

Lately it just seems like our forwards have turned to pillows. And no half is going to look good behind forwards that get dominated
 
Speed2burn said:
The club has plagued his career turning him into something he is not (an organising half)

Running 5/8 is more his role which was hugely evident next to a dominant voice in Hastings (Atleast in the Parra / south’s games)

Lately it just seems like our forwards have turned to pillows. And no half is going to look good behind forwards that get dominated
Click to expand...
At one stage today whilst he was still playing 5/8, I looked at the stats. Hastings had run for 117 meters whilst Brooks was on 50. He has to do a lot better to remain the running 5/8 for this squad.
 
stryker 69 said:
At one stage today whilst he was still playing 5/8, I looked at the stats. Hastings had run for 117 meters whilst Brooks was on 50. He has to do a lot better to remain the running 5/8 for this squad.
Click to expand...
Maybe if he didn't have to make twice as many tackles as Hastings he may have, only Liddle and Twal did more tackles than Brooks (for Tigers), our forwards let us down today
 
clokan said:
Maybe if he didn't have to make twice as many tackles as Hastings he may have, only Liddle and Twal did more tackles than Brooks (for Tigers), our forwards let us down today
Click to expand...
That would be true if correct. At that time of the game Brooks had 14 tackles and Hastings 11.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 521 (members: 50, guests: 471)
Back
Top