Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers

Status
Not open for further replies.
@happy_tiger said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505573) said:
@cochise said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505571) said:
@happy_tiger said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505569) said:
@cochise said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505509) said:
@elderslie_tiger said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505507) said:
Oliver Gildart spotted in Cronulla with bulldog Luke Thompson for a catch up and a feed of fish and chips maybe WT'S are still a chance of signing Thompson??????

Thompson is vaxxed now as well, but I think it is just 3 poms catching up.

Does the Vaxx improve them as players ....or is that another Vaxx.....

Thompson needs help

If it means that they are allowed to play then I would see that as an improvement to sitting on the sidelines.

It meant that Thompson isn't that good and hope for his sake the Vaccine makes him a better player

Yeah, I am not really interested in him either.
 
Thompson is very overpaid and has discipline issues (suspensions),seriously don't want him anywhere near our club
 
@jadtiger said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505583) said:
Thompson is very overpaid and has discipline issues (suspensions),seriously don't want him anywhere near our club

Totally agree .....
 
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505558) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505557) said:
@tigerwest said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505524) said:
@glenji95 said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505516) said:
@cochise said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505509) said:
@elderslie_tiger said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505507) said:
Oliver Gildart spotted in Cronulla with bulldog Luke Thompson for a catch up and a feed of fish and chips maybe WT'S are still a chance of signing Thompson??????

Thompson is vaxxed now as well, but I think it is just 3 poms catching up.

Maybe but if we have managed to sign Hodgson I won’t be surprised if we do make an attempt Liddle is on the outer as we all know Simpkin is the clubs next long term Hooker and Bulldogs do need a Hooker so maybe just maybe we might try and work something out or as you said it could just be pommies catching up

Has the “Liddell trying to undermine Madge”, got any legs?

I thought Madge has done a lot for him, when maybe other wouldn’t have.

Liddle would have to be idiot if he doesn’t see the writing is on the wall.

We have Simpkin and Tannous plying their trade in the lower grade’s plus the whispers for Hodgson are getting louder.

If it’s true that his undermining Madge he hasn’t got a leg to stand on, this year was his time to shine and own that number 9 jumper and he blew it.

Give Canberra Liddle to sweeten the deal in our favour and get it done. Hodgson would not only be a benefit to WTs but a big benefit more so to Simpkin and Tannous.

How did he blow it? He made 10 line breaks. And again IF it’s true, so you don’t know that is true, but give fuel to a rumour that slander’s him as a destabilising influence anyway. Poor form.

What would you call it Gunner if the WestsTigers are trying to buy a more experience hooker. If the WTs had faith in Liddle as their main stay hooker why are we even contemplating signing Hodgson. I don’t know about you but I would call that a missed opportunity by Liddle.

And I guess if all it takes is 10 line breaks at dummy halve and your content with the basic mistakes Liddle constantly makes at hooker at crucial periods of a game, well, your obviously happy with mediocre dummy halve.

And as for adding fuel to the fire I say pot met kettle.
 
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505591) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505558) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505557) said:
@tigerwest said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505524) said:
@glenji95 said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505516) said:
@cochise said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505509) said:
@elderslie_tiger said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505507) said:
Oliver Gildart spotted in Cronulla with bulldog Luke Thompson for a catch up and a feed of fish and chips maybe WT'S are still a chance of signing Thompson??????

Thompson is vaxxed now as well, but I think it is just 3 poms catching up.

Maybe but if we have managed to sign Hodgson I won’t be surprised if we do make an attempt Liddle is on the outer as we all know Simpkin is the clubs next long term Hooker and Bulldogs do need a Hooker so maybe just maybe we might try and work something out or as you said it could just be pommies catching up

Has the “Liddell trying to undermine Madge”, got any legs?

I thought Madge has done a lot for him, when maybe other wouldn’t have.

Liddle would have to be idiot if he doesn’t see the writing is on the wall.

We have Simpkin and Tannous plying their trade in the lower grade’s plus the whispers for Hodgson are getting louder.

If it’s true that his undermining Madge he hasn’t got a leg to stand on, this year was his time to shine and own that number 9 jumper and he blew it.

Give Canberra Liddle to sweeten the deal in our favour and get it done. Hodgson would not only be a benefit to WTs but a big benefit more so to Simpkin and Tannous.

How did he blow it? He made 10 line breaks. And again IF it’s true, so you don’t know that is true, but give fuel to a rumour that slander’s him as a destabilising influence anyway. Poor form.

What would you call it Gunner if the WestsTigers are trying to buy a more experience hooker. If the WTs had faith in Liddle as their main stay hooker why are we even contemplating signing Hodgson. I don’t know about you but I would call that a missed opportunity by Liddle.

And I guess if all it takes is 10 line breaks at dummy halve and your content with the basic mistakes Liddle constantly makes at hooker at crucial periods of a game, well, your obviously happy with mediocre dummy halve.

And as for adding fuel to the fire I say pot met kettle.

Why did they re-sign a mediocre hooker for 2 years?
 
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505557) said:
@tigerwest said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505524) said:
@glenji95 said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505516) said:
@cochise said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505509) said:
@elderslie_tiger said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505507) said:
Oliver Gildart spotted in Cronulla with bulldog Luke Thompson for a catch up and a feed of fish and chips maybe WT'S are still a chance of signing Thompson??????

Thompson is vaxxed now as well, but I think it is just 3 poms catching up.

Maybe but if we have managed to sign Hodgson I won’t be surprised if we do make an attempt Liddle is on the outer as we all know Simpkin is the clubs next long term Hooker and Bulldogs do need a Hooker so maybe just maybe we might try and work something out or as you said it could just be pommies catching up

Has the “Liddell trying to undermine Madge”, got any legs?

I thought Madge has done a lot for him, when maybe other wouldn’t have.

Liddle would have to be idiot if he doesn’t see the writing is on the wall.

We have Simpkin and Tannous plying their trade in the lower grade’s plus the whispers for Hodgson are getting louder.

If it’s true that his undermining Madge he hasn’t got a leg to stand on, this year was his time to shine and own that number 9 jumper and he blew it.

Give Canberra Liddle to sweeten the deal in our favour and get it done. Hodgson would not only be a benefit to WTs but a big benefit more so to Simpkin and Tannous.

With Liddle’s speed I could see him being a handy 14 playing a bit of back row ala McInnes. I also think that’s Peachey’s best role so it’ll be interesting to see what happens if we get Hodgo.
 
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505595) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505591) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505558) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505557) said:
@tigerwest said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505524) said:
@glenji95 said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505516) said:
@cochise said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505509) said:
@elderslie_tiger said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505507) said:
Oliver Gildart spotted in Cronulla with bulldog Luke Thompson for a catch up and a feed of fish and chips maybe WT'S are still a chance of signing Thompson??????

Thompson is vaxxed now as well, but I think it is just 3 poms catching up.

Maybe but if we have managed to sign Hodgson I won’t be surprised if we do make an attempt Liddle is on the outer as we all know Simpkin is the clubs next long term Hooker and Bulldogs do need a Hooker so maybe just maybe we might try and work something out or as you said it could just be pommies catching up

Has the “Liddell trying to undermine Madge”, got any legs?

I thought Madge has done a lot for him, when maybe other wouldn’t have.

Liddle would have to be idiot if he doesn’t see the writing is on the wall.

We have Simpkin and Tannous plying their trade in the lower grade’s plus the whispers for Hodgson are getting louder.

If it’s true that his undermining Madge he hasn’t got a leg to stand on, this year was his time to shine and own that number 9 jumper and he blew it.

Give Canberra Liddle to sweeten the deal in our favour and get it done. Hodgson would not only be a benefit to WTs but a big benefit more so to Simpkin and Tannous.

How did he blow it? He made 10 line breaks. And again IF it’s true, so you don’t know that is true, but give fuel to a rumour that slander’s him as a destabilising influence anyway. Poor form.

What would you call it Gunner if the WestsTigers are trying to buy a more experience hooker. If the WTs had faith in Liddle as their main stay hooker why are we even contemplating signing Hodgson. I don’t know about you but I would call that a missed opportunity by Liddle.

And I guess if all it takes is 10 line breaks at dummy halve and your content with the basic mistakes Liddle constantly makes at hooker at crucial periods of a game, well, your obviously happy with mediocre dummy halve.

And as for adding fuel to the fire I say pot met kettle.

Why did they re-sign a mediocre hooker for 2 years?

Tim sheen’s and crew are probably asking the same thing.
 
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505600) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505595) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505591) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505558) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505557) said:
@tigerwest said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505524) said:
@glenji95 said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505516) said:
@cochise said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505509) said:
@elderslie_tiger said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505507) said:
Oliver Gildart spotted in Cronulla with bulldog Luke Thompson for a catch up and a feed of fish and chips maybe WT'S are still a chance of signing Thompson??????

Thompson is vaxxed now as well, but I think it is just 3 poms catching up.

Maybe but if we have managed to sign Hodgson I won’t be surprised if we do make an attempt Liddle is on the outer as we all know Simpkin is the clubs next long term Hooker and Bulldogs do need a Hooker so maybe just maybe we might try and work something out or as you said it could just be pommies catching up

Has the “Liddell trying to undermine Madge”, got any legs?

I thought Madge has done a lot for him, when maybe other wouldn’t have.

Liddle would have to be idiot if he doesn’t see the writing is on the wall.

We have Simpkin and Tannous plying their trade in the lower grade’s plus the whispers for Hodgson are getting louder.

If it’s true that his undermining Madge he hasn’t got a leg to stand on, this year was his time to shine and own that number 9 jumper and he blew it.

Give Canberra Liddle to sweeten the deal in our favour and get it done. Hodgson would not only be a benefit to WTs but a big benefit more so to Simpkin and Tannous.

How did he blow it? He made 10 line breaks. And again IF it’s true, so you don’t know that is true, but give fuel to a rumour that slander’s him as a destabilising influence anyway. Poor form.

What would you call it Gunner if the WestsTigers are trying to buy a more experience hooker. If the WTs had faith in Liddle as their main stay hooker why are we even contemplating signing Hodgson. I don’t know about you but I would call that a missed opportunity by Liddle.

And I guess if all it takes is 10 line breaks at dummy halve and your content with the basic mistakes Liddle constantly makes at hooker at crucial periods of a game, well, your obviously happy with mediocre dummy halve.

And as for adding fuel to the fire I say pot met kettle.

Why did they re-sign a mediocre hooker for 2 years?

Tim sheen’s and crew are probably asking the same thing.

Or maybe not.
 
@bagnf05 said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505596) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505557) said:
@tigerwest said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505524) said:
@glenji95 said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505516) said:
@cochise said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505509) said:
@elderslie_tiger said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505507) said:
Oliver Gildart spotted in Cronulla with bulldog Luke Thompson for a catch up and a feed of fish and chips maybe WT'S are still a chance of signing Thompson??????

Thompson is vaxxed now as well, but I think it is just 3 poms catching up.

Maybe but if we have managed to sign Hodgson I won’t be surprised if we do make an attempt Liddle is on the outer as we all know Simpkin is the clubs next long term Hooker and Bulldogs do need a Hooker so maybe just maybe we might try and work something out or as you said it could just be pommies catching up

Has the “Liddell trying to undermine Madge”, got any legs?

I thought Madge has done a lot for him, when maybe other wouldn’t have.

Liddle would have to be idiot if he doesn’t see the writing is on the wall.

We have Simpkin and Tannous plying their trade in the lower grade’s plus the whispers for Hodgson are getting louder.

If it’s true that his undermining Madge he hasn’t got a leg to stand on, this year was his time to shine and own that number 9 jumper and he blew it.

Give Canberra Liddle to sweeten the deal in our favour and get it done. Hodgson would not only be a benefit to WTs but a big benefit more so to Simpkin and Tannous.

With Liddle’s speed I could see him being a handy 14 playing a bit of back row ala McInnes. I also think that’s Peachey’s best role so it’ll be interesting to see what happens if we get Hodgo.

If we do get Hodgson my guess is Liddle or Simpkin on the bench and when they come on Hodgson will either come off or go to Lock and Peachy comes off that’s how I see it
 
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505604) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505600) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505595) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505591) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505558) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505557) said:
@tigerwest said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505524) said:
@glenji95 said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505516) said:
@cochise said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505509) said:
@elderslie_tiger said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505507) said:
Oliver Gildart spotted in Cronulla with bulldog Luke Thompson for a catch up and a feed of fish and chips maybe WT'S are still a chance of signing Thompson??????

Thompson is vaxxed now as well, but I think it is just 3 poms catching up.

Maybe but if we have managed to sign Hodgson I won’t be surprised if we do make an attempt Liddle is on the outer as we all know Simpkin is the clubs next long term Hooker and Bulldogs do need a Hooker so maybe just maybe we might try and work something out or as you said it could just be pommies catching up

Has the “Liddell trying to undermine Madge”, got any legs?

I thought Madge has done a lot for him, when maybe other wouldn’t have.

Liddle would have to be idiot if he doesn’t see the writing is on the wall.

We have Simpkin and Tannous plying their trade in the lower grade’s plus the whispers for Hodgson are getting louder.

If it’s true that his undermining Madge he hasn’t got a leg to stand on, this year was his time to shine and own that number 9 jumper and he blew it.

Give Canberra Liddle to sweeten the deal in our favour and get it done. Hodgson would not only be a benefit to WTs but a big benefit more so to Simpkin and Tannous.

How did he blow it? He made 10 line breaks. And again IF it’s true, so you don’t know that is true, but give fuel to a rumour that slander’s him as a destabilising influence anyway. Poor form.

What would you call it Gunner if the WestsTigers are trying to buy a more experience hooker. If the WTs had faith in Liddle as their main stay hooker why are we even contemplating signing Hodgson. I don’t know about you but I would call that a missed opportunity by Liddle.

And I guess if all it takes is 10 line breaks at dummy halve and your content with the basic mistakes Liddle constantly makes at hooker at crucial periods of a game, well, your obviously happy with mediocre dummy halve.

And as for adding fuel to the fire I say pot met kettle.

Why did they re-sign a mediocre hooker for 2 years?

Tim sheen’s and crew are probably asking the same thing.

Or maybe not.

Hypothetically, where do you think it will leave Liddle, if let’s say we do sign Josh for 2 years and we have 2 promising Hookers in Simpkin and Tannous.

Would you say as a business you would put your time and effort into Simpkin and Tannous or Liddle?
 
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505613) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505604) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505600) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505595) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505591) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505558) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505557) said:
@tigerwest said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505524) said:
@glenji95 said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505516) said:
@cochise said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505509) said:
@elderslie_tiger said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505507) said:
Oliver Gildart spotted in Cronulla with bulldog Luke Thompson for a catch up and a feed of fish and chips maybe WT'S are still a chance of signing Thompson??????

Thompson is vaxxed now as well, but I think it is just 3 poms catching up.

Maybe but if we have managed to sign Hodgson I won’t be surprised if we do make an attempt Liddle is on the outer as we all know Simpkin is the clubs next long term Hooker and Bulldogs do need a Hooker so maybe just maybe we might try and work something out or as you said it could just be pommies catching up

Has the “Liddell trying to undermine Madge”, got any legs?

I thought Madge has done a lot for him, when maybe other wouldn’t have.

Liddle would have to be idiot if he doesn’t see the writing is on the wall.

We have Simpkin and Tannous plying their trade in the lower grade’s plus the whispers for Hodgson are getting louder.

If it’s true that his undermining Madge he hasn’t got a leg to stand on, this year was his time to shine and own that number 9 jumper and he blew it.

Give Canberra Liddle to sweeten the deal in our favour and get it done. Hodgson would not only be a benefit to WTs but a big benefit more so to Simpkin and Tannous.

How did he blow it? He made 10 line breaks. And again IF it’s true, so you don’t know that is true, but give fuel to a rumour that slander’s him as a destabilising influence anyway. Poor form.

What would you call it Gunner if the WestsTigers are trying to buy a more experience hooker. If the WTs had faith in Liddle as their main stay hooker why are we even contemplating signing Hodgson. I don’t know about you but I would call that a missed opportunity by Liddle.

And I guess if all it takes is 10 line breaks at dummy halve and your content with the basic mistakes Liddle constantly makes at hooker at crucial periods of a game, well, your obviously happy with mediocre dummy halve.

And as for adding fuel to the fire I say pot met kettle.

Why did they re-sign a mediocre hooker for 2 years?

Tim sheen’s and crew are probably asking the same thing.

Or maybe not.

Hypothetically, where do you think it will leave Liddle, if let’s say we do sign Josh for 2 years and we have 2 promising Hookers in Simpkin and Tannous.

Would you say as a business you would put your time and effort into Simpkin and Tannous or Liddle?

Tannous is a halfback isn’t he, why is he in the conversation? I don’t mind running with all 3 of Hodgson, Liddle and Simpkin. Simpkin could still ply his trade in KOE for a year. It would be ridiculous to get rid of Liddle, cos if Hodgson goes down, Simpkin is left like a shag on a rock.
 
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505615) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505613) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505604) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505600) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505595) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505591) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505558) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505557) said:
@tigerwest said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505524) said:
@glenji95 said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505516) said:
@cochise said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505509) said:
@elderslie_tiger said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505507) said:
Oliver Gildart spotted in Cronulla with bulldog Luke Thompson for a catch up and a feed of fish and chips maybe WT'S are still a chance of signing Thompson??????

Thompson is vaxxed now as well, but I think it is just 3 poms catching up.

Maybe but if we have managed to sign Hodgson I won’t be surprised if we do make an attempt Liddle is on the outer as we all know Simpkin is the clubs next long term Hooker and Bulldogs do need a Hooker so maybe just maybe we might try and work something out or as you said it could just be pommies catching up

Has the “Liddell trying to undermine Madge”, got any legs?

I thought Madge has done a lot for him, when maybe other wouldn’t have.

Liddle would have to be idiot if he doesn’t see the writing is on the wall.

We have Simpkin and Tannous plying their trade in the lower grade’s plus the whispers for Hodgson are getting louder.

If it’s true that his undermining Madge he hasn’t got a leg to stand on, this year was his time to shine and own that number 9 jumper and he blew it.

Give Canberra Liddle to sweeten the deal in our favour and get it done. Hodgson would not only be a benefit to WTs but a big benefit more so to Simpkin and Tannous.

How did he blow it? He made 10 line breaks. And again IF it’s true, so you don’t know that is true, but give fuel to a rumour that slander’s him as a destabilising influence anyway. Poor form.

What would you call it Gunner if the WestsTigers are trying to buy a more experience hooker. If the WTs had faith in Liddle as their main stay hooker why are we even contemplating signing Hodgson. I don’t know about you but I would call that a missed opportunity by Liddle.

And I guess if all it takes is 10 line breaks at dummy halve and your content with the basic mistakes Liddle constantly makes at hooker at crucial periods of a game, well, your obviously happy with mediocre dummy halve.

And as for adding fuel to the fire I say pot met kettle.

Why did they re-sign a mediocre hooker for 2 years?

Tim sheen’s and crew are probably asking the same thing.

Or maybe not.

Hypothetically, where do you think it will leave Liddle, if let’s say we do sign Josh for 2 years and we have 2 promising Hookers in Simpkin and Tannous.

Would you say as a business you would put your time and effort into Simpkin and Tannous or Liddle?

Tannous is a halfback isn’t he, why is he in the conversation? I don’t mind running with all 3 of Hodgson, Liddle and Simpkin. Simpkin could still ply his trade in KOE for a year. It would be ridiculous to get rid of Liddle, cos if Hodgson goes down, Simpkin is left like a shag on a rock.

I think you’ll find his plays both position over his young career.
 
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505617) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505615) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505613) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505604) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505600) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505595) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505591) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505558) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505557) said:
@tigerwest said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505524) said:
@glenji95 said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505516) said:
@cochise said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505509) said:
@elderslie_tiger said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505507) said:
Oliver Gildart spotted in Cronulla with bulldog Luke Thompson for a catch up and a feed of fish and chips maybe WT'S are still a chance of signing Thompson??????

Thompson is vaxxed now as well, but I think it is just 3 poms catching up.

Maybe but if we have managed to sign Hodgson I won’t be surprised if we do make an attempt Liddle is on the outer as we all know Simpkin is the clubs next long term Hooker and Bulldogs do need a Hooker so maybe just maybe we might try and work something out or as you said it could just be pommies catching up

Has the “Liddell trying to undermine Madge”, got any legs?

I thought Madge has done a lot for him, when maybe other wouldn’t have.

Liddle would have to be idiot if he doesn’t see the writing is on the wall.

We have Simpkin and Tannous plying their trade in the lower grade’s plus the whispers for Hodgson are getting louder.

If it’s true that his undermining Madge he hasn’t got a leg to stand on, this year was his time to shine and own that number 9 jumper and he blew it.

Give Canberra Liddle to sweeten the deal in our favour and get it done. Hodgson would not only be a benefit to WTs but a big benefit more so to Simpkin and Tannous.

How did he blow it? He made 10 line breaks. And again IF it’s true, so you don’t know that is true, but give fuel to a rumour that slander’s him as a destabilising influence anyway. Poor form.

What would you call it Gunner if the WestsTigers are trying to buy a more experience hooker. If the WTs had faith in Liddle as their main stay hooker why are we even contemplating signing Hodgson. I don’t know about you but I would call that a missed opportunity by Liddle.

And I guess if all it takes is 10 line breaks at dummy halve and your content with the basic mistakes Liddle constantly makes at hooker at crucial periods of a game, well, your obviously happy with mediocre dummy halve.

And as for adding fuel to the fire I say pot met kettle.

Why did they re-sign a mediocre hooker for 2 years?

Tim sheen’s and crew are probably asking the same thing.

Or maybe not.

Hypothetically, where do you think it will leave Liddle, if let’s say we do sign Josh for 2 years and we have 2 promising Hookers in Simpkin and Tannous.

Would you say as a business you would put your time and effort into Simpkin and Tannous or Liddle?

Tannous is a halfback isn’t he, why is he in the conversation? I don’t mind running with all 3 of Hodgson, Liddle and Simpkin. Simpkin could still ply his trade in KOE for a year. It would be ridiculous to get rid of Liddle, cos if Hodgson goes down, Simpkin is left like a shag on a rock.

I think you’ll find his plays both position over his young career.

He’s miles behind Liddle as a first grade hooker.
 
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505618) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505617) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505615) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505613) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505604) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505600) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505595) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505591) said:
@gnr4life said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505558) said:
@tigerlily said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505557) said:
@tigerwest said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505524) said:
@glenji95 said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505516) said:
@cochise said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505509) said:
@elderslie_tiger said in [Oliver Gildart has agreed to join the WestsTigers](/post/1505507) said:
Oliver Gildart spotted in Cronulla with bulldog Luke Thompson for a catch up and a feed of fish and chips maybe WT'S are still a chance of signing Thompson??????

Thompson is vaxxed now as well, but I think it is just 3 poms catching up.

Maybe but if we have managed to sign Hodgson I won’t be surprised if we do make an attempt Liddle is on the outer as we all know Simpkin is the clubs next long term Hooker and Bulldogs do need a Hooker so maybe just maybe we might try and work something out or as you said it could just be pommies catching up

Has the “Liddell trying to undermine Madge”, got any legs?

I thought Madge has done a lot for him, when maybe other wouldn’t have.

Liddle would have to be idiot if he doesn’t see the writing is on the wall.

We have Simpkin and Tannous plying their trade in the lower grade’s plus the whispers for Hodgson are getting louder.

If it’s true that his undermining Madge he hasn’t got a leg to stand on, this year was his time to shine and own that number 9 jumper and he blew it.

Give Canberra Liddle to sweeten the deal in our favour and get it done. Hodgson would not only be a benefit to WTs but a big benefit more so to Simpkin and Tannous.

How did he blow it? He made 10 line breaks. And again IF it’s true, so you don’t know that is true, but give fuel to a rumour that slander’s him as a destabilising influence anyway. Poor form.

What would you call it Gunner if the WestsTigers are trying to buy a more experience hooker. If the WTs had faith in Liddle as their main stay hooker why are we even contemplating signing Hodgson. I don’t know about you but I would call that a missed opportunity by Liddle.

And I guess if all it takes is 10 line breaks at dummy halve and your content with the basic mistakes Liddle constantly makes at hooker at crucial periods of a game, well, your obviously happy with mediocre dummy halve.

And as for adding fuel to the fire I say pot met kettle.

Why did they re-sign a mediocre hooker for 2 years?

Tim sheen’s and crew are probably asking the same thing.

Or maybe not.

Hypothetically, where do you think it will leave Liddle, if let’s say we do sign Josh for 2 years and we have 2 promising Hookers in Simpkin and Tannous.

Would you say as a business you would put your time and effort into Simpkin and Tannous or Liddle?

Tannous is a halfback isn’t he, why is he in the conversation? I don’t mind running with all 3 of Hodgson, Liddle and Simpkin. Simpkin could still ply his trade in KOE for a year. It would be ridiculous to get rid of Liddle, cos if Hodgson goes down, Simpkin is left like a shag on a rock.

I think you’ll find his plays both position over his young career.

He’s miles behind Liddle as a first grade hooker.

I never said he first grade material at this stage of his career his got a lot to learn before playing in the Nrl.
 
How's my man Oli G going? I haven't seen him in any preseason photos recently.
Training the house down of course..

Actually was at Concord yesterday around 8pm ..there were a few guys still in the Gym.. Gildart was one of them doing extras..which I found interesting..
 
Training the house down of course..

Actually was at Concord yesterday around 8pm ..there were a few guys still in the Gym.. Gildart was one of them doing extras..which I found interesting..
I thought the lads were in terrigal for the week?

Looks like it from Insta
 
Training the house down of course..

Actually was at Concord yesterday around 8pm ..there were a few guys still in the Gym.. Gildart was one of them doing extras..which I found interesting..
Good stuff, I expected nothing less of the soon-to-be-Tigers-legend.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Staff online

Back
Top