Our side over the years

[BenjiMagic96]

If we kept our good players, not signed duds and injuries had not been mean to us, over the past couple of years this is how our side would have looked.

1\. Tedesco
2\. Koroibete
3\. Lawrence
4\. Ayshford
5\. Tuiaki
6\. Marshall
7\. Moltzen
8\. Woods
9\. Farah
10\. Galloway
11\. Pettybourne
12\. BMM
13\. Fulton

14\. Fifita
15\. Gibbs
16\. Dwyer
17\. Halatau

God we can only wish :frowning:

 

[tig_prmz]

i miss taniela the tank tuiaki :frowning:

 

[Joel Helmes]

Every club can do this - it's pointless even thinking about it.

Players come and players go for different reasons, the key is to consistently have the right mix of players.

 

[wests4life987]

if your including Gibbs and Fifita why not include Heighington, Ellis and Beau Ryan ?

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

do we get a glass of wine with this thread.
The reminiscing.

 

[Muffstar]

do we get a glass of wine with this thread.
The reminiscing.

or red cordial for the younger brigade that frequent the forum :slight_smile:

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

sorry Muffstar - the kids are our future.

 

[happy_tiger]

BM96 So you would have Pettybourne over Dwyer

Dwyer would probably be on the verge of SOO had he not been injured

Why not include Scott Prince ,Ben Teo ,Ryan Hoffman , Izzy,Brett Hodgson,Ben Galea and Sam Moa

 

[BenjiMagic96]

BM96 So you would have Pettybourne over Dwyer

Dwyer would probably be on the verge of SOO had he not been injured

Why not include Scott Prince ,Ben Teo ,Ryan Hoffman , Izzy,Brett Hodgson,Ben Galea and Sam Moa

Did not watch footy back in there days at the Tigers and I dont remember Teo as a Tiger don't think I watched in his day either. Too young :stuck_out_tongue: Also what do you mean by Izzy?

 

[pHyR3]

Tedesco over hodgson? Tedesco isn't that great yet, can't even force potters hand over moltzen, nor my hand. I'd pick moltzen as a better fullback than tedesco. Although, I'd pick him as a better winger than teddy too which is why i'd like 1\. Tedesco and 2\. Moltz to help the team and to build for the future.

And, as someone else mentioned Pettybourne over DWYER? he was bloody amazing, saddens me everytime i hear his name how his career ended up… Pettybourne probably wouldnt even be on my bench. even buchanan would be there over him, although that would make it too many props on the side so he's out.

 

[wests4life987]

i was so devastated when i found out simon dwyer would never play again. Anyone remember his hit in the semis in 2010 against roosters probably one of the greatest hits

 

[GNR4LIFE]

i was so devastated when i found out simon dwyer would never play again. **Anyone remember his hit in the semis in 2010 against roosters** probably one of the greatest hits

Are you serious? anyone who doesn't has serious problems

 

[wests4life987]

yea true but then we lost :frowning:

 

[BenjiMagic96]

Tedesco over hodgson? Tedesco isn't that great yet, can't even force potters hand over moltzen, nor my hand. I'd pick moltzen as a better fullback than tedesco. Although, I'd pick him as a better winger than teddy too which is why i'd like 1\. Tedesco and 2\. Moltz to help the team and to build for the future.

And, as someone else mentioned Pettybourne over DWYER? he was bloody amazing, saddens me everytime i hear his name how his career ended up… Pettybourne probably wouldnt even be on my bench. even buchanan would be there over him, although that would make it too many props on the side so he's out.

He is 35…

 

[pHyR3]

Oh, i thought this was like an alltime wests line up. Like, putting in andrew johns, lazarus, that kind of thing. Apologies, figured it was alltime since all time for wests tigers is obviously not very long

 

[GoldXR50Leroy]

if your including Gibbs and Fifita why not include Heighington, Ellis and Beau Ryan ?

Gareth Ellis made his own decision to return to the UK so in the 'what if' subject he is ineligble.

 

[innsaneink]

sorry Muffstar - the kids are our future.

God help us.

 

[kh_canada]

BM96 So you would have Pettybourne over Dwyer

Dwyer would probably be on the verge of SOO had he not been injured

Why not include Scott Prince ,Ben Teo ,Ryan Hoffman , Izzy,Brett Hodgson,Ben Galea and Sam Moa

Did not watch footy back in there days at the Tigers and I dont remember Teo as a Tiger don't think I watched in his day either. Too young :stuck_out_tongue: Also what do you mean by Izzy?

Don;t remember Teo?! He only left us in 08? Signed with Broncs in 09

 

[stryker]

sorry Muffstar - the kids are our future.

God help us.

Doesn't fill one with much confidence does it?

 

[Black_n_White]

BM96 So you would have Pettybourne over Dwyer

Dwyer would probably be on the verge of SOO had he not been injured

Why not include Scott Prince ,Ben Teo ,Ryan Hoffman , Izzy,Brett Hodgson,Ben Galea and Sam Moa

Did not watch footy back in there days at the Tigers and I dont remember Teo as a Tiger don't think I watched in his day either. Too young :stuck_out_tongue: Also what do you mean by Izzy?

Don;t remember Teo?! He only left us in 08? Signed with Broncs in 09

hes has Moltzen at 7, so maybe he honestly doesn't.

Maybe its because Im new here and he hasnt got under my interwebz skin yet, but BM96 seems like a passionate/borderline insane (in the good way) supporter, and good on him. I kind of get a kick out of his threads and his youthful unwavering persistance and passion. BM96, big fan of your work son, keep it up and never let the fire die.