Players you think legitimately suck

Demps

Demps

Moderator
Staff member
Forum Leader
Straight forward thread… **[ LETS KEEP IT CURRENT ]**
I expect Beau Ryan's name to be thrown around,
but I'm going to kick things off with these guys;

Alan Tongue
Jason King
Daniel Mortimer

There would be a lot more, but there is a few to start things off.
#YOUR TURN
 
@Demps said:
Straight forward thread… **[ LETS KEEP IT CURRENT ]**
I expect Beau Ryan's name to be thrown around,
but I'm going to kick things off with these guys;

Alan Tongue
Jason King
Daniel Mortimer

There would be a lot more, but there is a few to start things off.
#YOUR TURN
Click to expand...
 
Luke Burt
Jeff Robson
Andrew McCullough (wouldn't say he sucks but he has a mistake in him)
Dean Collis

id name the Beauster but i think he's gonna get enough mentions as it is
 
I don't think Beau Ryan Sucks - Ill raise my hand as a supporter of Beau.
, and I strongly disagree with Luke Burt - you don't break club records by sucking…

however onto the list.

Shannon McDonnell
Willie Tonga - (selfish selfish player)
Brent Kite
George Rose
Arana Taumata
Daine Laurie
Adrian Purtell
Jarred Croker
Daniel Mortimer
Nathan Hindmarsh
 
@underdog said:
I don't think Beau Ryan Sucks - Ill raise my hand as a supporter of Beau.
, and I strongly disagree with Luke Burt - you don't break club records by sucking…

however onto the list.

Shannon McDonnell
Willie Tonga - (selfish selfish player)
Brent Kite
**George Rose**
Arana Taumata
Daine Laurie
Adrian Purtell
Jarred Croker
Daniel Mortimer
Nathan Hindmarsh
Click to expand...

Can't agree with that, he may not exactly look like the best athlete but he's all heart and passion.
Does his job well consistently, makes the occasional mistake but no way he sucks (In my opinion)
I can agree with you on all the other players except maybe Willie Tonga & Croker is young so he may improve.
 
Honestly mate, Georgie lost me with his giving Cherry Evans a mouthful on the field, that was the sealer for me. Attitude on top of his lack of fitness.

If he was in the tigers pack, he'd be told by Sheens to go lose the weight - much like he did to Fifita, and Rose would be a 100% better player, and prob be SOO material.

You are probably right about Croker though Demps, he is only just out of Toyota Cup by 12 months I suppose… However all he seems to be at Canberra for is kicking goals, getting tackled, and not being able to chase down Daniel Fitzhenry.
 
Personally I dont think that any player who regularly plays first grade sucks. Its an extremely hard way to make a living and with the amount of freaks that I have played with who didnt make the grade I take my hat off to all.

Its only when those who are decent grade players are talked up for rep that I say they dont deserve it.

There are a few NSW reps who I think suck at that level but theres no doubt that they can play the game at first grade level.
 
@stryker said:
Personally I dont think that any player who regularly plays first grade sucks. Its an extremely hard way to make a living and with the amount of freaks that I have played with who didnt make the grade I take my hat off to all.

Its only when those who are decent grade players are talked up for rep that I say they dont deserve it.

There are a few NSW reps who I think suck at that level but theres no doubt that they can play the game at first grade level.
Click to expand...

Wrong thread champ, hahaha.
Of course there is dudes that suck, don't be scared to drop names.

I'd like to add a few more names to the list with;
Mitchell Pearce
Matt Keating
Brett Seymour
 
I'm serious mate.

Whats you criteria for sucking? Theres guys who are aweful in certain positions e.g. Motltz at fullback, Morris at half etc…but in no way do I think that they suck as footballers in general.
 
I agree with Stryker. If you get a start in first grade then you don't suck, according to my criteria– but in the spirit of the thread I'd like to nominate Cameron Smith and Darius Boyd for being straight-up, personality by-pass, grade A dickheads.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 
Ennis- The guy is a disgrace to rugby league. He just sledges other players and gives away penaltys. The truth is enis is only a P away from penis. P-away, ha. Unfortunately only tigers fans realise thia
 
I agree with Stryker, they've all done well to make first grade. I'll list ones that have undeservedly played rep;

- Ennis
- King
- Morris
- Tonga
- Young
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 
@Cultured Bogan said:
I agree with Stryker, they've all done well to make first grade. I'll list ones that have undeservedly played rep;

- Ennis
- King
- Morris
- Tonga
- Young
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
Click to expand...

how about Anasta? IMO opinion how Tim Mannah can be considered 1 of the best props in NSW has me stuffed
 
Well Anasta doesn't actually play origin anymore (until Ricky pulls him out of retirement for game 3) and Mannah has a go, I think they've expected too much of him, especially since Merrin is the only other legitimate prop on the team.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 429 (members: 20, guests: 409)
Back
Top