Random Question - Ellis for NSW????

  • Thread starter Thread starter weewaawomble
  • Start date Start date
W

weewaawomble

Guest
Bit of a random question I know, but I was wondering whether someone could help me out. The question is: could Gareth Ellis play for New South Wales? I know Neville Costigan got selected for Queensland despite being Fijian and I was wondering if there was a residency qualifying period? (117)
 
Highly doubt it simply because if there was such a loop hole, QLD would have exploited that several years ago.
 
I think it has something to do with the period leading into the World Cup. If Gareth, or Benji, in the 18 or so months leading to the next world cup declared they were now eligible for Australia, then they could be picked after that world cup. They couldn't play for their own country for that period, of course. This is how Brad Thorn (Qld, Australia, NZ, All Blacks) could do it a couple of times.

I did hear that the qualifying was in the period before, and I think it was 18 months or something.

I could be nowhere near right, just a vague recollection in my head.

PS: He'd have to change clubs too. Maybe a stint at Manly or Easts would help I'm sure
 
@Chris said:
Highly doubt it simply because if there was such a loop hole, QLD would have exploited that several years ago.
Click to expand...

What are you trying to say Chris
Are you trying to say we bent the rules to suit us :laughing:
Whatever happened to the rule of having Qld refs for NSW games and vice versa
You blokes down south just need to accept it
You don't have the players or the Qld spirit
Be prepared to lose a few more series yet I reckon
 
@happy tiger said:
@Chris said:
Highly doubt it simply because if there was such a loop hole, QLD would have exploited that several years ago.

What are you trying to say Chris
Are you trying to say we bent the rules to suit us :laughing:
Whatever happened to the rule of having Qld refs for NSW games and vice versa
You blokes down south just need to accept it
You don't have the players or the Qld spirit
Be prepared to lose a few more series yet I reckon
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

lol… I'm no where near as confident as you Happy. I cant see us winning next year without Darren Lockyer running the team. I'd go as far to say we may lose 1-2 series before Thurston/Cronk learn to do this...

Either way, I'm certain Gareth Ellis flew via Cairns on his first trip to Australia, so I'll claim him as a Queenslander!!!
 
@Tiger Watto said:
@happy tiger said:
@Chris said:
Highly doubt it simply because if there was such a loop hole, QLD would have exploited that several years ago.

What are you trying to say Chris
Are you trying to say we bent the rules to suit us :laughing:
Whatever happened to the rule of having Qld refs for NSW games and vice versa
You blokes down south just need to accept it
You don't have the players or the Qld spirit
Be prepared to lose a few more series yet I reckon

lol… I'm no where near as confident as you Happy. I cant see us winning next year without Darren Lockyer running the team. I'd go as far to say we may lose 1-2 series before Thurston/Cronk learn to do this...

Either way, I'm certain Gareth Ellis flew via Cairns on his first trip to Australia, so I'll claim him as a Queenslander!!!
Click to expand...
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

Yeah I'm with you Watto he saw a picture of the Great Barrier Reef before the Coathanger so he is a Qlder
Where is Livermore and the late great Ron MacAuliffe to raise a stink :laughing:
 
he is prob more of QLDer than some of the others you have picked in recent times!
Ill never know how Falou qualified as a Qlder!

On Izzy, did he play either HM or SG Ball for Wests?? I know he played in the Campbelltown junio district, remember we went out to watch him play before schoolboys carnival hoping to get the jump on the field, after about 2 minutes we realised he was out of our price range!
 
@Goose said:
he is prob more of QLDer than some of the others you have picked in recent times!
Ill never know how Falou qualified as a Qlder!

On Izzy, did he play either HM or SG Ball for Wests?? I know he played in the Campbelltown junio district, remember we went out to watch him play before schoolboys carnival hoping to get the jump on the field, after about 2 minutes we realised he was out of our price range!
Click to expand...

That's all right they just want to play for the champion state that's all
Don't worry all you Mexicans out there I'm sure you'll win …..................................................................................................................................... eventually
 
Folau was at Westfield Sports High before moving to Logan… I think he was only young, like 13/14 so he possibly missed playing HM or SG?!
 
@Snowy said:
Sorry to say but this thread is stupid!
Click to expand...

Any thread that leads us to talking about Qld's dominance of Origin over the last 6 years can't be stupid
But yes Ellis will never play for NSW and I hope he never wants to either
It would cheapen the value of Test football and could start the beginning of the end for Test football if we allow it to happen which we would be a great shame
 
Speaking of QLD stealing NSW born players, add Sam Thaiday onto the list. 3rd man in was born at Baulkham Hills Hospital and only moved to QLD in his mid teens.
Back on topic, isn't Ellis' partner Aussie? Technically he could apply for citizenship allowing him to play for Aus and NSW. However it will never happen.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
 
@AJ* said:
Speaking of QLD stealing NSW born players, add Sam Thaiday onto the list. 3rd man in was born at Baulkham Hills Hospital and only moved to QLD in his mid teens.
Back on topic, isn't Ellis' partner Aussie? Technically he could apply for citizenship allowing him to play for Aus and NSW. However it will never happen.
\
\
Posted using RoarFEED
Click to expand...

Lets not start this Sterling , was born in Toowomba Kenny Nagas, Peter Dawes blah blah blah
Its not as if there made to play for a state they don't want to
 
@Goose said:
he is prob more of QLDer than some of the others you have picked in recent times!
Ill never know how Falou qualified as a Qlder!

On Izzy, did he play either HM or SG Ball for Wests?? I know he played in the Campbelltown junio district, remember we went out to watch him play before schoolboys carnival hoping to get the jump on the field, after about 2 minutes we realised he was out of our price range!
Click to expand...

Lucky Sticky picked young Hoppa this year, he's doing his Mormon Mission in Qld next year, they'd probably try and claim him upon return.
 
@Marshall_magic said:
@Goose said:
he is prob more of QLDer than some of the others you have picked in recent times!
Ill never know how Falou qualified as a Qlder!

On Izzy, did he play either HM or SG Ball for Wests?? I know he played in the Campbelltown junio district, remember we went out to watch him play before schoolboys carnival hoping to get the jump on the field, after about 2 minutes we realised he was out of our price range!

Lucky Sticky picked young Hoppa this year, he's doing his Mormon Mission in Qld next year, they'd probably try and claim him upon return.
Click to expand...
Click to expand...

What do you mean try ??
He actually coming up here to get a sizing for a jersey
The Mormon mission was just a ploy
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 530 (members: 8, guests: 522)
Back
Top