Joel Helmes
Well-known member
@LaT said:
Nicely said.
Nicely said.
S
system
Guest
@magpiecol said:
The NRL?
Benjirific
New member
@wtfl1981 said:
Despite what you perceive his motivations to be (to be honest I disagree in this regard, but not my point), do you agree with the principle of a structure that sees the club stand alone as a representative of both club's history and future?
tigermaniac
Well-known member
Why didn't he try his best to unify the JV when he had the power, or maybe it wasn't a concern then. Should've, could've, would've but didn't.
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
Gary_Bakerloo
New member
@LaT said:
Fair enough, let's do the following:
1\. Home games
6 x games at SFS
6 x games at Campbelltown
Sufficient exposure in both Sydney and Campbelltown to satisfy growth areas for sponsors. State of the art stadiums with consumer comfort and excellent corporate facilities.
2\. Feature matches
Heritage round: Brisbane (first team we played in 2000)
Rivalry round: St. George-Illawarra or North Qld
I wonder how many would agree to this? Again, many use Wests Tigers and as per your claim to "get on board or get out" when it best suits either Balmain or Western Suburbs.
Hence the language from Trodden.
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
@LaT said:
The thing is, people only tend to ever acknowledge the dinosaurs on ''the other side'' and excuse the ones from the side they use to support. Make no mistake, both sides have them
S
system
Guest
@Gary Bakerloo said:
If we were to do a stadium split which would be best for WT moving forward I would suggest the following
2 x Sunday afternoon @ Leichhardt (ties into nostalgia, satisfies a niche)
3 x SFS (Blockbuster games of larger drawing teams)
3 x Blutongue Stadium ( Best place to allocate some lower named teamms as we have a massive support base on the CC. Would also serve to give a more optioned breakdown of Season Tickets and likely increase our overall count)
4 x CSS. (Derby games where we can. At least one Monday night early in the season as during Daylight Saving it makes attendence from people with younger folk in the area more likely, also maintains our presence in the South West)
S
system
Guest
In fact with the Bluetongue allocation I would play exclusively interstate teams there. Not only would it sell tickets to see stars like Slater, Thurston, Hodges and Taylor but it throws an extra couple of hours in a bus on top of a plane ride which can take a toll
Gary_Bakerloo
New member
@LaT said:
No. I would like to see Leichhardt retain some exposure.
I would however like to see our feature matches move to those indicated above.
WT have 200 years of combined history.. Do we have less rugby league significance than Melbourne Storm? I dont think so…
If we should all 'move on and get over it' ad history and tradition is out the window under a new structure then do we also stop playing at Leichhardt also? Do we stop relying on Ashfield & Campbelltown leagues clubs to back the club financially as they are of Wests Magpies origin? Do we stop wearing victa and philips jerseys as they are linked to balmain & wests?
WT is a business and sporting legacy of Wests & Balmain - thats why it was formed. Even if it reverted to a merged club from top to bottom, the club would need a viable leagues club or private owner behind it. A person or business that has an interest in taking it on. Do we want to be in a newcastle with tinkler situation?
Trodden is a Tigers man from top to bottom.. He wants to see the Tigers brand live on before balmain are declared bankrupt and WT ownership reverts to wests group or a 3rd party private owner.. Highlighting the nsw cup situation as a reason for moving to a merged club is a cover up of the real issue concerning WT - that is the financial demise of Balmain
\
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
If we should all 'move on and get over it' ad history and tradition is out the window under a new structure then do we also stop playing at Leichhardt also? Do we stop relying on Ashfield & Campbelltown leagues clubs to back the club financially as they are of Wests Magpies origin? Do we stop wearing victa and philips jerseys as they are linked to balmain & wests?
WT is a business and sporting legacy of Wests & Balmain - thats why it was formed. Even if it reverted to a merged club from top to bottom, the club would need a viable leagues club or private owner behind it. A person or business that has an interest in taking it on. Do we want to be in a newcastle with tinkler situation?
Trodden is a Tigers man from top to bottom.. He wants to see the Tigers brand live on before balmain are declared bankrupt and WT ownership reverts to wests group or a 3rd party private owner.. Highlighting the nsw cup situation as a reason for moving to a merged club is a cover up of the real issue concerning WT - that is the financial demise of Balmain
\
\
\
_Posted using RoarFEED 2012_
Alright, before this degenerates I'll say that as long as this remains a vigorous debate the thread will stay open.
The minute personal sniping and deliberate trolling takes place, it will be locked.
The minute personal sniping and deliberate trolling takes place, it will be locked.
@wtfl1981 said:
Why would history and tradition go out the window by moving on? The history won't change, what matters is the future.
If angry old men are going to sit back and cry about how this and that are Balmain/Wests influenced decisions everytime something pops up they don't like, things are just going to go round and round in circles.
I will always be a Balmain fan, but I bought my Magpies heritage jersey and wear it proud. I've got nothing against respecting our history, but there is only one way forward.
GNR4LIFE
Well-known member
@Chunk said:
Whats typical is your arrogant pig headed mentality. The only time you ever pop up is to have a dig at the Pies. Its clear you've accepted the JV. 😕
S
system
Guest
If anyone wants to have a discussion about the issue please let me know.
This is going down the usual path of this forum though so I am out.
Enjoy your niggle fest kids
This is going down the usual path of this forum though so I am out.
Enjoy your niggle fest kids
