LIVE GAME Round 25 vs Roosters

[wstigers11]

Looked the best he has in a long time because he actually had room to look threatening... AD cannot be in the halves (if he's here next year)

Agree mate

 

[Tigerstigerstigers]

Really begs the question why Benji was selecting Sione on the edge for so long when Sukkar has shown a few times this year he's more then up to the job.

first time i have noticed our halves giving him the ball. He must have been sick of being decoy runner.

 

[Chunk]

Does Api seem a bit crook to anyone, not quite himself?

 

[king_sirro]

One thing yesterday brought up for me, the quick tap needs to be outlawed. The penalty the Roosters got was a diabolical decision by Klein but we couldn't challenge it because he allowed a quick tap. So as long as the challenge rule exists, the quick tap cant be allowed.

 

[batboy]

One thing yesterday brought up for me, the quick tap needs to be outlawed. The penalty the Roosters got was a diabolical decision by Klein but we couldn't challenge it because he allowed a quick tap. So as long as the challenge rule exists, the quick tap cant be allowed.

Can we challenge the Play / Penalty by holding them down in the tackle for a Penalty / Stoppage?

 

[king_sirro]

Can we challenge the Play / Penalty by holding them down in the tackle for a Penalty / Stoppage?

I think they outlawed that a while ago. I could be wrong but if you give a deliberate penalty away to challenge you get 10 in the bin

 

[NT_Tiger]

I think many of us owe the WTs a massive apology for writing them off so badly
Who else wants to own it
Sorry boys

Yep, I was one. Sorry

 

[Suzie-Q]

Wow! Just watched the replay! Bloody hell!!!

 

[Tigerdazz2]

We're lucky to have him.
There's a player in there.

He cops so much hate but he gets better each year and hes coming into his best.

Big fan

I'd much rather Seyfarth than the soon to become a Bear, Canberra meathead Ranga Corey Horsborogh.

Both have heaps of passion, but I'd have "our" Ranga over the walking brain explosion Ricky will probably be glad to see the arse end of.

 

[Tigerdazz2]

Ok I know we won but those ref calls were a bit sus favouring the chickens.

That "Escort" penalty with a few minutes to go was crap!

Wests Tigers didn't just beat the Roosters, they beat Klein as well.

With Twal out in the first few minutes that meant it was 18 v 16 in their favour.

 

[Tigerdazz2]

Does Api seem a bit crook to anyone, not quite himself?

He's buggered after 80mins of playing out of his skin and copping a nice shiner doing it.

 

[Halbrowne61]

Does Api seem a bit crook to anyone, not quite himself?

Agree C, I’ve thought that for a while, he looks more stuffed than usual but it certainly didn’t stop him playing a real captains knock yesterday.
Maybe it’s just age starting to catch up with him.

 

[TurnStyle]

Surely people are starting to see the value in Seyfarth. Pure commitment - every club has to have effort players he is ours. No world beater but gives it everything.

Yes, I am one of them. For years I thought of him as somewhat of the team numpty and said as much.

You phrased it perfectly: This has been the year he has shown he has true value.

Particularity this last lean trot, when sub-par effort and performance could be more easily deflected, he has actually excelled and shown so much heart.

I was a big Chris Lawrence fan, and the lines Seyfarth has been running have reminded me of the days when rowdy was in the 2nd row.

He has definitely changed my view on him and I hope he gets a realistic salary bump if possible; Because a core aspect of the niche role he plays for the tigers is that they are great value for money.

 

[TigerBurnsy]

Does Api seem a bit crook to anyone, not quite himself?

Probably gassed

 

[TigerBurnsy]

He's buggered after 80mins of playing out of his skin and copping a nice shiner doing it.

I swear he’s had a black eye for a month poor guy

 

[TT 01]

I hope Marshall has a good chat to Saukuru. I know he is young but jogging in defence immediately before the Roosters scored their final try is not on. Robinson would expect significantly more from his debutant and younger players, in fact he'd make it mandatory players demonstrate urgency and desperation in defence to not let your team or team mates down. If it is a fitness issue, he needs to get fitter. If it is an attitudinal issue, he needs to speak with Seyfarth and Twal.

Same with Luai on that play. Did you see he tackled Marky Mark kinda a bit late but then they both got up Mark was straight up and into the play while Luai just walked. Effort there would have stopped the

Luai was back there trying to affect the tackle as he scored

Exactly, if he was two steps further he would have made it

 

[Halbrowne61]

Yes, I am one of them. For years I thought of him as somewhat of the team numpty and said as much.

You phrased it perfectly: This has been the year he has shown he has true value.

Particularity this last lean trot, when sub-par effort and performance could be more easily deflected, he has actually excelled and shown so much heart.

I was a big Chris Lawrence fan, and the lines Seyfarth has been running have reminded me of the days when rowdy was in the 2nd row.

He has definitely changed my view on him and I hope he gets a realistic salary bump if possible; Because a core aspect of the niche role he plays for the tigers is that they are great value for money.

I think he’s worked on his game, eliminated many of the dumb errors and happy to do the hard yards/tackling.
Good team player.

 

[TT 01]

Agree C, I’ve thought that for a while, he looks more stuffed than usual but it certainly didn’t stop him playing a real captains knock yesterday.
Maybe it’s just age starting to catch up with him.

Benji needs to next year really manage the minutes of the him and Terrel to get the most out of them. They have both looked cooked at different times this year

 

[Dr_Ice]

Funny game NRL.

While we all thinking why couldnt we play like we did yesterday against parra and saints....roosters fans are thinking this morning why couldnt they have played like they did against the cowboys, against us

The beauty of sport eh

The best reality TV show

 

[innsaneink]

Same with Luai on that play. Did you see he tackled Marky Mark kinda a bit late but then they both got up Mark was straight up and into the play while Luai just walked. Effort there would have stopped the

Exactly, if he was two steps further he would have made it

Gawd
Some.players are quicker than others
You said he was walking...thats BS