@mighty_tiger said in [Seibold's Analysis](/post/1316469) said:
When Mbye was playing center his defence was great and he nearly had me convinced that center was his future position.
If BJ keeps stuffing up wouldn’t hesitate and put Mbye in over BJ.
yep 100%
I still think 5/8 is Mbye's best position. The trouble is his kicking game has sufferred since he hasn't played in that position for 5 years. Same with Douehi, he can do those magical bombs but his kicking won't be amazing as he hasn't done regular kicking in top grade.
Mbye's eternal problem - doesn't excel in any one position where we don't have a superior option. His defence is always decent, he's fast, he makes 1-1 tackles. He just hasn't been able to claim a position long-term as his own.
I actually think Mbye is a pretty decent fullback, but I also think Daine Laurie has shown more ability in 2 matches.
He's not blameless but we have had to stuff him around a bit. He came to us as a fullback but got injured early on and we decided to go with Thompson at fullback and stuck him at centre. He wasn't hopeless though as he ended up making Origin. Last year, he trained entire pre-season at hooker but then Harry Grant came through and he kept switching between centre/fullback with AD. Now this year, he has trained the entire pre-season at fullback but Laurie deservedly has been given the first shot.
We can't blame any of this on lack of professionalism or bad attitude at training because clearly Maguire was impressed enough to make him captain. He has never let us down in defence no matter the position. He is usually mistake free in attack but has never been given time to make combinations with any player.
And he hasn't complained, still kept plugging away and trained hard. I hope he makes a position his own this year as I have a bit of respect for this guy. And I hope no one brings his salary into the conversation.