Should Brooks be NSW 7?

Status
Not open for further replies.
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
How people are saying Blake Green is beyond me

And then using the excuse for Brooks that he can’t be picked on 6 good games

That same excuse falls into Green just as much

Rubbish. Green was good for Manly last year too. ( Not that im suggesting Green be picked). Listen to Mitch Pearce, he has always struggled for NSW and freely admits to being picked too early. We're not talking about coming into a side that has won so many series out of the last 11 or 12, we are talking about a side and state that is desperate, and that brings enormous pressure on the halfback and 5/8\. Pressure that would be unfair to place on Brooks at this point in his career given what he has achieved thus far.

Blake Green was nowhere near good enough for origin contention, but then plays 5-6 good games and all of a sudden should be picked

You’d be silly to say otherwise

Read my post again. Not sure where i said he should be picked for Origin. But for you to suggest Green has only had 5 or 6 good games is absolute crap.

Well then you must’ve read my post wrong at the start, I was referring to Green playing 5-6 good games and all of a sudden should be picked

Never said he was bad beforehand but certainly no where near good enough to be talked about as an origin bolter

I still don’t rate the kid….. just my opinion anyway

When the Warriors hit that form slump they usually do you’ll agree with me when he goes missing
 
@ said:
It's more about combos. I think you have to pick Maloney at 7\. At this stage it would be what six is best next to him.
I don't think Maloney and Brooks would work. Similar to Maloney and Cleary hasn't been that good.

Well here are all the options in order if I was the selector:

6\. Maloney
7\. Brooks

6\. Keary
7\. Maloney

6\. Green
7\. Maloney

6\. Gutherson
7\. Maloney

6\. Peachey
7\. Maloney

6\. Bird
7\. Maloney

6\. Maloney
7\. Pearce

6\. Moylan
7\. Maloney
 
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
@ said:
Rubbish. Green was good for Manly last year too. ( Not that im suggesting Green be picked). Listen to Mitch Pearce, he has always struggled for NSW and freely admits to being picked too early. We're not talking about coming into a side that has won so many series out of the last 11 or 12, we are talking about a side and state that is desperate, and that brings enormous pressure on the halfback and 5/8\. Pressure that would be unfair to place on Brooks at this point in his career given what he has achieved thus far.

Blake Green was nowhere near good enough for origin contention, but then plays 5-6 good games and all of a sudden should be picked

You’d be silly to say otherwise

Read my post again. Not sure where i said he should be picked for Origin. But for you to suggest Green has only had 5 or 6 good games is absolute crap.

Well then you must’ve read my post wrong at the start, I was referring to Green playing 5-6 good games and all of a sudden should be picked

Never said he was bad beforehand but certainly no where near good enough to be talked about as an origin bolter

I still don’t rate the kid….. just my opinion anyway

When the Warriors hit that form slump they usually do you’ll agree with me when he goes missing

All good my man, we shall see.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top