Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

Halbrowne61 said:
You don’t actually think that Crichton would want to come to us do you ?
His future is sorted in Rugby( also where his heart really is from what I’ve heard ).
Click to expand...
I don't want us to go near him. No idea if he would want to remain in Sydney and play NRL...
He probably wants Rugby and Rugby probably want NRL players... Don't know, nor care.

We need good attitude and we need bankable. Crichton isn't that at the moment. Infact we need to sign next to no one, we have no idea where Benji needs to inject talent and who will stand up and who will stand down.

I still don't know if our Halves, Backs or forwards will choke.
 
JB9918 said:
Pearce went to North Shore. Played him in high school MCC. Him & Foran were the halves from year 10 to 12. In year 10 they have a bloke on the wing called Matt Shirvington. They were unstoppable.
Click to expand...
That can't quite be right because Shirvo was the year ahead of me at school and that makes him about 10 years older than Mitchell Pearce.

I saw Mitchell play the MCC Grand Final one year but I'm pretty sure the match I saw his halves partner was Liam Foran rather than Kieran. At that time the thought was Liam was a very good chance of a first-grade career.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 851
bptiger 0 said:
Word is that Bevan French will return to the NRL next year , this is one player we should nail down NOW , must on here complain about no x- factor in our backs , well this bloke covers it all , benji and Richo get on to this
Click to expand...
I have continuous worry that Bevan French cannot recapture his ESL form in the NRL. He was custard when he left the NRL, just physically found out all the time, and the transition back to NRL is so difficult; so few players make it back.
 
Todd Packer said:
Penrith say hello.........twice.
Click to expand...
2x ambushes on a trial-season Penrith. Good luck to St Helens and Wigan for playing huge games and getting up for the challenge, but both clubs would be destroyed attempting to play NRL week in and out.

Even 2023 season Penrith opened with 4 wins 4 losses, including the loss to us, but got it together end of season to only lose 2 of the last 19 matches including the GF. In other words - Penrith only lost 2 more matches after losing to us in Rd 9 in rainy Bathurst.
 
GCfan said:
I’ve got this feeling that anyone with a different opinion to you makes you feel insecure and you resort to personal jabs, but that’s just my opinion (insert smart ass meme here)
Click to expand...
I don't have opinions on this non-issue - I don't read crystal balls or make hot take negative predictions with nothing but a "gut feeling" to go on - and I see through GNR's trolling modus operandi.

Bateman is signed for three more years - I have no opinion on whether he will see out that contract.

So how did I express a "different opinion"?

Learn to read - you are the reason people need to communicate with memes!
 
Snidest 0 said:
I don't have opinions on this non-issue - I don't read crystal balls or make hot take negative predictions with nothing but a "gut feeling" to go on - and I see through GNR's trolling modus operandi.

Bateman is signed for three more years - I have no opinion on whether he will see out that contract.

So how did I express a "different opinion"?

Learn to read - you are the reason people need to communicate with memes!
Click to expand...
Sorry my English isn’t that good.
I thought you calling out GNR was because you didn’t agree with his view that Bateman won’t see out his contract here, that’s why I assumed you had a different view / belief / thought / opinion or whatever the correct word is on the topic.
 
Jedi_Tiger said:
Bateman bailed in his Canberra contract ... has done it before
Click to expand...

Didn't we pay to get him out of his contract to come here?
Didn't the Raiders pay to get him out of his contract to Aus come originally?

It's hardly speculation when he's dipped on his last 3 contracts?
Moreso, Just the way it goes....
 
batboy said:
Didn't we pay to get him out of his contract to come here?
Didn't the Raiders pay to get him out of his contract to Aus come originally?

It's hardly speculation when he's dipped on his last 3 contracts?
Moreso, Just the way it goes....
Click to expand...
Exactly. Not sure why all the pearl clutching over that scenario.
 
Snidest 0 said:
But why speculate?

That had nothing to do with on-field success - but more to do with his personal family situation and Canberra being a crappy place to live...
Click to expand...

Canberra is a paradise compared to the north of England,the family situation is another matter which i understand
 
jirskyr said:
That can't quite be right because Shirvo was the year ahead of me at school and that makes him about 10 years older than Mitchell Pearce.

I saw Mitchell play the MCC Grand Final one year but I'm pretty sure the match I saw his halves partner was Liam Foran rather than Kieran. At that time the thought was Liam was a very good chance of a first-grade career.
Click to expand...
Pearce 34 yold Shirvo 45 yold.
 
jirskyr said:
That can't quite be right because Shirvo was the year ahead of me at school and that makes him about 10 years older than Mitchell Pearce.

I saw Mitchell play the MCC Grand Final one year but I'm pretty sure the match I saw his halves partner was Liam Foran rather than Kieran. At that time the thought was Liam was a very good chance of a first-grade career.
Click to expand...

Its obviously a different Matt Shirvington with some speed who played sports
😂😂😂
 
jirskyr said:
2x ambushes on a trial-season Penrith. Good luck to St Helens and Wigan for playing huge games and getting up for the challenge, but both clubs would be destroyed attempting to play NRL week in and out.

Even 2023 season Penrith opened with 4 wins 4 losses, including the loss to us, but got it together end of season to only lose 2 of the last 19 matches including the GF. In other words - Penrith only lost 2 more matches after losing to us in Rd 9 in rainy Bathurst.
Click to expand...
Have to agree completely with the points that you have made and then add to that some dubious on field decisions.

Not in the habit of going in to bat for the 'Riff because I don't mind them losing especially with the gutsy display Wigan put on but I think Brian To'o got it right with respect to that Wigan try that was awarded.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Latest posts

Members online

Total: 281 (members: 18, guests: 263)
Back
Top