Signings, Suggestions & Rumours Discussion

[BZN]

Was Gardiner good?

I seem to recall we had:
Madge
Gardiner
Nathan Cayless

and we came last. I mean that's great coaching, you know to move a side that is near the bottom of the ladder to dead set last.

From memory Gardiner was very good when he was our NSW Cup coach for a short time.
When Madge was moved on, he apparently got the flick as well which was a real pity.

 

[Coastie_Tiger]

Has anyone else heard lodge will be here in 2025?

No but it wouldn't be unrealistic, I doubt anyone is still here from his previous time here. I would assume we need to move a few on first before making anymore signings, unless of course we go down the Gus road and sign them first and move on later. Leaves your hand a bit weak though imo.

 

[weststigerman]

I guess Lodge has been to nearly every club now and needs to go back to the beginning. He's skipped Melbourne Storm (or they skipped him)!

 

[Modman]

No. But it said are the people on this thread should be taking some.

Lol. You mean stop taking them. So today its Haas , yesterday To'o . day before Cobbo. Surely were not getting a 4 spoon with so many rep players coming.
Putting Mushrooms aside reality we wont get any of them.

 

[clontarfkid]

Kobe hetherington news about visiting COE etc that's about it

Not exactly a replacement for the 3 representative forwards weve just lost
Potental yes..but cant make the Broncos starting 13
Not a huge step forward..unfortunately

 

[Betterdays22]

I guess Lodge has been to nearly every club now and needs to go back to the beginning. He's skipped Melbourne Storm (or they skipped him)!

Pretty sure he did toyota cup with Melbourne. I remember a story at the time that he "asked" Bellamy to meet him in the carpark

 

[weststigerman]

Pretty sure he did toyota cup with Melbourne. I remember a story at the time that he "asked" Bellamy to meet him in the carpark

Yeah that's what I meant when I said he skipped Melbourne. That's where he started.

 

[clontarfkid]

Not a fan of jobs for the old boys, but Hodgson is the one bloke with actual coaching experience, including head coach in Super League and assistant with the Wallabies. To be honest he would have been better than Benji.

Nup..its repeating the Benji mistake of promoting admired ex Tiger players who have absolutely no coaching track record
Nepotism/desperation/seeking a short term publicity sugar hit...but nothing else
Big mistake

 

[clontarfkid]

800K... WOW!!! that's gotta buy a lot of lattes on the high falutin Balmain/Rozelle coffee strip.
And I hope those coffees help him to perform at a higher level in '25 to show us he is worth the $$$ he is being paid.

Doubt hes on anything like $800k..tho this is the West Tigers!!

 

[Wildcat777]

One thing for certain is the introduction of any new franchises will send players asking price through the roof.
So now is the time to stitch up any elite signings. We need to get our kids signed up to.

Can’t see Galvin going to PNG but he will be able to use them to inflate his next deal. It’s going to be like the super league war again where players will hold the whip

Don’t forget PNG is team 19. Let’s not forget about team 18. Western Bears. Possibility?

 

[mtd#2]

I’ve had confirmation from a family source that To’o is a Tiger in 2025! Kobe Hetherington is also locked in🔥🤝

Penrith have openly stated they won't let to'o leave until the end of his contract which is the end of 2025. So maybe we take him for 2026.

 

[AmericanHistoryX]

What about the people doing it tough here? Couldn't that money be used to help them. Help your family

 

[mtd#2]

Lol. You mean stop taking them. So today its Haas , yesterday To'o . day before Cobbo. Surely were not getting a 4 spoon with so many rep players coming.
Putting Mushrooms aside reality we wont get any of them.

Maybe by taking mushrooms it sends him to another reality where all these signings happen

 

[mtd#2]

Not exactly a replacement for the 3 representative forwards weve just lost
Potental yes..but cant make the Broncos starting 13
Not a huge step forward..unfortunately

"3 representative forwards"...
It's a great sales pitch.
But in reality they weren't representative forwards when they pulled on the Wests Tigers jersey.
So I don't buy it.
The replacements will probably be better on the field wearing the wests tigers than those 3 ever were.

 

[BZN]

Fanta? I didn't know you were 12 and it's 1985

I purchased a pineapple Fanta from the Kempsey Service Centre yesterday, and I noticed the place that sold all the pies sold 'crocodile pies'...but I forgot to ask if they sold 'Crocodile Rolls' haha.
If they do maybe they can be our major sponsor haha.

 

[Tiger_Yoshi]

I’ve had confirmation from a family source that To’o is a Tiger in 2025! Kobe Hetherington is also locked in🔥🤝

I’ve had confirmation from a family source that To’o is a Tiger in 2025! Kobe Hetherington is also locked in🔥🤝

I bet you $100 they aren’t…are you on?

 

[bigsiro]

I could think of better ways to spend 2 million bucks....

Classic Tigers forum.
Poo-pooing even the idea of Haas, the best prop in the game by a mile.
And some say we shouldn’t spend on To’o either. The best winger in the game.

Crikey.

 

[Kelce68]

I said 3 coaches - You can count right?
Before this 'plan' took off
1 - Benji
2 - Farah
3 - Heighno
had zero games coaching experience at senior level. (Any level really)

Compared to that, Make Hodgo look like Wayne Bennett

Ah, ignore the main assistant because it doesn't fit your narrative.

Got it.

 

[tigermate]

why is everyone still defending benji --

2 wooden spoons

never coached before

IMAGINE -- if it wasnt Benji but someone else, like John Skandalis or Pat Richards who was the coach.

Both never coached before, both 2005 Wests Tigers champions.

And then they win the wooden spoon twice in a row.

Everyone would be going MENTAL.

Ahhhh the Benji factor hey. Hard to see past.

 

[BZN]

Classic Tigers forum.
Poo-pooing even the idea of Haas, the best prop in the game by a mile.
And some say we shouldn’t spend on To’o either. The best winger in the game.

Crikey.

I don't think anyone is poo-pooing the idea bigsiro, just doubting a player of his caliber would end up playing for us.